The Art Market in 2023 NFT “Chaos under the pure light” by 1dontknows 02 01 SUMMARY OVERVIEW: WINDS OF CHANGE AFTER TWO RECORD YEARS STATE OF THE MARKET Asia restarts while the West readjusts Reasons to remain optimistic THE YEAR IN REVIEW STRUCTURE AND EVOLUTION OF THE MARKET BY PRICE RANGE Changes in the high-end market The dynamics of the intermediate markets High transaction volume at the low end GEOGRAPHY OF THE ART MARKET AND THE MAIN AUCTION HOUSES TOP PERFORMING COUNTRIES The United States shrinks by two billion Lots of works sold – and unsold – in China The UK market has shrunk since Brexit The France market holds up well GLOBAL RANKING OF AUCTION HOUSES Flexibility at Christie’s and Sotheby’s Phillips posts remarkable sold-through rates The top Chinese auctioneers QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARAA’S OVERVIEW OF THE CHINESE ART MARKET IN 2023 6 24 33 GEOGRAPHIC DEVELOPMENTS IN THE MARKET London increasingly squeezed Hong Kong confirms its power of attraction India: the surprise of the year THE ARTISTS AND WORKS THAT MARKED THE YEAR THE RELATIVE MARKET WEIGHT OF THE DIFFERENT CREATIVE PERIODS Old Masters 19th Century Modern Art Post-War Art Contemporary art NFTs WHICH ARTISTS GENERATED THE HIGHEST TRANSACTION VOLUMES The winning trio The most sought-after artists by country SECOND BEST PERFORMANCE BY FEMALE ARTISTS History’s female painters revalued 20th Century works revalued by several million dollars Yayoi Kusuma overtakes Gustav Klimt Joan Mitchell generates over $100 million Julie Mehretu - most expensive artist of African origin Paula Rego - record year one year after her death Enthusiastic bidding for emerging female artists TOP 100 FINE ART AND NFT WORKS SOLD AT AUCTION IN 2023 TOP 500 ARTISTS BY AUCTION REVENUE IN 2023 03 38 62 64 Methodology The analysis of the Art Market presented in this report has been compiled on the basis of the results of Fine Art public auctions recorded by Artprice and Artron between 1 January and 31 December 2023. This analysis only concerns paintings, sculptures, drawings, photographs, prints, videos, installations, tapestries and NFTs, and it excludes antiques, anonymous cultural goods and furniture. All prices indicated in this document relate to the results of public auctions, buyers' fees included. Any mention of $ refers to the US dollar and any mention of ¥ refers to the Chinese yuan. The exchange rate used by ARAA to convert sales results recorded in the Chinese market is an annual average rate. Except for Chinese art, Artprice’s temporal segmentation of art history refers to the following creative periods: • “Old Masters”: works created by artists born before 1760 • “19th Century”: works created by artists born between 1760 and 1860 • “Modern Art”: works created by artists born between 1860 and 192 • “Post-War Art”: works created by artists born between 1920 and 1945 • “Contemporary Art”: works created by artists born after 1945 • “Ultra-contemporary Art”: works created by artists under 40 years old ARAA divides Chinese Art into two main categories: • “Chinese painting and calligraphy” refers to traditional Chinese art, i.e. Chinese ink on supports as diverse as Xuan paper, silk and fans. “Chinese calligraphy” has words, poems and wishes as subjects, while “Chinese painting” depicts landscapes, people, birds and flowers. • “Oil painting and contemporary art” refers to works of art created by Chinese artists who have appropriated Western techniques and media (oil painting, photography, sculpture, installation, pencil drawing, gouache, watercolor , etc.) since the first exhibition of an oil-on-canvas in China in 1579. 4 FOREWORD BY THIERRY EHRMANN Our 2023 Art Market Report is much more reassuring than the results of the major prestigious sessions alone suggest: the number of auction transactions reached a new absolute record and the unsold rate of lots has remained completely stable. The art auction market is therefore running at full speed with only the ultra high-end segment slowing down. The number of transactions over $10 million actually fell by 25%, but the total number of lots sold worldwide increased by +5%. With no fabulous results hammered for works in major collections like the Paul G. Allen Collection in 2022, the year 2023 was much less illustrious at the high-end, and 19th Century Art was the segment that contracted the most. In the absence of major works, Claude Monet remained the 6th top-selling artist in the world (at auction) in 2023, although his auction total dropped from $540 million in 2022 to $197 million in 2023. It is clear that the global geopolitical context has substantially contributed to a slowdown in sales of historical masterpieces. However, this report highlights many remarkable performances: the very first auction result above $100 million in London, the rapid development of auctions in India as well as the stabilization of NFT sales. Generative Art experienced sensational success in 2023, with seven-digit results for NFTs by Dimitry Cherniak and Tyler Hobbs. Artprice sees this medium as a domain with major potential. We are also very proud to collaborate with the digital artist 1DONTKNOWS by presenting his NFT Chaos under the pure light on the front cover of this report. Our 2023 Art Market Report also highlights the performances of women artists. Japanese visual artist Yayoi Kusama has for the second consecutive year joined the 10 top-selling artists in the world (all creative periods combined) behind René Magritte and above Gustav Klimt! New auction records were also recorded for Joan Mitchell, Louise Bourgeois, Agnes Martin and Barbara Hepworth. They attest to the new appreciation collectors now have of these major artists of the 20th Century. Artprice observed the growth in the recognition of female artists is further amplified by their diverse origins, with the Ethiopian-American Julie Mehretu (b. 1970) and the Nigerian-English Jadé Fadojutimi (1993) among the brightest stars on the global art market in 2023. Artprice by Artmarket. com – world leader in art market information – continues its collaboration for the fifteenth consecutive year with the Chinese company Artron, whose ARAA service provides essential information on the Chinese art market. Together we publish the world’s most comprehensive annual report on the art market. Our partnership honors the diplomaticrelationsestablishedsixtyyears ago between China and France, which, in 2024 (year of the dragon in China) has a new lease of life with the announcement by the former French Minister of Europe and Foreign Affairs, Catherine Colonna, and her Chinese counterpart, Wang Yi, of the “Franco-Chinese Year of Cultural Tourism” in 2024. The global coverage of art auction sales made possible by the association of Artprice and Artron allows a comprehensive view of the structural evolution and trends in the global art market. This report is therefore unique and we are proud to present it to you in three languages: French, Mandarin and English. Thierry Ehrmann, CEO of Artmarket.com and Founder of Artprice 5 FOREWORD BY WAN JIE In 2024, marking the 60th anniversary of Sino-French diplomatic relations, the world’s political and economic landscape continues to harbor a degree of uncertainty. Nonetheless, the sharing of cultural and artistic ideals persists as an enduring aspiration of mankind. In fact, across the annals of human civilization, the creation, exchange, accumulation, and spread of cultural and artistic works have persisted, unaffected by shifts in the economy or turbulence in politics. Beginning in 2010, the partnership between Artron Art Group and Artprice celebrates its 15th anniversary this year. “The 2023 Global Art Market Report” encapsulates the essence of our 14-year collaboration and serves as a testament to cultural and artistic exchanges between the East and West. Nowadays, a growing array of international artists and art exhibitions are leaving their mark in China. This trend not only reflects the enthusiasm and openness of Chinese art enthusiasts towards the diverse cultures and arts of various nations, but also highlights China’s ambition to integrate with the global community, and the world’s eagerness to understand and cherish Chinese culture and art. Art endures against the passage of time, and art data plays a crucial role in preserving cultural and artistic heritage. As one of the world’s top three art data companies, Artprice not only serves the French art market but also the global art market at large. Through the partnership between Artron and Artprice, our goal is to enhance the exchange of cultural and artistic values between the East and West. This endeavor holds profound significance for the exchanges, collections, education, and research within the art market, enabling the international community to gain a deeper understanding of Chinese artists and helping Chinese artists gain entry into the international art scene. Simultaneously, it allows more outstanding international artists to participate in the Chinese art market. China has a profound