PEER-REVIEW  INSTRUCTIONS

Read the papers sent to you and provide a peer-review for the authors. Write a formal text based on
the structure below.  Each argument in your text should be supported by evidence and some
recommendation where possible.


CONTENT

1. Adequate topic coverage

2. Relevance, importance, credibility and strength of ideas/arguments

3. Author´s contribution


ORGANIZATION

1. Arrangement of ideas (clear, structured, easy to follow)

2. Paragraph quality

3. Signposting/Guiding the reader


STYLE

1. Clarity

2. Coherence

3. Formality

4. Referencing


MECHANICS:

1. Spelling

2. Grammar

3. Punctuation


OVERALL EFFECTIVENESS / IMPRESSION