^f . 'Scientists E- USE/ Scholarly Publishing lift ■ v Assessment, Indicators & Visibility M§n Michal Petr Research Office Masaryk university Žerotínovo náměstí 9, 601 77 Brno Tel. 549 49 5887 petr@rect.muni.cz Publish or Perish dilemma Keynotes Self-promotion game • Make your research public and visible! Create your own identifier, join the social networks, promote yourself Your role in the czech national assessment • Responsibility - have a complete and correct list of publications (Information System MU) Research Assessment (in a Nutshell) • Evaluated unit-you! Make the metrics familiar Self-presentation at MU ResearcherlD profiles with affiliation to MU: ca 800 (including students) Self-presentation in the university campus (CEITEC, F. of Sport Studies, Medical R, F. of Science, 511 respondents): 10 Not registered anywhere ResearchGate Linkedln ResearchID Academia.edu 4,5 ORCID I 4,1 Other | 0,8 COS Scholar Universe I 0,2 20 30 40 50 60 70 63,6 Why should I care about my online presentation? • To make your research and teaching activities known • To increase the chance of publications getting cited • To increase the chance of new contacts for research cooperation • To increase the chance of funding • To correct attribution, names and affiliations • To make sure that a much as possible is counted in research assessment 5 Researcher's Ecosystem Affiliation Employment (organisational) Education Qualification Application Funding (administrative) Output Publications, Patents (cognitive) Problem... Variant 1 Variant 2 Variant 3 Umlaut Glänzel Glanzel Glaenzel Transliteration 3E1H Wang, Y Name particles Van De Broek, I Broek, I Vande / Broek, IV Vandebroek, I Initials Wem ans, Andre Wemans, ADV Wemans, A Name change Petre, Camelia Stanciu, Camelia Camelia, Stanciu Database VANRAAN, AFJ VanRaan, AFJ Van Raan, AFJ Source: W. Glanzel, 2015 • Affiliation changes, missing affiliation • Frequent names • Common errors 7 Personal Digital Identifiers Administrative burden? NO! • Linking researchers and their work accross databases • Unambiguous identification in case of different name and affiliation variants History of publication profile independent on the actual affiliation/employer Statistical and bibliometric functions (cooperation, citation networks) Export functions (lists of publication); import functions (from citation managers) Are to be combined; data migration Identifiers used specifically by the database Scopus Author Identifier • vedidk(ISR&D&l) Help: http://vvzkum.rect.muni.cz/cs/evaluace-vvzkumu/vedecke-vvstupv (in Czech) Universal identifier does not exist yet RESEARCHERID ORCID (Open Researcher and Contributor ID) • Orcid.org • Profile with persistent digital identifier • Today's best choice - widely supported by funding agencies and publishers • Connection between databases, publications and other identifiers by your ORCID (ResearcherlD, Scopus ID, ANDS, CrossRef, Metadata Search, Europe PubMed Central) 9 ORCiD Z : " = T. 'r -.= i= 3." 1" r. = i = E'-l' = 'i FOR ORGANIZATIONS ABOUT HELP SIGN OUT 1 ACCOUMT5 ETTINGS | DEVELOPER TOOLS LEACH MORE 1 1 71 &e5 ORCIC Ce art:: iolpi ng. 5ěe mart- Michal Petr Q Biography I v Education (1) 1 + Add education It ÜDrt View Public Profile " Get a QR Code for your iD O Also known as: $ Country: ^ Czech Republic Masarykova Univerzita: Brno, CZ M3r. SCLRCE \J :tl PEir CREA-EC 20I4-OÍ-2Í ✓ Ir 1 v Employment (1) + AdkJ employment _|_t - = rt Keywords: Websites: Other IDj: Res-eartherlD F-7757-2013 0 Masarykova Univerzita: Brno, CZ 2012 to presem | Manager fcr Research EvJuatton [Reanr's Office) SOURCE Michal Petr v Funding (D) CREATED; 1014-06-26 /ti You haven't added any funding, add lome now v Work. (5) Opava železniční: I 60 let od příjezdu prvního vlaku 2014 I bank ISBN: 973-80-90539(1-9-3 + Add funding It iort + Add works ySulkedh JtSort 13 * 4 ä SOURCE Mehal Petr CREATED: 2014-1 I-OS G Preferred source Obecní dům v Opavě 0 * 201 1 1 journal-article SOURCE ResearcherlD CREATE Ľ* 2014-06-26 E Preferred source Analýza pravěkých a raně historických nálezů z povrchových 0 *J sběrů v okolí Břeclavi 2008 1 :.