respect for the cultural and artistic contributions of all nations and ethnicities. Thus, the partnership between Artron and Artprice aims not only to learn, study, and draw inspiration from foreign art and culture, but also to foster deeper integration into the global community. We eagerly anticipate making fresh new contributions to the cultural and artistic realms of both China and the world. Artron is committed to taking on greater responsibilities by building bridges that enable Chinese and international artists, art institutions, cultural and art enthusiasts, as well as researchers to comprehensively understand Chinese art and effectively tell Chinese stories. Wan Jie, Founder and CEO of Artron Art Group and Founder of Artron Research Academy of Arts (ARAA) Overview: Winds of change after two record years 7 KEY FIGURES FOR AUCTIONS OF FINE ART AND NFT WORKS WORLDWIDE (2023) Global turnover Down -14% compared to 2022 Lots sold Maximum number of transactions: almost 763,000 Unsold rate This ratio increases in the face of abundant supply Lots presented The market reaches its highest density, more than 1.2 million lots $14.9 billion +5% 38%+10.5% ©artprice.com/ARAA 8 STATE OF THE MARKET In 2022, a post Covid-19 rebound effect coupled with the sale of some of the most extraordinary private collections in history led the global art market to a remarkable auction turnover total. Indeed for the market’s top price bracket it was a record year with 24 lots fetching prices above $50 million. These prices rewarded extremely rare works that each had a place in art history and whose singularity and value represented ‘holy grails’ for any major collector or museum. In 2023 there were some sales of private collections, but they were much less prestigious and much less successful than those of the previous year, and the number of results above the $50 million threshold fell from 24 to just 6. Indeed, given the very high prices they fetched, the eighteen major high-end auction lots that were absent in 2023 (in a total of 763,000 lots sold) represented a shortfall of $1.46 billion versus 2022. But while such a shift in gear might have been expected, what was less expected was the complexity of the global context with the stagnation of the Ukraine-Russia war and the arrival of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. After the enthusiasm that gripped the market following the Covid-19 crisis, the art market had to adapt to a constantly disrupted macro-environment with severe economic turbulence in both Europe and the United States. Once again, the major auction houses were forced to demonstrate both flexibility and agility to adjust their activities and adapt their strategies to a downturn in the high-end market. By all accounts, they succeeded, selling more art than ever before and increasing their customer base even further. Asia restarts while the West readjusts In 2023, global art auction turnover reached $14.9 billion, which represents a slowdown of 14% compared with the preTURNOVER FROM FINE ART AND NFT SALES IN CHINA AND THE WEST 5 10 15 20 Billion ($) 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Fine Art in China ©ARAAFine Art in the West ©Artprice NFT ©Artprice ©artprice.com/ARAA 9 vious year. At the global ‘East vs. West’ level, 2023 was also similar to 2022, but in the reverse direction: while Asian markets expanded, the Western market shrank compared with its excellent results in 2022. In 2022, the American market particularly benefited from the dispersals of major collections belonging to Paul G. Allen and Thomas & Doris Ammann, which alone generated two billion dollars. And in the absence of such prestigious sales this is exactly the shortfall in 2023 compared with 2022. The American art auction turnover total, which amounted to $5.2 billion in 2023, was down -28% despite a 9% increase in the volume of transactions. The Chinese art auction market generated $4.9 billion, thereby returning to its pre-Covid level. In other Asian countries, the totals were both up and down: Japan lost 22% while South Korea contracted 49% after the previous year’s growth. India posted turnover growth of 76%. The United Kingdom, the third largest art market place in the world, posted a 15% contraction in art auction revenue (at $1.8 billion) despite a slight uptick in transactions (+5%). Like the American market, there was a general absence of supply in the market’s high-end segment. With $875 million (down 11%), France was in its customary 4th place on the global map and it is now clear that an annual total above the $1 billion threshold is well within reach for French auction operators when conditions are good. The other main European players, whose turnover is generated at more intermediate price levels, held steady or even posted better figures in 2023. Germany and Italy were stable while Belgium and Spain posted growth of +21% and +31% respectively. Reasons to remain optimistic In an uncertain environment, a drop in sales revenue is not the most important indicator. Indeed it is quite natural that enthusiasm wanes when global news deteriorates. Right now it is clear that we are witnessing renewed caution regarding the most sensitive and highly valued categories of works. After the flurry of records in an extraordinary year 2022, the bidding was, generally speaking, less flamboyant and buyers were considerably more prudent. However, the waning of post-Covid euphoria and heightened tensions in the macro-environment have not undermined the urge to buy in the majority of the art market’s segments, and the numerous sellers have provided a particularly dense offering with over a million artworks put up for auction during the year. Of the million works offered, more than 763,000 changed hands. This represents a new peak, even higher than the sales flow of 2022 which was already a historic year in terms of transactions. 2023 stands out as the most dynamic year in the history of the global art market, with more than 763,000 transactions. The fact that transaction flow is at its highest level is a testament to the energy, appetite and passion that drives the market. It’s a key sign of vitality, like the soldthrough rate, which, at more than 70% in the main Western market places (77% in the USA and 71% in the UK), is high enough to reassure sellers and it reflects a healthy equilibrium between supply and demand in the market. In addition, we have seen the number of bidders continue to grow. The main auction houses have once again recorded significant increases in the number of auction participants, particularly from the younger generations. In its end-ofyear report, Christie’s indicated a 17% increase in the number of art buyers for its 20th & 21st Century Art sales in 2023. Phillips’ end-of-year report indicates that almost half of its 2023 customers were first-time buyers and that a third of their buyers are part of generations ‘Y’ and ‘Z.’ The market is therefore continuing to evolve, driven by young art enthusiasts 10 who fully contribute to the market’s overall dynamic in a context of increasing globalization and digitalization. In 2021 and 2022, the general trend was geared towards prestige and big spending. It was a good time for sellers in possession of important high-value works, but also works created by prominent young artists whose works carry significant upside potential in terms of value. In 2023 we have seen a shift from a sellers’ market to a buyers’ market. High quality works were much rarer in 2023 and the bidding was generally less competitive compared to the previous two years. Several works by major 20th QUARTERLY EVOLUTION OF THE OVERALL AUCTION PRICE INDEX 100 200 2023 2024 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 ©artprice.com century artists like Pablo Picasso, Andy Warhol, Mark Rothko and Robert Rauschenberg sold without great enthusiasm, sometimes beneath their low estimates. At the same time, some sellers chose to remain discreet by favoring the private sales channel rather than public sales. In sum, the 2023 global art market survived without mega results or speculative buying, both of which substantially contributed to the market dynamic in the previous two years. Obliged to adapt to the new climate, the market repositioned itself to build new solid foundations while opening the field to more attractive purchasing opportunities. 11  WASSILY KANDINSKY (1866-1944) Murnau mit Kirche II (Murnau with Church II) (1910) - $44.7 million Sotheby’s, London, 1 March 2023 12 THE YEAR IN REVIEW In addition to the highlights of the traditional prestigious New York sales in May and November, a month-by-month breakdown of the year reveals the highs and lows and the strategies and expectations of the global art market. H1 2023 The art market procrastinated throughout the first half of 2023, ending the period with a 20% slowdown in global turnover (vs. H1 2022). This strong decline was due to the consignment of fewer highend and exceptional quality artworks than a year earlier. The absence of works valued at over $10 million was responsible for 87% of the contraction in the first half of the year (or -$1.4 billion). In 2023 only 0.02% of transactions were hammered in this price bracket (>$10 million) compared with 0.03% in H1 2022, and that difference was enough to reduce the halfyear result by almost $1.5 billion. Certain major artists posted drastic reduction in their auction turnovers: in H1 2023 Andy Warhol was down 89%, Mark Rothko shrank 95% and Francis Bacon’s turnover fell 73%. These contractions clearly impacted the overall H1 2023 turnover total, as did the absence of major 19th century masterpieces, notably, by Claude Monet, whose auction turnover fell 94%. However, although the best works by these major artists were absent from the prestige sales, their prices have not shown any sign of contraction. Despite the drop in global auction turnover, the overall results remained positive in a number of respects: the volume of transactions remained at an unprecedented level; the unsold rate improved slightly (from 34% in H1 2022 to 31% in H1 2023), and China’s art market considerably stabilized. The results of the American market in H1 2023 perfectly illustrated the contrast between the strength of general demand and the weakening of the high-end segment: while sales turnover declined by a quarter in H1 2023 due to the absence of exceptional collections coming onto the market (as in 2022), the overall volume of transactions increased by 3%. January The year 2023 opened with one of the most important collections of Baroque art ever to appear on the market: the 10 masterpieces from the Fisch Davidson Collection sold on January 26 by Sotheby’s generated $50 million, of which, over half was hammered for a painting by Peter Paul Rubens titled Salome presented with the Head of Saint John the Baptist (1609). The painting changed hands for $26.9 million after just two minutes of bidding, although the work was expected to fetch up to $35 million. However this timid result for a very powerful canvas was followed by a superb result for a portrait of a young man by Bronzino (stolen during WWII) that fetched double its high estimate, setting a new record for the artist at $10.6 million. March On 1 March at Sotheby’s, a monumental work by Edvard Munch joined his top-ten secondary market results, while Wassily Kandinsky reached a new auction record at nearly $44.7 million with a superb canvas from 1910, produced at a pivotal moment for the Russian painter. These two works by Munch and Kandinsky were both looted during the Second World War and recently returned to their heirs. In March, art market professionals became concerned about the risk of an increase in the import tax on works of art (20% compared to 5.5%), which would have severely undermined the competitiveness of European countries had the measure been adopted. Meanwhile, Asia Week was in full swing in New York, where Christie’s achieved an all-time record of $2.76 million for one of the best known prints of Hokusai’s Great Wave off 13 Kanagawa. The existing auction record for this iconic image by the illustrious Japanese artist climbed by more than a million dollars, Christie’s having sold another print for $1.59 million in 2021. April Sotheby’s celebrated its 50th anniversary of activity in Asia with a commemorative sale of works by Eastern and Western masters during which it fetched the highest auction price for a sculpture by Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama: $7.9 million for Pumpkin (L), a bronze work measuring almost two and a half meters high. May The American Central Bank raised its Fed Funds rate to the highest level since 2006 (source FOMC), which was not conducive to excellent sales in May. In New York, where Christie’s sales totaled HOKUSAI (1760-1849) The Great Wave off Kanagawa - $2.76 million Christie’s, New York, 21 March 2023  $1.4 billion in May 2022 (notably thanks to the Anne Bass and Doris Amman Collections), they peaked at $930 million for the two collections offered: the first, Modern and Contemporary, collected by the media mogul S.I. Newhouse, who died in 2017, did reasonably well, taking $177.8 million on 11 May. But, a few days later, the Contemporary collection put together by Gerald Fineberg, a major real estate investor who died in 2022, reached only $197 million versus Christie’s low estimate of $235 million. The collector’s heirs apparently decided to forego the minimum price guarantees offered by the auction house and third parties, which would certainly have allowed the works of Lucio Fontana, Willem de Kooning, Roy Lichtenstein, Gerhard Richter and Christopher Wool to reach at least the low estimates. Meanwhile Sotheby’s and Phillips also experienced turnover contractions with the latter dropping from $255.9 million to $108 million in May 2023 vs. May 14 2022. But the news was not all bad: Sotheby’s, for example, hammered the second best-ever result for René Magritte when his The Empire of Lights (1951) from the Mo Ostin Collection sold for $42.3 million. June On 15 June, Sotheby’s hosted a sale dedicated to the pioneers of Generative Art with works in the form of NFTs by Tyler Hobbs, Jeff Davis, Casey Reas, Hideki Tsukamoto and Dmitri Cherniak. The latter obtained a new record at $6.2 million for his NFT Ringers #879 (The Goose) (2021). At the end of the month, Sotheby’s returned to the classics and set a new record for Gustav Klimt at $108.39 million, well beyond the $82 million initially expected. In a context of market slowdown, a sale above the $100 million threshold is a reassuring sign that major collectors still have an appetite for important works. H2 2023 In the second half of 2023, global art auction turnover rose to $7.79 billion (+9.4% vs. H1 2023) thanks to renewed energy in the ultra high-end market. The presence of remarkable works, particularly in the New York and Hong Kong sales, raised the number of results above $10 million to 67, after the sharp decline during the first half of the year to 57. July London’s Old Masters sales generated a couple of surprises: on 5 July, Sotheby’s offered a painting depicting the Pentecost (circa 1490), the largest and most important work among those recognized as being by the Master of the Baroncelli Portraits. The work fetched a new record at $10 million for this little-known artist who was the presumed student of Hans Memling and whose works can be found at the MONTHLY EVOLUTION OF GLOBAL FINE ART AND NFT AUCTIONS (2023) 3 2 1 Billion ($) January February March April May June July August Septem ber October Novem ber Decem ber ©artprice.com 15  MAÎTRE DES PORTRAITS DE BARONCELLI (act. 1490) Pentecost - $10 million Sotheby’s London, 05 July 2023 16 Louvre and at the Courtauld Institute. The following day, Christie’s sold The artist’s workshop with a seamstress, a work by a long-forgotten Flemish artist, Michiel Sweets, for a record price of $16 million against a high estimate of $3.8 million. The result put The artist’s workshop with a seamstress among the year’s top results in the Old Masters category after a drawing by Wang Meng, two works by Rubens, an exceptional calligraphy by Zhao Mengfu and a set of two portraits by Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes. October On5OctoberSotheby’ssufferedanumber of disappointing results. In Hong Kong, Liu Yiqian and Wang Wei’s superb collection seemed to loose its nerve after the flagship lot, Portrait of Paulette Jourdain by Modigliani reached just $34.8 million, which was $8 million less than in 2015. Then Léonard Tsuguharu Foujita’s superb Nu au chat (1930) remained unsold despite a low estimate of $5 million, the price paid for the work in 2016. On the other hand, a monumental work by Julie Mehretu set a new record for the artist at $9.3 million on the same day. The following week in London, Sotheby’s was forced to buy in its star lot, a powerful abstraction by Gerhard Richter estimated $19 - 29 million (two other Richter works both exceeded $30 million in November). However, in the same week Christie’s London hosted totally reassuring sales that generated a higher turnover total than the same sales a year earlier: Its 20th/21st Century Art sale took $54.5 million with a sales ratio at 89% in value. The second part of the sale reserved for the Samuel Josefowitz Collection generated $63.2 million, with 90% of the lots sold in value. Offering rare works by the Nabis, the Pont-Aven school and the largest private corpus of Rembrandt engravings, the sale posted remarkable results, particularly for Kees Van Dongen’s superb painting, Tranquility, which fetched $13 million (double its high estimate), and for Félix Valloton’s Five hours (1898), which set a new auction record for the artist at $4.4 million. After the sale of Modigliani’s Portrait of Paulette Jourdain in Hong Kong, the month’s second best result was hammered in Paris for one of the most significant paintings by Joan Miró offered on the market – Peinture (femmes, lune, étoiles) (1949) – which reached $21.9 million on 20 October at Christie’s. Among nearly 50,000 artworks sold in October around the