-==:: -. SOURCE ResearclierlD CREATED: 2014-06-26 Preferred source Fi Geografická a archeologicko-prostorová data z Rakouska a možnosti jejich využití 2008 I journal-article 0 * SOURCE Resear-rherlD CREATED: 2014-06-26 E Preferred source Železniční trať Opava - Trenčín jako doklad kolapsu soukromě výstavby železnic v 70. letech 19. století : Vlastivědný sborník Novojičínska 2008 | :.■■?=■:: -. ISSN: 12148032 Usage of identifiers National consortium for ORCID set to improve UK research visibility and collaboration identifiers on grant applications. The Wellcome Trust will make ORCID a mandatory requirement from August 2015, while both HEFCE and RCUK have shown high levels of support for the initiative. In addition, the envisaged enhancements to systems and processes integrating ORCID should also play an important role in helping universities respond to funders* open access (OA) policies, for example as part of the next REF, supporting the move towards an open culture. Universities see ORCID as a crucial service, easing the workload of their researchers in ensuring compliance with OA mandates, making research more visible and discoverable, and creating opportunities for international and cross-disciplinary collaboration. ORCID ORCID provides an international and unique digital identifier for researchers. Researchers at Dalarna University are encouraged to acquire ORCID. The Swedish Research Council's application and management system Prisma requires the use of ORCID. Italy Launches National ORCID Implementation 11 RV ResearcherlD • www.researcherid.com • Profile developed by Thomson Reuters • Feedback to Web of Science for grouping author name variants or corrections to affiliations • Basic bibliometric functions • Suitable for regular Web of Science users RESEARCHERID Petr, Michal Researched D: F-7757-2013 Other Names: Your labs page and badge shovt only your pub ic cata E-mail: petr@rect.muni cz URL: http:/Afrwresearcherid.com/rid/F-7757-2013 Subject: History Keywords: Enter a Keyword ORCID: http 7/0 rci d. o rgVO 000-0003-4067-6139 fEťchangedatawithQRCJD ] Description: Enter a Description My URLs: httpflls.muni.cz/Qsoba/65024 wfrwmichalpetr.cz nttp ://www. n e do stave n atrat. estra nkv. cz My Institutions (more details) Primary Institution: Masaryk University Sub-orgJDept Rector's Office Role: Administrator Joint Affiliation: Sub-org.'Oept: Role: Past Institutions: THOMSON REUTERS Home My Researcher Profile Refer a Colleague Logout Search Interactive Map EndNote > Preview Public Version My Publications My Publications [□) on s Citation Metrics Manage|Add ResearcherlDlabs Create A Badge Collaboration Network Citing Articles Network Publication Groups Publication List 1 {O) View Publications Citation Metrics Manage|Add Publication List 2 (0) View Publications Citation Metrics Manage I Add My Publications: View ve authored. You have the ability to make this list public or private. If public, then visitors of ResearcherlD can see your scholarly output, and your list will be sent to the Web of Science (die-: here for more information). Click on the Manage Profile button at the top-right corner of the page and select the Publication Lists tab to change the privacy settings of your data. 5 publication(s) Page 1 Sort by: Publication Year T Results per page: 10 T 1. Title: Opava železniční: "160 let od příjezdu prvního vlaku Author(s): Petr, Michal; Borovcová. Alena 2. Title: Obecní dům v Opave Author(s): Petr, Michal 3. Title:.Analýza pravekých a rané historických nálezů z povrchových scérů v okolí Břeclavi Author[s): Petr. Michal 4. Title: Geografická a archeologicko-prostorová data z Rakouska a možnosti jejich využití Author(s): Petr, Michal 5. Title: Železniční trať Opava - Trenčín jako doklad kolapsu soukromé výstavby železnic v 70. letech "19. století Author[s): Petr, Michal Source: Vlastivedný sborník Novojicínska Pages: 140-152-140-152 Fublished: 2008 added Q5-N0V-14 added 12-N0V-13 added 12-NOV-13 added 12-NOV-13 added 12-N0V-13 5 publication(s) Page 