world, the 10 best results totaled $154 million, only 10 million less than in October 2022, and this recovery was the prelude to further good results in November. November In November, Christie’s and Sotheby’s together hammered $1.2 billion at their New York sales of Modern and Contemporary Art. Christie’s 20th Century Art sale on 9 November generated a total of $640.8 million and its highest result was $74 million for Claude Monet’s Bassin aux nymphéas (1917-1919), a vast canvas measuring 1 x 2 meters kept in the same family collection for 50 years. It fetched the year’s third best auction result. At Sotheby’s, the most coveted private collection of 2023, that of the late Whitney Museum patron Emily Fisher Landau, generated $424.55 million. All of the works found buyers, including nine at over $10 million and one – Pablo Picasso’s 1932 portrait of Marie-Thérèse Walter, Femme à la montre – at $139.4 million, the world’s highest art auction result in 2023. The Chara Schreyer Collection, also sold by Sotheby’s, achieved good results as well, notably $18.7 million for a key work by Frank Stella. The two auction houses subsequently hosted prestige sessions in Hong Kong with Christie’s 20th/21st Century Art Evening Sale taking $88.9 million from fifty lots, which was two million more than at the same session in November 2022. The jewel of this sale, San Yu’s Femme nue sur un tapis, fetched $24 million, $5 million above its high estimate. Lastly, we note that while the best works by Yayoi Kusuma, Yoshimoto Nara and Zao Wou-Ki appear to have motivated bidders, works 17 Auction house Title Date Sales proceeds Lotssold Unsoldlots Maximum price 1 Christie's New York 20th Century Evening Sale 9 Nov. 2023 $640,846,000 61 2 $74,010,000 2 Sotheby's New York The Emily Fisher Landau Collection: An Era Defined 8 Nov. 2023 $406,422,100 31 0 $139,363,500 3 Christie's New York 20th Century Evening Sale 11 May 2023 $328,779,600 44 12 $43,535,000 4 Sotheby's New York Modern Evening Auction 16 May 2023 $303,104,250 40 8 $53,188,500 5 Sotheby's New York Contemporary Evening Auction 15 Nov. 2023 $250,514,100 43 3 $42,000,000 6 Sotheby's London Modern and Contemporary Evening Auction 27 June 2023 $242,610,830 50 9 $108,743,230 7 Sotheby's New York Modern Evening Auction 13 Nov. 2023 $223,335,300 31 3 $30,783,000 8 Sotheby's London Modern & Contemporary Evening 1 March 2023 $191,386,640 29 7 $44,721,120 9 Christie's New York Masterpieces from the S.I. Newhouse Collection 11 May 2023 $177,792,000 16 0 $34,622,500 10 Sotheby's New York Contemporary Evening Auction 18 Mai 2023 $167,453,500 27 0 $32,804,500 TOP 10 FINE ART AND NFT AUCTION SALES (2023) ©artprice.com 18 by George Condo, Richard Prince, Rudolf Stingel, Genieve Figgis and Zhang Xiaogang received a less enthusiastic reception, sometimes leading to failed sales. December On 7 December, the dispersal of Rembrandt engravings collected by collector Sam Josefowitz resulted in three new 7-digit results at Christie’s (Saint Jerome reading in an Italian landscape, The Three Crosses, and The Three Trees). Rembrandt was also in the spotlight at Sotheby’s where his Adoration of the Magi returned to the market after being reattributed to the artist. Previously considered from the “Rembrandt Circle”, in 2021 it nevertheless soared to $992,700 versus an estimate of $11,000 at Christie’s Amsterdam. But in 2023, after its reattribution, this painting – measuring just 20 cm – sold for $13.79 million. Re-attributions of this type – involving intuition, conviction and a great deal of research – are always one of the most exciting phenomena on the art market. CLAUDE MONET (1840-1926) Le Bassin aux nymphéas (detail) - $74 million Christie's, New York, 9 November 2023  19 STRUCTURE AND EVOLUTION OF THE MARKET BY PRICE RANGE In 2023, the pace of the high-end market weakened compared with the last two years. For example, the total value of the world’s top 10 art auction results fell by 45% compared with 2022. However, activity was much more dynamic in other important price segments, including that of works valued between $100,000 and a million dollars, and the most affordable segment reached a new high point. Changes in the high-end market In 2022, the threshold of $100 million at auction was exceeded six times, which had never happened before. This year, just two works reached that level, one by Picasso and the other by Klimt, both sold through Sotheby’s. The market is therefore just as capable as last year of appreciating truly exceptional works at the highest price level. The best Modern works still sell dearly, but their rarity (like that of Post-War masterpieces as well) has reduced turnover on the most ‘high-end’ segment. The total value of artworks that fetched prices above $50 million declined by a $1.5 billion compared with last year (In 2022, 24 works valued above $50 million alone generated $1.95 billion compared with $494.5 million this year, from only six lots sold). The sale of Gustav Klimt’s last masterpiece, Lady with a Fan, brought the first half of the 2023 to a dynamic close by beating the artist’s previous record ($104.5 million) hammered in 2022 for Birch Forest from the famous Paul G. Allen Collection. Lady with a Fan is the very last work painted by Gustav Klimt and it was one of the rare portraits by the Viennese master still in private hands. Its owner had purchased the painting for approximately $10.5 million in 1994 at Sotheby’s. This time round, Lady with a Fan fetched $108.7 million, well above its $82 million high estimate, setting a new record for an artwork sold at auction in Europe. Another Modern portrait easily exceeded $100 million in 2023. Pablo Picasso’s Femme à la montre, a testimony to the artist’s passionate love for Marie-Thérèse Walter, sold for $139.4 million on 8 November, becoming the second most expensive Picasso work in auction history. The work was long the centerpiece of Emily Fisher Landau’s collection, who bought it in 1968 from collector Ernst Beyeler, himself having acquired it directly from Picaso’s studio in Mougins in 1966. The painting therefore has remarkable provenance, but also the best possible creation date as 1932 was a pivotal year in the artist’s life and his frenetic production THE THREE TRANSACTIONS ABOVE $50 MILLION IN H1 2023: $108.7 million: Lady with a Fan (1917-1918) by Gustav Klimt (Sotheby’s) $67.1 million: El Gran Espectaculo (The Nile) by Jean-Michel Basquiat (Christie’s) $53.2 million: Insel im Attersee (1901/02) by Gustav Klimt (Sotheby’s) THE THREE TRANSACTIONS ABOVE $50 MILLION IN H2 2023:: $139.3 million: Woman with watch (1932) by Pablo PICASSO (Sotheby’s) $74 million: Bassin aux Nymphéas (c.1917/19) by Claude MONET (Christie’s) $52.1 million: Figure in Movement (1976) by Francis BACON (Christie’s) 20  GUSTAV KLIMT (1862-1918) Lady with a fan (1917-1918) (detail) - $108.7 million Sotheby's London, 27 June 2023 21 in that year has already been the subject of dedicated exhibitions at the Tate Modern in London and the Picasso Museum in Paris (Picasso 1932 – Love, Fame, Tragedy and Picasso 1932. Année érotique). The high-end market relies primarily on Modern works, which, along with Post-War artworks, are the two creative periods that elicit the vast majority (65% in 2023) of the big auction results above $1 million. The other creative period most likely to elicit 7-digit results is of course Contemporary Art, which in 2023 accounted for 18% of the results in this price range, a share that is larger than the combined shares of Old Master and 19th Century Art, and which is bound to increase in the future. The dynamics of the intermediate markets One of the big positives of the global art auction market in 2023 was the 21% progression of transactions on works valued between $100,000 and $1 million compared to the previous year. This price range was nourished by the works of great Chinese artists from the 20th century, first and foremost Qi Baishi, Zhang Daqian, Wu Guanzhong, Huang Binhong, Lin Fengmian, Xu Beihong and Li Keran. In the Western art market, the most successful artists in the $100K – $1 million bracket were also mainly major 20th century signatures like Andy Warhol, Yayoi Kusama, Pablo Picasso, NUMBER OF 7-DIGIT AUCTION RESULTS PER CREATIVE PERIOD IN 2013 VS 2023 203 156 157 105 863 590 352 417 275 282 500 1000 1500 2000 2013 2023 Old masters 19th century Modern art Post-War art Contemporary art ©artprice.com 22 François-Xavier Lalanne, Marc Chagall and Fernando Botero. The vitality of this market segment, which generated 14,588 transactions in 2023, came 40% from China and 60% from the West. In fact, the lower the price bracket, the denser the transactions, so the volume of works valued between $20,000 and $100,000 was three times higher than in all the higher price ranges combined, increasing by 18% in 2023 (vs. 2022) with 41,871 transactions (or 5% of global art auction transactions. This price bracket was, once again, generously fueled with works by Andy Warhol, Pablo Picasso, Yayoi Kusama, as well as Qi Baishi, Zhang Daqian and Pu Ru from China. However, it offered exceptional diversity, notably with works by the Russian Constructivist Liubov Sergeevna Popova, the Czech Surrealist Frantisek Muzica, the Aboriginal artist Rover Thomas as well as several Indian artists like Bharti Kher, Kattingeri Krishna Hebbar and Jangarh Singh Shyam. High transaction volume at the low end The reality of the global art market is its accessibility since 90% of its transactions involved lots that sold for under $12,000. The growth in global demand and the opening of the market to young buyers via online sales has ensured constant growth in sales in the most affordable price segments for 15 years. The most remarkable acceleration concerns the least expensive works, those selling for less than $1,000, which generated nearly 423,000 transactions in 2023. Driven by exceptional growth of 65% since the digital acceleration of the market in 2020, transactions 90% of lots sold for less than $11,875 70% of lots sold for less than $2,032 50% of lots sold for less than $700 132 LOTS ≥ $10 million 2 LOTS ≥ $100 million AFFORDABLE MARKET HIGH-END MARKET GLOBAL FINE ART AND NFT AUCTION MARKET BREAKDOWN BY PRICE RANGE (2023) ©artprice.com/ARAA 23 below $1,000 represent more than half of global transactions (55%) and above all reached a historic peak in 2023. 2023 was historic in terms of the number of works sold for less than $1,000, with nearly 423,000 transactions. Salvador Dali, Victor Vasarely and Ber- nardBuffetwereamongthekeysignatures in this first price bracket under $1,000 thanks to the numerous serigraphs, lithographs and engravings that these artists produced. This affordable segment is of little interest to the most powerful auction houses. Christie’s, Phillips and Sotheby’s prefer to devote their energies to the high and mid-range markets. The segment is therefore occupied by other auction operators such as the Japanese company, Mainichi Auction, the Irish firm, Morgan O’Driscoll Fine Art Auctioneers, the Italian auctioneer, Studio d’Arte Borromeo, the French auction operator, Millon & Associés and even the Polish company, Desa Unicum, all of which contributed to the segment’s dynamic around the world. Geography of the global art market and its principal auction houses 25 THE MOST DYNAMIC COUNTRIES IN THE FINE ART AND NFT AUCTION MARKET (2023) UNITED STATES $5.2 billion UNITED KINGDOM $1.8 billion CHINA $4.9 billion INDIA $152 million JAPAN $144 million GERMANY $372 million FRANCE $875 million ITALY $197 million SWITZERLAND $125 million ©artprice.com/ARAA 26 THE TOP PERFORMING COUNTRIES China was the only country among the top five powers in the art market (which accounted for 89% of the global results) to record an increase in revenue from art auction sales. Nevertheless, the United States remained the world’s strongest art marketplace despite a 28% fall in its annual turnover in 2023. This drop in turnover was notably due to the comparatively poor performance of Christie’s New York following the most successful year in its history, having sold three firstrate American collections in 2022. The United States contracts by $2 billion The American market was still the most dynamic, accounting for 23% of global transactions as well as the vast majority of the best results. New York alone accounted for 39 of the 50 key results of the year, several of which involved works by Picasso, Basquiat, Richter, Magritte, and Mitchell. However, the absence of sales as exceptional as last year’s, i.e. the private collections of Thomas & Doris Ammann, Anne H. Bass and Paul G. Allen (which alone generated in $2.4 billion via Christie’s New York in 2022), mechanically reduced the American result by two billion dollars from $7.3 billion to $5.2 billion in 2023. The United States’ market share dropped from 44% to 35% of global auction turnover, while China’s market and global market share recovered, posting better results than in 2022. Lots of works (sold and unsold) in China The second largest market in the world, the Chinese art auction market posted just under 5 billion ($4.95 billion) in turnover, a recovery driven by the dispersal of important private collections and the return of some exceptional works to auction podiums. Several creations by great Chinese artists like Wang Meng, Cui Ruzhuo, Zhang Daqian, Zhao Mengfu, San Yu and Fu Baoshi exceeded 10 million dollars in Beijing and Hong Kong, the two main cities of the Chinese auction market. But while China’s high-end market appeared to recover, the very dense offerings from auction houses seemed to overwhelm Chinese buyers and the 195,000 lots offered in China generated a particularly high number of unsold items, despite an overall increase in transactions (+33%). Indeed, in this respect, the trend TOP 5 CHINESE CITIES BY AUCTION TURNOVER (2023) BEIJING $2.5 billion |35,494 lots sold HONG KONG SHANGHAI GUANGDONG ZHEJIANG $1.5 billion |6,596 lots sold $346 million |6,055 lots sold $216.6 million |7,983 lots sold $187.4 million |5,627 lots sold ©ARAA 27 was the opposite to the global average, since China posted a 64% unsold rate compared to a 38% average for the global art auction market. The UK market has shrunk since Brexit The United Kingdom, which generated 20% of global art auction turnover in 2018, only accounted for 12% in 2023. The London market has indeed shrunk since Brexit, which has mainly affected transactions between the United Kingdom and the European Union since European buyers and sellers wishing to transport a work to, or from, the UK must now fulfill customs formalities and pay VAT. The heavier procedure and expenses has led to a contraction of consignments from Europe. On the buyers’ side, Europeans will also tend to avoid raising bids too high, knowing that they will then have to pay additional costs to repatriate the work to Europe. Totaling $1.8 billion in 2023, the UK’s art auction turnover shrank 15% in value versus 2022, but above all, now posts a 33% contraction since 2018. However, among the positive points, we found a slight increase in the volume of British transactions over the financial year (+5%) and above all a sold-through rate (71%) that substantially exceeded the global average (62%). The third largest marketplace in the world also retained its capacity to attract some of the most prestigious and valued works on the planet. Although they were few and far between in 2023, the most remarkable – the extraordinary Klimt painting – sold for more than $108 million – illustrating the Artist Artwork Price Auction House Date 1 Yayoi KUSAMA Summer and Butterfly (1989) $18,500 Shinwa Tokyo 14 apr. 2007 $966,620 Christie's Hong Kong 24 sept. 2023 2 Nicole EISENMAN Support Systems for Women, No. 1 (1998) $10,800 Phillips de Pury New York 17 nov. 2006 $400,780 Sotheby's London 13 oct. 2023 3 Kazuo SHIRAGA Hiryu (Flying Dragon) (1988) $19,200 Christie's New York 28 march 2006 $614,070 Christie's Hong Kong 28 nov. 2023 4 Lucio FONTANA Concetto spaziale, La fine di Dio (1963) $684,310 Christie's London 6 dec. 2000 $20,556,900 Sotheby's New York 15 nov. 2023 5 ZAO Wou-Ki 17.01.60 (1960) $69,750 Sotheby's New York 15 nov. 2000 $2,061,170 Sotheby's Hong Kong 5 apr. 2023 6 Maqbool Fida HUSAIN Untitled (The Musician) $10,800 Sotheby's New York 15 oct. 2001 $277,940 Sotheby's London 24 oct. 2023 7 Frantisek KUPKA Compotier aux Pommes $29,520 Sotheby's London 29 march 2000 $756,000 William Doyle New York 17 may 2023 8 Pietro BELLOTTI The Parca Lachesis $13,750 John Moran Monrovia 26 apr. 2023 $304,080 Sotheby's London 7 dec. 2023 9 Elizabeth PEYTON David, Victoria and Brooklyn (1999) $94,000 Christie's New York 17 may 2001 $2,052,180 Sotheby's London 12 oct. 2023 10 Cy TWOMBLY Untitled (1970) $776,000 Christie's New York 13 nov. 2001 $11,425,090 Sotheby's London 27 june 2023 TOP 5 RESALES OF WORKS THAT HAVE CHANGED COUNTRIES ©artprice.com 28  ANNE VALLAYER-COSTER (1744-1818) Nature morte au vase d’albâtre rempli de fleurs avec sur une table plusieurs espèces de fruits, comme ananas, pêches et raisins (1783) - $2.8 million Christie’s, Paris, 15 June 2023 29 continued prestige of the London market, and it raised the record auction price for an artwork sold in Europe. France asserts itself The French market relies primarily on its local supply. Indeed, France has a dense art auction market (the second largest after the United States with 106,400 lots sold in 2023), that is gaining strength in the high-end segment as well. Looking at the decade, the turnover from sales of artworks in France has increased by 72% with a significant increase in the number of 7-digit results (by approximately 80%) compared to the years 2011-2014. In addition, big results exceeding $10 million have started to become regular occurrences since 2017, whereas they were the exclusive prerogative of the UK and American markets in the early 2000s. In 2023, the highest art auction price on the French market stood at $21.9 million for a painting by Joan Miró (Painting (women, moon, stars), 1949). Although it is far from the $108.7 million for the Klimt painting sold in London, this result is nevertheless remarkable compared with other European players. After the work by Miró, the second best French result went to François-Xavier Lalanne for an exceptional Rhinocrétaire from 1964. This rhino concealing a desk, a bar and a safe in its metal sides prompted bidding up to $19.4 million in October, at three times Christie’s high estimate. The daring works by François-Xavier Lalanne have continued to gain value over the last fifteen years, distinguishing the artist as the most successful on the French art market for the second consecutive year, with an annual auction turnover exceeding 50 million dollars. While the local market is supplied by great French artists (including a work by Fragonard kept in the same family for more than a century, and one of the most beautiful paintings known by Anne Vallayer-Coster), French collections also bring together artists of very varied origins, periods and styles, such as the Spaniard Joan Miró, the Belgian René Magritte, the American Joan Mitchell, the British Francis Bacon, the Italian Lucio Fontana, the Romanian Adrian Ghenie and the Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama, who generated the best results on the French market in 2023. 