1 Sort by: Publication Year T Results per page: 10 T Help Refer a Colleague How to use these lists Return to Search Page Get A Badge Researcher! D ResearcherlD: I'- ll RL: http ://www. researcherid.com/ri d/' My Institutions (more details) Primary Institution: Masaryk University Sub-org/Dept: Role: Faculty My Publications My Publications (16} View Publications Citation Metrics ResearcherlD labs Create A Badge Collaboration Network Citing Articles Network My Publications: Citation Metrics This graph shows the number of times the articles on the publication list have been cited in each of the last 20 years. Note: Only articles from Web of Science Core Collection with citation data are included in the calculations. More information about these data. 45 H 40 35 30 '.lU | 25 H □ 20 15 10 5 0 Citation Distribution by year ■□U «V «V V V V A A A A A A A A A A A* A* A* A' A' A* Total Articles in Publication List: 18 Articles With Citation Data: 1* Sum ofthe Times Cited: 539 Average Citations per Article: 29.94 h-index: 12 Last Updated: 02/20/2015 07:11 GMT Year Other possibilities of (se presentation Personal Identifiers - ORCID, ResearcherlD Institutional Repository (Open Access in general) Social networks • Increasing visibility • Stay in touch with the community ResearchGate & Academia.edu • Community organized around selected topics • Social functions (following researchers, comments to paper drafts, discussions, questions around topics) - chance to start new collaborations • Metrics and source for alternative metrics (# downloads, # views,...) • Job offers • Publication list and sharing full texts (indexed by Google Scholar) ResearchGate • Researchgate.com • RG-score (total activity and interaction, plus publications) • Impact points (number of publications weighed by journals they are published Academia.edu • Academia.edu • You see the content without logging in • Google Scholar, Linkedln, Facebook, Google+, Twitter, Skype,... HOME QUESTIONS JOBS R v Search Do your peers have these skills? Johannes Sorz Plant Environmental Stress Physiology Wolfgang Glánzel added a research Endorse Skip ASK HE LATER Multi-authorship and citation advantage, a mythical relationship June 2015 Source Bart Thijs ■ Rodrigo Costas ■ Wolfgang Glanzel Description: Scien to metricians have devoted much time to the analysis of the (almost mythical) telation between collaboration and citation impact. Several authors found positive cottelation between co... DOWNLOAD FOLLOW 73 RD Martin Kvizda added full-texts to 6 publications Managing the Czech Joint-Stock Companies - Failure of Economic Transformation - JOES YOU MAYBE INTERESTED IN 55 'j Senior Project Manager E uropear Vaccine I n itiative Research Manager Monash University (Australia) Research Manager - Higher Educatio... The University of Sheffield I m prove these suggestions Get your job displayed here January 2006 Martin Kvizda ■ Jindřiška Sedova Abstract: The aim of this paper is to analyse whether legal rules, set up during; the first years of the economic transition could stimulate behaviour of economic subjects so that it would lead to ... CURRENT LAST READS WEEK WEEK CURRENT LAST WEEK WEEK PROFILE VIEWS OVERVIEW CONTRIBUTIONS INFO SWS RG SCORE Show your career's best Use your profile overview page to present yourself and your research. Customizing your profile is the best ray to slow your peers what you've been working on, create exposure for your current projects, and start building your network. Masaryk University s ; Rector's office V/ Brno, Czech Republic, Czech Republic 6 PUBLICATIONS 5 0 Reads Citations View stats Add your unpublished work to your profile Start gaining visibility and citations for unpublished work by adding research such as working papers, methods, and results to your profile. Upload unpublished work ABOUT Add a snort introduction about yourself or tout current project. CONNECT WITH MORE COLLEAGUES X ^ Add your other social network services to find more A colleagues and share your achievements and \3 updates. Connect now FEATURED PUBLICATIONS