30 OUR GLOBAL RANKING OF AUCTION HOUSES In 2022, Christie’s generated the lion’s share of global art auction turnover with the exceptional sales of the Paul G. Allen ($1.6 billion) and Bass & Amman Collections contributing to the firm’s annual art auction turnover total of $5.8 billion. Without such ‘power’ sales in 2023, Christie’s annual total (Fine Art + NFT) fell by more than two billion, to $3.5 billion. The drop is around -40%, or, if we exclude the very exceptional Paul G. Allen sale from the equation, around -16%. Meanwhile, Sotheby’s, under the leadership of Patrick Drahi, posted stable results at $3.8 billion (only down 2%) and took global first place. With a combined annual sales turnover total of $7.3 billion, Christie’s and Sotheby’s hammered a little less than half of the global art auction turnover ($14.9 billion) in 2023, compared with more than 70% at the start of the millennium, that is to say, before the blossoming of the Chinese market. Flexibility at Christie’s and Sotheby’s The two companies demonstrated considerable agility to avoid subjecting sellers, or the artists’ markets, to a lack of interest in certain lots. In some cases they lowered their reserve prices, in others, lots were withdrawn at the last minute from the May sales to counter the risk of unsold items or disappointing results. In May, Sotheby’s Now sale finally took place without its flagship lot, a painting by Yoshitomo Nara announced on the cover of the catalog and estimated between $12 and $18 million. As of the Spring sales, the major auction houses showed prudence, anticipation and TOP 7 AUCTION HOUSES BY FINE ART AND NFT AUCTION TURNOVER (2023) AUCTION HOUSE Sotheby’s Christie’s Phillips China Guardian Poly Auction Bonhams Beijing Rongbao SALES PROCEEDS $3.8 billion $3.5 billion $573 million $539 million $517.7 million $219.3 million $216 million LOTS SOLD 15,101 13,353 6,586 8,490 6,512 13,544 3,005 ©artprice.com/ARAA 31 patience which allowed them to navigate a transition phase with contradictory signals without too much damage. It wasn’t until November that Christie’s and Sotheby’s hosted their best sessions of the year ($640.8 million for Christie’s 20th Century Art Evening Sale and $406.4 million for Sotheby’s Landau Collection sale). Phillips posts remarkable sold-through rates Phillips remained the third biggest art auction vendor in the world with total proceeds for 2023 of $573 million. But, after an exceptional year 2022 in which it hammered its best-ever result ($85 million for a painting by Jean-Michel Basquiat), its 2023 art auction turnover total shrank by 21%. For several years now, the company has managed to offer important works by major artists. In 2023, its best result came from a Gerhard Richter painting that fetched $34.8 million (Abstraktes Bild (636), 1987). This painting was part of a November sale that generated the second highest result in Phillips’ history: $155 million (up +11% compared with November 2022). In addition, Phillips has further expanded its customer base – around half of buyers in 2023 were firsttime buyers, including a third of millennial and generation Z collectors – and it announced sold-through rates above 90% for its 20th Century and Contemporary Art sales. Bonhams sells more works than Christie’s worldwide The fourth Western art auction vendor in the world by turnover, Bonhams appears not to have suffered in any way from the vagaries of the market and it even progressed slightly compared with 2022, posting an annual total of $219 million. To that sum we must add $54 million following the recent acquisition of the auction companies Bukowskis, Skinner, Bruun Rasmussen and Cornette de SaintCyr. These operators form a vast network of auction rooms which strengthens Bonhams’ activity in the growing affordable and mid-market segments (prices below 1 million dollars). With more than 19,000 works sold via its global network, Bonhams was also the most dynamic company in terms of transaction volumes. The top Chinese auctioneers China Guardian and Poly Auction, the two most powerful auction companies in China, totaled $1.2 billion from 15,000 lots sold in total, including eight for more than $10 million. The highest result of the year was $40.5 million for Inkstone washing by Wang Meng, a major artist active in the 14th century and whose work was sold at the end of November at China Guardian. The most remarkable results are not only the prerogative of these two leading companies since Yongle managed to sell a drawing by Cui Ruzhuo for $33 million (Rafting In Wind And Rain). Yongle ultimately sells few works compared to its competitors (including Beijing Rongbao and Xiling), but it presents Chinese artists closely followed by the country’s collectors (both for Classic and Contemporary works) while also offering Western works, particularly since its alliance with Phillips in 2022. 32  WANG MENG (1308-1385) Inkstone washing - $40.5 million China Guardian Auctions, Beijing, 30 November 2023 Questions & Answers Artron Research Academy of Arts Overview of the Chinese art market in 2023 34 Fine Art auctions got back on a growth trajectory in the Chinese mainland. What were the main drivers of this recovery? The recovery of fine art auctions in the Chinese mainland in 2023 was driven by several factors. First of all, China’s economy maintained stable growth in 2023, which was good news for the art auction market as well. In addition, people’s awareness of cultural and artwork consumption continued to grow, and they were more inclined to spend money on cultural goods to meet their aesthetic needs, pursue cultural connotations, and improve their quality of life by including art in their lifestyle. Secondly, political support for culture and the art market provided a favorable environment for the recovery of fine art auctions. In recent years, the Chinese government has launched a series of policies in the cultural sector to encourage the art industry and increase spending on cultural goods. Further, the development of the Greater Bay Area played a big part: The Greater Bay Area, including Hong Kong and Macao, is one of the new drivers of economic growth in the Chinese mainland. As the Greater Bay Area develops, its arts and culture market has also been expanding. At the same time, art capital from places like Shanghai and Beijing is also testing the waters and exploring the Bay Area market. Finally, the Chinese art market continued to see a growing pool of collectors and investors, and as the market continued to grow, more and more collectors and investors entered the market, and their demand for high-end art increased, further fuelling the recovery of fine art auctions. What were the highlights of the Chinese art market in 2023? Are the major auctions scheduled in relation to other events (e.g. art fairs)? The auction calendar is not directly related to the holding of Art Fairs and is mainly determined according to its own collection and sales status. Primarily, the highlight of the Chinese art market in 2023 was that the contemporary art market received high attention and collectors were more enthusiastic about participating. The sales of contemporary artworks were particularly impressive. As China’s economy develops and the concept of art collecting becomes increasingly popular, more collectors have turned their attention to contemporary artworks. Christie’s Hong Kong launched the Post-Millennium Evening Sale, Sotheby’s Hong Kong the Contemporary Art Evening Sale, China Guardian the Impressionist and Modern Art Evening Sale, Beijing Poly the Chinese New Painting Evening Sale, etc., and many post-1990s artists such as Sun Yidian, Zhang Zipiao, and Ji Xin have achieved brilliant results. Also, auction houses were bold in terms of innovating their services, and more auctions adopted new service models such as online auctions. These models not only provide a more convenient way to bid but also expand the coverage of the market and attract more young collectors to participate. The rise of online auctions makes the business of auction houses no longer subject to geographical restrictions, further enhancing the transaction rate and providing participants with a better service experience. Furthermore, the Chinese art auction market in 2023 saw a decline in the number of lots in the highest price ranges. The transaction rate of lots in the middle price range increased, exceeding expectations and boosting the market. The middleand low-end auction market became an active area for transactions, indicating that collectors have become more cautious when purchasing art. 35 Zhang Daqian and Qi Baishi are once again among the top ten in terms of total global auction sales. What do you think about their status in art history? Zhang Daqian and Qi Baishi are two of the greatest masters in the history of Chinese art, and their works are highly regarded not only in China but also in the international art market. Zhang Daqian was one of the most representative Chinese painters in the 20th century - his works have a distinctive style, and are dynamic and ethereal. His landscapes, figures, and bird-and-flower paintings are all unique, especially his splashed-ink works, which contain rich cultural connotations. They illustrate not only the pursuit of natural beauty, but also the reflection and expression of Chinese cultural tradition and history. He applied the techniques of Western abstract expressionism and combined them with the splashed-ink technique of traditional Chinese painting to create brand-new visual effects. He held many exhibitions of his paintings overseas, contributing to the proliferation and promotion of Chinese culture. According to data from the Artron Research Academy of Arts (ARAA), in 2023, a total of 3,531 works by Zhang Daqian were put up for auction in the records of the 100 sample companies of Artron, and 998 of them were sold, totaling 377 million US dollars. Qi Baishi is one of the most important figures of Chinese flower-and-bird paintings in the 20th century. His works use bright colors, concise and powerful lines, and clever compositions, and are full of vitality and academic precision. Qi Baishi was famous for his comprehensive painting skills, including fine brushwork in his landscape paintings (Gongbi1 and Xieyi2 ) and figure paintings, etc., with his flower-and-bird paintings being particularly 1 Traditional Chinese painting method characterized by meticulous brush technique and detailed descriptions. (TN) 2 This style of painting uses numerous calligraphy techniques which favor the spontaneity of the line. (TN) outstanding. He also achieved quite distinctive accomplishments in seal carving and calligraphy. His seal carving art is one of the most important in the history of Chinese seal carving. In addition, Qi Baishi also made great achievements in calligraphy, and his calligraphy works are deeply loved and admired. He was best at Semi-cursive script and Seal script (script styles in Chinese calligraphy), of which his Semi-cursive script is characterized by grandeur and vividness, and his Seal script has a precise and rigorous structure. According to data, in 2023, ARAA recorded a total of 2,676 auctioned works for Qi Baishi, 962 of which were sold, earning 248 million US dollars. These two artists not only made outstanding contributions to the development of Chinese painting, but also made important contributions to the development of art history. Their works have been widely collected and exhibited, becoming treasures of Chinese art. Three works of Sara Hughes (1971) were sold in Beijing and Shanghai for a total price of 1.4 million US dollars in 2023. Are there any other works of Western artists that are particularly sought after by Chinese collectors? In recent years, auction houses have shown a strong market-driven trend in their selection of lots to meet the needs of a new generation of customers and the younger aesthetic standards that are being injected into the market. Most of the record-breaking post-1990s artists in 2023 were newcomers to the market. Some of them put their works up for auction for the first time, and some provided relatively few works. It can be seen that auction houses have been continuously strengthening their efforts to explore post- 1990s artists in recent years. Among the top 10 foreign artists on the record-breaking list of transactions, 9 of them sold their works in Hong Kong salesrooms, including Sotheby’s Hong Kong, Christie’s Hong Kong, Phillips Hong Kong, and Poly Hong Kong. Among them, Japanese artists made up 36 the highest number, with a total of three on the list. In addition, there were also artists from the UK, France, the US, and Poland. In addition to Sara Hughes, there were also six works by Lucy Bull, with an annual total transaction price of 5,357,700 US dollars. Her work “Flash Chamber” created in 2020 had the highest transaction value of the annual post-1990s artists’ works. After 21 rounds of bidding, the work was finally sold for 1,918,900 US dollars. Jadé Fadojutimi’s works were sold for a total price of 3,228,700 US dollars in 2023, and her works broke records constantly in 2023. Michaela Yearwood-Dan’s works grossed 896,200 US dollars at the 2023 Chinese art auction market, with a total of three works being auctioned, all of which sold. She featured plants and poetry in her works and explored many diverse themes. Furthermore, the works of Diane Dalpra, Emi Kuraya, a representative of the new-generation of artists in Japan, the British artist Felix Treadwell, who was once rated as a “young artist worthy of attention” by a British magazine, Japanese artist Ryoko Kaneta, and Oh de Laval, a representative of the new-generation post- 1990s female artists, were all favoured by Chinese collectors. This year, the market for Chinese ultra-contemporary artists (born in the 1980s) was particularly active. Can you introduce the works of Chen Fei (1983) and his performance at the 2023 auction? Chen Fei has gained a high level of popularity and influence in the contemporary art world of China thanks to his works featuring unique styles and innovative media. Chen Fei’s works cover multiple fields such as painting, sculpture, installation, and architecture, and show strong colors combinations and contemporary regional characteristics - at the same time combining traditional Chinese art with modern aesthetic concepts. At the 2023 salesrooms, Chen Fei’s works demonstrated considerable value and potential. His works received high attention from collectors and investors, and set high transaction records multiple times. In 2023, Chen Fei had a total of 19 works put up for auction, with 14 of them sold, accounting for 73.68%, and a total transaction amount of 5,028,900 US dollars. Among them, “Stars Pile Up All Over the Sky (Diptych)” became the highest-priced work, and was sold at the China Guardian Auctions for 1,218,800 US dollars. 37 GEOGRAPHIC DEVELOPMENTS IN THE MARKET The Art Market is today globalized with live sales that allow auction houses to reach collectors from all over the world at the same event. Although – technically speaking – the whole world can participate in such sales, the global map of the art market is constantly shifting, sometimes to the point of reversing certain balances of power. London increasingly squeezed In London, where 96% of the UK’s art auction turnover is hammered, the main players in the market – Christie’s, Sotheby’s and Phillips – have seen their results decline in recent years. The contraction versus 2022 (-16%) is not particularly worrying in itself as it is cyclical and common to several major market places, but if we look back further we see a less positive picture. Over five years, London’s art auction turnover has dropped 35% and if we compare it to 2008 (its highest level at $3.4 billion) it has dropped by approximately 50%. Meanwhile, the volume of art auction turnover has been gradually rising in Paris (since Brexit) and in Hong Kong it has tripled in fifteen years. London’s loss of momentum stems from the fact that it is no longer only in competition with New York for the dispersal of very fine works; it is also increasingly competing with Paris and Hong Kong. Asian collectors, particularly Chinese, play an important role in the sale of the most expensive works. Sotheby’s reports, for example, that 32% of collectors who have placed bids on works of art exceeding $1 million over the past five years are Asian, a share almost equal to that of American collectors and slightly higher than that of Europeans. For example, the most expensive work sold in London in 2023, Klimt’s Lady with a Fan, was acquired by Patti Wong for $108.39 million on behalf of a Hong Kong collector. While London remains an essential market place for the top quality works, particularly Modern and 20th Century art, the main auction houses are investing heavily elsewhere, thereby modifying the landscape of