Technical Report: Podoby vnitrního hodnocení výzkumu na vybraných zahraničních institucích a pohled na ně očima výzkumníků Michal Petr Source 3 Reads 0 Citations Book: Opava železniční: 160 let od příjezdu prvního vlaku Michal Petr 0 0 Reads Citations Article: Obecní dum v Opavě Michal Petr 0 Reads 0 Citations SKILLS AND EXPERTISE [4) Q 19th Century History Q Bibliometrics Scientometrics Research Evaluation Michal, are you skilled in these areas of research? Library Science x Scholarly Communication x Digital Libraries x Bibliographic Databases x Academic Librarianship * Learn more Add skills to profile 13 FOLLOWING View all 3 FOLLOWERS A 7 V7i i--* View all ACADEMIA <* SMi-ch.. 0 HOME ANALYTICS New job added to History: Scholarship Program (PhD, Post-Doctoral, Visiting Scholars) - China Scholarship Council & Hebrew University of Jerusalem Hebrew University of Jerusslern ^ 94 History. China,... New job added to History: Want to host a panel discussion to expose students to all sides of an issue? Check out the IHS On-Campus Faculty Partnership Institute for HumanE Studies 23 History. Reaea... m-M Juan Gorraiz added 5 papers: Excellence, merit and research team size: a library and information science case study H BOOKMARK rjh DOWNLOAD by Juan Goirsiz Research Data Explored: Citations versus Altmetrics ■) BOOKMARK © DOWNLOAD by Juan Goirsiz 0 On the temporal stability of Garfield's impact factor and its suitability to identify hot papers PI BOOKMARK © DOWNLOAD by Juan Goirsiz 1 Hew pa per added to H istory Envisioning a "Whitened" Brazil: Photography and Slavery at the World's Fairs, 1862-18S9 JOB BOARD Scholarship Program (PhD, Post-Doctoral, Visiting Scholars) -China Scholarship Council & Hebrew JnrverHty of Jerusalem Hebrew University nf Jerusalem Lecturer / Senior Lecturer - Materials Engineering Sheffield Ha lam University Post-Doctoral Fellowship in the History and Philosophy of Science and Ideas at Tel Aviv University Tel AviVUnivErsrty ADVERTISE WITH US > SUGGESTED SESSIONS A theory of the origins of non-racist 1 thinking Jen I 9 25 I Jim Harries FIMD FRIENDS & COLLEAGUES Discover more new research by fdbwrtg people you know en AEademia.edu: 3* GOOGLE CONNECT Suggestions to be more visible on the web Suggestion 1 - Database Indexing Suggestion 2 - Research Documentation (IS MU) Suggestion 3 - Language (English) Suggestion 4 - We recommend the use of a correctly updated personal identifiers such as ORCID (or ResearcherlD) Suggestion 5 - Self-marketing - communities (Academia, ResearchGate) Suggestion 6-Self-marketing-social media (Linkedln, blog, website) Suggestion 7 - Exploration of the use of „Google Scholar Citations", especially for SSH 20 Czech National Evaluation Jeffrey Mervis, Science 2014;343:596-598 Czech Evaluation Methodology - principles • Defines, which outputs are eligible for the Information System of R&D&I (RIV, not IS MUM!) and how are they rewarded by points • Advantage: consistent structure of outputs for many years The goal is to define the share of every research organization on the whole research funding budget • Assessment in 2016 (outputs 2010-2015) influences funding in 2018 • Evaluation methodology evolution: - 2010-2012 - strictly quantity-based counting; output = defined number of points - 2013-2016 - actual methodology, small share of panel/peer review - From 2018 (expected) - NERO - National Evaluation of Research Organizations, international experiences, professional design, partly Performance-Based Research Funding System Evaluation Methodology • Methodology 2013-2016 has 3 „pillars": - Pillar I. - publications (metrics and peer review) - Pillar II. - excellence (peer review) - Pillar III. - patents, innovative outputs, policies Type of outputs (in czech): http://www.vvzkuin.cz/storage/att/2DB911A3086BC7D47A5B5F462DC 9F041/Druh%20v%C3%BDsledku.pdf Your role in the system • Make familiar with the output types and their definitions • Declare all your publication activities honestly • Behave ethically: - Declare correct affiliation • Don't cheat the system: - Don't produce fragmentary outputs - Don't put quantity before quality • Don't reduce your scientific attention to counting the points! National Evaluation Systems Australian (.uuTiiiiK'tii \m-I r . • I«_ c ■ t -■. ..i . h > OUlHil R€F 01.2014 December 2014 This document is for information. This document sets out the m results of the 2014 Research Excellence Framework. Excellence in Research for Australia 2012 National Report Research Excellence Framework 2014: The results vffir R€FÜM Research Excellence Framework Recent Trends (World) • Increasing importance (public financing, complicated research systems) • Reducing the costs - Usage of indicators • Amphasis on profesionalization (agencies), relevance and reliability • peer-review (or informed peer-review) • Formative effect, low influence on core funding • Impact-based indicators (societal too) x Czech Republic (outputs) Metrics-based Peer review / panels Austria - BMWF Belgium (FI)-EWI ■ Czech Republic - RDI Council ■ ■ Denmark - Fl Finland - MINEDU France - AERES Italy-ANVUR Netherlands - KNAW/NWO/VSNU Norway - RCN Spain -CNEAI ■ Sweden - SRC UK - HEFCE ■ European Parliament, STOA - Science and Technology Options Assessment 2014 No influence on core funding Influence on core funding Not linked to funding decisions Additional to the block grant Less than 20% Between 20% and 50% More than 50% Austria - BMWF | Belgium (Flanders) - EWI | | Czech Republic Denmark - Agency for Science, Technology and Innovation (Fl) Finland - Min. of Education & Culture (MINEDU) France - AERES Italy-ANVUR | Netherlands - KNAW/NWO/VSNU Norway - RCN | Spain -CNEAI Sweden - Vetenskapsradet, SRC UK-HEFCE | European Parliament, STOA - Science and Technology Options Assessment 2014 Finland Norway (PRI) Belgium/FL (BOF) Norway (HEI) Sweden Society Innovation Research Czech Republic [ Outputs Systemic & process indicators Impacts Zdroj: Technopolis, 2014 (Individual) Research Evaluation in a Nutshell Important strategic tool of R&D policies Who is afraid of the evaluation? • Not a repression tool • Valuable feedback & learning • Scientists often dispute, that they are able to measure the quality of their own research alone... Methods • Qualitative (peer/panel review, ISAB) • Quantitative (bibliometrics - indicators) Makro Meso Mikro gencies Bibliometrics Ilustrace: David Parkins, www.nature.com Bibliometrics • Bibliometrics and scientometrics are sub-disciplines of information science Set of quantitative methods applied to the media of scientific communication (journals, books,...) • Bibliometrics can provide tools to be applied to research evaluation, but is not designed to directly evaluate research performance • Does not replace qualitative methods • Can inform research strategies Bibliometrics in a Researcher's Career • Habilitations • Professorial appointment procedures • Hiring procedures • Professional promotion • Self-promotion • Grant application procedures • Re-accreditation of PhD programs Benefits of bibliometrics for scientists Planning the career and developing publication strategies (especially for young scientists) Increasing the scientist's visibility (ResearcherlD, ORCID, Google Citations Profile, etc.) Mapping the research environment: • Which are the key players (authors, institutions, countries, etc.) in my research field? • What are the hot topics in my research field? • How visible are my publications? How can I increase their visibility (publication strategies)? • How big is the impact of my publications ? How many citations do I need to belong to the „best" (excellence)? • Who are my potential competitors/collaborators? • How does my research output fare in comparison to my competitors/collaborators? What can be measured: Coverage (databases; WoS/Scopus) • Activity (trends) • Visibility (JIF) • Impact (Top Percentiles) • Collaboration Databases and Sources * Bibliographic databases suitable for bibliometric analyses - Thomson Reuters (Web of Science) and Elsevier (SCOPUS) - Subject Specific Databases: MathSciNet (mathematics), SciFinder - CAS (chemistry, biochemistry), PubMed (medicine), ADS - Astrophysics Data System (astrophysics). Patents - Derwent (součást Web of Science), EPO- PATSTAT, USPTO, DEPATISnet, WIPO * Google Scholar as a data source - Alternative source for SSH - Extreme caution - In some fields high correlation with traditional databases Citation Index since 1960s - from books to online platform (Web of Science) CITATION INDEX both of these items by ArUSAfzA I M« references need f* Wagner C ui hu article from Mcllllur|icffl yeetr of publication, foumoi abbrevuuton. mturnf 4 pfSft both trie authors cited ANSAßl AH I paper at their amctes iff Otntemc* ud G*n«cok>j> undated item - Source IndtX entry for article by fetal w which _ motel reference to the mi paper by Anselm F. Sample Display ANSANELLIV -—j. 17 AM i BOLLEFI " u« iir AM J ROENTQ ANSA RAI - _[— (I IMMAISWFrE CH EWE 101 ~— i 1 3EMM CH« ETAT *0U ■ WAAHEfl - Mr. TAU. T-B ANSARI A-- -■ AM 4 i'.is rhutN rthol M ANDEHSSO A AUER 2 _ hg PEC3I II P MAS US U 5 HEB J «1 EU *»',£ KS AM ft »E V D ANSARI AH- Cksn, Item - cinnf author journal abbreviation yalrnme. page a\ year 173 ■r 17 Connrft Jnr Source Indes urrtwi *»/ rAr SCI for btbliofraphtc information on all citing, trims th the Clu-cion laaex. tSee sample betow) ■ AH J CUSTtT Q7NEC 101 «11 IM HORMONE MET S 30 rfr-BTKJTV STSHIUTT 21 ITJ — STBuvl FA 06STET a'M 33 1_ yOuhq jk ANSEAU Un E7 §7 Coda lodkale Type of Source Item: flunk jrrr*7#J, repttrti. technical papers, etc. boot -'. ir* . ifrom iclerMuf* Sv.c CANTOR 9 ANSELIN F- B CA MKO0MAO It ACAO tM - POAt Iff J SOL ST CM B T All NUCL SOC 20 BLANC-HAft 5 T AM NUCL S c I I L M M R SOURCE INDEX ENTRY PEZAT M- * TAWGL/Y B H POnTICR J HAGENMUL P—(FR) AJWE? EAHTH NITRIDE n_L>0fl.DES J SOL ST CH i J/ * • Jü i - J *: «7 NffVlure) t>i■I ■ ™i... I.;■ tWM about Umdividuak ttrttttttI, .jtiJiKirif'i, t repnnli (ompu/er nrvifwf f rWrrfway-* ' r I - . "■ - 1 • r " f - . database rrvwrwr, A tnmpittr Jticnpno*. uf tturh source htm codt appcan in the SCI Codei A Consultant: OcKfeoo Imln ,-. V. ■! -.' -.c tlOfiat tSt • Jourmt Acctinon Sumbtr PATENT CITATION INDEX reference patent number cued reference year reference inventor . -Jff10eS17 - 4,300 titles .) 0 Health Sciences (> 6,300 titles . 100% Medline coverage } Document Type ALL 0 Physical Sciences (> 7,200 titles.) 0 Social Sciences & Humanities (> 5,300 titles .} Learn more about how to Improve Scopus Stay up-to-date on Scopus. Follow @Scopus on Twitter Watch tutorials and learn how to make Scopus work for you ÉL Get citation alerts pushed straight to your inbox Get started with Scopus APIs About Scopus What is Scopus Content coverage Scopus Blog Scopus API Language Customer Service Help and Contact Live Chat ELSEVIER Terms and Conditions Privacy policy Copyright © 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.Scopus® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. Databases Web of Science, SCOPUS Importance for national assessment Quality standard (journal selection process) Responsible peer review process Visibility Easy citations tracking WoS (traditional, but less sources indexed) x SCOPUS (newer, more „european", but not so strict selection process) Michal Petr Masaryk University history, railway history, sports E-mailová adresa ověřena na: rect.muni.cz Můj profil je veřejný Upravit Změnit fotografii □ Název + Přidat — Další 1-6 Citace Rok □ Geografická a archeologicko-prostorová data z Rakouska a možnosti jejich využití M Petr Masarykova univerzita Brno: Archeologický ústav AVČR. Praha, wi ... 2 2008 □ Analýza pravěkých a raně historických nálezů z povrchových sběrů v okolí Břeclavi M Petr Masarykova univerzita Brno: Archeologický ústav AVČR, Praha, wi ... 1 2008 □ Opava železniční: 160 let od příjezdu prvního vlaku M Petr, A Borovcová Opavská kulturní organizace 2014 □ Obecní dům v Opavě M Petr Matice Slezská 2011 □ Železniční trať Opava-Trenčín jako doklad kolapsu soukromé výstavby železní c v 70. letech 19. století M Petr 2008 □ Úspěchy a neúspěchy výstavby železnic v Rakouskem Slezsku v 70. letech 19. století M Petr Masarykova univerzita 2007 Google Scholar Citační indexy Citace h-index i 10-indejí III 2012 2013 2014 Spoluautoři Upravit. Žádní spoluautoři Všechny Od 2010 3 1 0 Zobrazil další Data a počty citací jsou odhady určené automaticky počítačovým programem. Nápověda Ochrana soukromí Smluvní podmínky Poskytnout zpětnou vazbu Moje citace $ Hamng's Publish or Perish File Edit View Tools Help Author impact Journal impact General citations Multi-query center Web browser Check for updates Help contents What's new? 2-Minute intra PoP FAQ PoP web site PoP book Author impact analysis - Perform a citation analysis for one or more authors Author's name: Michal Pen- Exclude these names: Year of publication between: 2008 and: 2014 Data source: | Google Scholar ■> Results Papers: Citations: Years: Papers/author: Cites/year: Cites/auth/year: 4,50 0.43 0.42 h-index: g-index: he-index: Midhal Petr from 2008 to 2014: all Query date: 2015-02-19 Papers: 5 Citations: 3 Lookup j Lookup Direct | Clear All Help □ Cites/paper: O.SO hi,annual: 0,14 hI,norm: 1 years: 7 Cites s- Per year Rank Authors TiťJe Year Publication Publisher Type - 0 0,00 966 P Michal Vývoj a trendy v oblasti fotoinidátorů 2013 dspace.upce.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 957 M Petr Prindp ne bis in idem v prostoru svo.., 2008 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 968 M Petr, Z Tonarová Soutěžní právo, dominance a regula,,. 2010 muni.cz CITATION 0 0,00 969 M Petr, A Borovcová Opava železniční: 160 let od příjezdu,.. 2014 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 97Ü MPetr Podniky, koncerny, dceřiné společno.,, 2013 muni.cz CITATION 0 0,00 971 MM Petr Tajemství dechu CITATION □ 0 0.00 972 M Petrr M Růžičková Test dtace 2 2012 muni.cz □ 0 0,00 973 P Míchal Genderová analýza ve vybrané nezi.,, 2009 is.muni.cz PDF □ 0 0,00 97-4 M Petr, M Rflžičkov,. Test dtace 2013 Výzkumný ústav pivovarský ... CITATION 0 0,00 975 MPetr Obemí dům v Opavé 2011 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 976 M Petr Paleosesmologická vyhodnocení průz,.. 2010 Brno: Ustav fyziky Země, Pr... CITATION □ 0 0,00 977 MPetr Bílá kniha 0 náhradě škody způsoben,.. 2008 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 973 J Čermák, Z Loe,. Cyber Law in the Czech Republic 2012 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 979 F Černoch, B Dančá. , Nekonvenční zdroje zemního plynu-.., 2012 muni.cz 0 0,00 930 M Růžička, P Sojka Redakční systém odborného časopis.,, 2011 muni.cz 0 0.00 931 J Holý, J Flaišman, .. Kronika a glosy 2011 Česká literatura ceeol.com 0 0,00 932 P Mrkývka, P Jánoši. , Finanční a daňové právo 2009 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 933 L Vitova,TKyndov,. Another Czech literatuře (?) 2011 ... NA FLORENCI 3, PP 14, P... CITATION □ 0 0,00 93^ R Micka, P Cimala, P, . RECENZE 2010 Studia theologica CITATION □ 0 0,00 935 M Petr DROGY A MLADISTVÍ 2009 dspace, tul.cz □ 0 0,00 934 P Černek, M Brejch,. A Comparison of Power Quality Cont.,, 2012 Acta Polytechnica ojs.cvut.cz □ 0 0,00 937 M Burger, B Ondráč, Farmakoekonomické hodnocení [CEA.,, 2013 muni.cz □ 0 0,00 93í P Kearney.TMcDo,. Pa6o4aq rpynna EeponeňcKoro 06.,, 2010 CITATION 0 0,00 939 P Kuchtová, B Šerá,, . REAKCE OSIVA MÁKU SETÉHO NA O,.. OSIVO A ... krv.agrobiologie.cz PDF 0 0.00 990 P Sojka, M Růžička TeXové technologie pro digitální mat... 2009 muni.cz 0 0,00 991 M Lehnert, R Psotta. . SEASONAL VARIATION IN ISOHNET.,, 2014 Kineziologija hrcak.srce.hr □ 0 0,00 992 1 GOLQNKA, Z VAŠÍ. Artykury wprowadzajace i objasnieni.,, journals, bg.agh.edu.pl □ 0 0,00 993 P Lichý, M Cagala Studium filtrace taveniny sledováním.,, 2009 dspace.vsb.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 994 F Avilés, J Bartůněk. Deputy Editors actavia, e-coretvasa. cz □ 0 0,00 993 O Májek, J Mužik, . Nový informační systém a datový au.,, 2009 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 996 P Sojka, M Bulant SCO 2008, Sharable Content Object,.. 2008 muni.cz CITATION □ 0 0,00 997 L Kynd,P Mrkývka,, . Metoda a ekonomické limity regulace,.. 2013 muni.cz BOOK 0 0,00 993 J Zatloukal, P Raus,. Osophagographie,Thorakotomie, O,,. 2009 Kleintier-Praxis CITATION 0 0.00 999 S Bengtson, X Hou, . . Thematic issue: Biomechanics and Pa... app.pan.pl 0 0,00 1000 MPetr Železniční trať Opava-Trenän jako d,.. 2008 muni.cz CITATION □ 1 0.17 517 M Petr Odpovědnost v soutěžním právu 2009 muni.cz CrTATION □ 1 1,00 513 M Petr, L Boerboom, An uncertainty assessment framewo.,, 2014 Forest Policy and Economics Elsevier □ 1 0,17 ó 7-4 S Michal, Stři tez,. Does Cold Plasma Affect Breaking D.., 2009 Plasma Sdence and ... adsabs, harvard .edu Iři -1 1 nn Ü/0/0 prn 0/10 m Wh 54/4 h 177 total Hotovo Copy results Copy > Check all Check selection Uncheckall Uncheck 0 dtes Uncheck selection Help 4.11.0.5495 Indicators - example There is no single indicator to express all! Journal evaluation (not individuals!!!) • Journal Impact Factor (JIF) + Quartile Rank Article-Level Indicators (impact) • Citation Impact - citations per publication (in a dataset) • Category Normalized Citation Impact - ratio of actual citations to expected citations rate, normalized to the field, year and type (1 = world average) • Percentiles • H-index Journal Impact Factor (Thomson Reuters) Originally designed for better selection of subscribed journals Measures journal influence (according to the calculation), not quality or impact of research published in! IF is calculated by dividing the number of citations in the JCR year by the total number of articles published in the two previous years. • Often used as a proxy for the relative importance of a journal within its field; journals with higher IF are considered to be more important than those with lower ones Limitations: 80/20 rule - high IF doesn't directly lead to high citations count of the article Calculation can be skewed by: - Review articles - Small number of highly cited articles - Aggreements between journals (mutual citations) Very subject specific H-index • H-index measures productivity and impact • The value of h is equal to the number of papers (N) in the list that have N or more citations • For example, an h-index of 2 indicates that in the dataset, 2 papers were cited at least 2 times each • Different value, while excerpted from different sources Advantages • Cannot be influenced by small number of extremely highly cited article or big number of zero-cited articles • In terms of trend data can identify consitently excellent research in the field • Can identify „rising stars'' in the field Limitations • Subject-specific, cannot be compared between research fields • Rises with the age of the researcher; never falls down Colleague A • 1 article, year 2012, JIF 12,511 • H-index 1 Colleague B • 1 article, year 2012, JIF 4,842 • H-index 1 Colleague A • 1 article, year 2012, JIF 12,511 • H-index 1 • Multidisciplinary • Citation count: 9 • Multi-authored: 55 authors Colleague B • 1 article, year 2012, JIF 4,842 • H-index 1 • Specialized journal in category, locally relevant • Citation count: 30 • Bilateral collaboration with leading university • Article is shared via Twitter comments Perspectives of bibliometrics • Appropriate indicators for the assessments of the social sciences, humanities and arts • Analysis of web visibility and Weblinks (webometrics) • „Usage" statistics (e.g., download, access, views, visits) • „Altmetrics" (alternative metrics), e.g., based on discussion in social media (Mendeley, CiteULike, Twitter and others) • Social networks and tools (ResearchGate, academia.edu etc.) Conclusions • Use the bibliometric services for shaping your publication strategy • Use alternative metrics as a measures of impact (social networks) • You shouldn't be evaluated by one indicator • Quality of research cannot be meaured by Journal Impact Factor Useful weblinks • www.vyzkum.cz • www.isvav.cz • www.webofscience.com • www.scopus.com • www.orcid.org • www.researcherlD.com • http://www.harzing.com/pop.htm (Publish or Perish) • http://www.ascb.org/dora/ • http://vyzkum.rect.muni.cz/cs/evaluace-vyzkumu Error in the Assessment Design.