the global art market, particularly in Asia. Hong Kong’s confirms its power of attraction The second Chinese city after Beijing in terms of art auction turnover, Hong Kong’s auction rooms hammered over $1.5 billion in 2023. After the lifting of Covid restrictions, a renewed energy was reflected in the city’s spring sales and its turnover rose sharply by 33.7% compared with 2022. This progression was driven by superb works by artists of Chinese origin like Zhang Daqian and San Yu as well as by Western masterpieces by Amedeo Modigliani, Pablo Picasso and a number of Ultra-contemporaries. Several sales sessions brought together particularly desirable works, notably Christie’s selections for 20th and 21st Century Art in May and November. One of the jewels of these sales was San Yu’s Femme nue sur un tapis (Nude on Tapestry) which fetched $24 million, one of the artist’s top-ten auction results. On 28 November, Christie’s hosted a small live auction titled Post-Millennium in collaboration with Taiwanese pop star Jay Chou that raised $15.2 million, a third of which ($5.5 million) came from a painting by Adrian Ghenie (b. 1977) titled Lidless Eye inspired by Van Gogh’s iconic Self-portrait. Very popular among Asian buyers, the Romanian artist owes his personal auction record to a Christie’s Hong Kong sale in 2022 when his Pie Fight Interior 12 (2014) fetched $10.3 million. The sale commemorating Sotheby’s 50th anniversary in Asia totaled $85 million, 38  AMEDEO MODIGLIANI (1884-1920) Paulette Jourdain (1919) - $34.8 million Sotheby's, Hong Kong, 5 October 2023 39 including $32 million for Pink Lotuses on Gold Screen by Zhang Daqian. It was the artist’s third-best auction result; his best and second-best were also hammered at Sotheby’s. A superb work by Joan Miró set a new record for the artist in Asia after a bidding battle of nearly 20 minutes and a work by Yayoi Kusama set a new record in sculpture for the artist at $7.9 million (Pumpkin (L), 2014). Other remarkable results were hammered for works by women artists, Louise Bonnet, Lucy Bull, Loie Hollowell and Lynne Drexler, substantially above their estimates. The other highlight of Sotheby’s Asia was the dispersal of the collection belonging to the billionaire founders of the Long Museum in Shanghai, Liu Yiqian and Wang Wei. The session set an auction record for Modigliani in Asia (even if the superb Portrait of Paulette Jourdain was expected to fetch a few million dollars more) and generated the best-ever sales total for a private collection sold in Asia at $69.5 million. In 2023, Sotheby’s was the top performing art auctioneer in Hong Kong with $531 million (14% of its global fine art turnover) while Christie’s hammered $408 million (11% of its global fine art turnover) in the city. If we add Phillips’s fast-growing Hong Kong activity, the cumulative result of the three auction companies exceeded one billion dollars and accounted for 67.5% of Hong Kong’s art auction market in 2023, substantially ahead of the main Chinese players, China Guardian and Poly International. The third non-Chinese auction house in Hong Kong, Phillips is entering a new era. Having inaugurated its Asian headquarters in Hong Kong in the spring, it is becoming a more serious competitor in the region. The company hosted its first auction on the Asian market in 2015 before establishing itself in Shanghai in 2018 and then establishing a strategic cooperation with the Chinese auction house Yongle in 2022, in order to pool their resources and develop their markets. At the end of March, Phillips hosted its inaugural art sale of 20th Century and Contemporary Art in its new Hong Kong headquarters, taking a total of $45 million, an increase of 65% compared with the previous year. GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF FINE ART + NFT AUCTION TURNOVER HAMMERED BY SOTHEBY’S, CHRISTIE’S AND PHILLIPS (2023) Dubai Zurich Amsterdam Singapore Cologne Shanghai Milan Paris Hong Kong London New York $500 million $1 billion $1.5 billion $2 billion $2.5 billion Sotheby’s Christie’s Phillips ©artprice.com 40  AMRITA SHER-GIL (1913-1941) The Story teller (1937) - $7.4 million Saffronart, Bombay, 16 September 2023 41 In March, Phillips opened its new Asian headquarters in a beautiful building in Hong Kong. In 2023, Phillips generated 17.4% ($100 million) of its global art auction turnover in Hong Kong and its overall performance in the city was 6% better than the previous year. The upside potential would appear to be substantial as the company is banking on the growing number of young collectors (from mainland China or Hong Kong itself) who are strongly interested in Contemporary Art, the segment where Phillips is most specialized. India: the surprise of the year The Indian art market has shown relatively discreet growth on an international scale, with the acceleration in its art auction turnover being mainly driven by the major Indian signatures of the 20th century like Vasudeo S. Gaitonde, Sayed Haider Raza and Tyeb Mehta. In 2023, works by all these artists generated results above the million-dollar threshold. However, it is a female artist, India’s ‘national treasure’ Amrita Sher-Gil – whose career was short, but dense (she died at the age of 28) – who elicited India’s best result of the year for her The Story teller (1937). Sold for $7.4 million, the painting dethroned a previous auction record hammered in New York in 2015, generating the best art auction result ever hammered in India. The vitality of the Indian market was also surprising in other respects, notably for its exceptional sold-through rate above 95% when the global average (China included) was 62%. The supply was tight (less than 2,200 lots offered in 2023) but perfectly adjusted to a competitive demand, and it gave India seventh place in our global ranking of countries by their art auction turnover. The $152 million hammered over the year represented a sharp increase of 76% versus 2022, which was already a record year. Artist Sales proceeds Lots sold Unsold lots Maximum price 1 Sayed Haider RAZA $15,171,560 49 0 $6,258,645 2 Raja RAVI VARMA $14,642,680 8 0 $5,286,826 3 Francis Newton SOUZA $11,536,120 70 5 $4,172,430 4 Vasudeo S. GAITONDE $8,550,860 9 1 $5,745,600 5 Tyeb MEHTA $8,506,250 7 1 $3,573,912 6 Maqbool Fida HUSAIN $7,947,630 76 9 $870,749 7 Amrita SHER-GIL $7,872,830 10 0 $7,432,686 8 Akbar PADAMSEE $6,745,790 19 0 $3,107,002 9 Ram KUMAR $4,611,320 74 1 $595,650 10 Manjit BAWA $3,591,990 9 0 $3,011,086 TOP 10 ARTISTS BY AUCTION TURNOVER IN INDIA (2023) ©artprice.com The artists and works that marked the year 43 THE RELATIVE MARKET WEIGHT OF THE DIFFERENT CREATIVE PERIODS In 2023, an exceptional quantity of artworks changed hands in all segments of the market (notably Old Master Art, 19 Century Art, Modern Art, Post-War Art, Contemporary Art). This excellent transaction dynamic suggests that supply was well balanced with strong demand. On the other hand, sales revenues were down because the market presented fewer major works than last year. Only the Old Masters segment progressed versus 2022 with an annual result up 18% versus the previous year, notably thanks to the sale of works by Goya and Rembrandt and two paintings by Rubens, which gave Sotheby’s the world leader position on Old Masters last year. Old Masters (artists born before 1760) The world’s best result in the Old Masters segment this year was hammered for an ink drawing made more than 600 years ago by Wang Meng. It was not a record for this artist (a larger work having reached $62.1 million in 2011 in Beijing), but it marked the strong return of top quality works on the Chinese market. In the West, Rubens was the dominant signature with his Salome Presented With the Head of John the Baptist (1609) from the Fisch Davidson Collection, and his Portrait of a Man as the God Mars (c.1620). The former had not appeared at auction since 30 January 1998 when it sold for $5.5 million (Sotheby’s NY). Fetching $26.9 million on 26 January 2023, its value grew more than $21 million in a quarter of a century. The latter work also substantially re-valued: acquired for $6.8 million at Sotheby’s in 2002, it fetched $26.2 million last year. These two results – plus seven others – allowed the master of Flemish baroque art to post an annual turnover of $62 million, Rubens’ third best-ever annual total. GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF FINE ART AND NFT AUCTION TURNOVER BY CREATIVE PERIOD (2023) 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% United States United Kingdom Hong Kong France Germany India Belgium Old masters 19th century Modern art Post-War art Contemporary art ©artprice.com 44 Artist Artwork Price Date Auction House 1 WANG Meng Inkstone washing $40,562,800 30 Nov. 2023 China Guardian Beijing 2 Peter Paul RUBENS Salome presented with the head of Saint John the Baptist $26,926,000 26 Jan. 2023 Sotheby's New York 3 Peter Paul RUBENS Portrait of a Man as Mars (c.1620) $26,187,000 16 May 2023 Sotheby's New York 4 ZHAO Mengfu Calligraphy in regular script (1302/1322) $25,070,780 5 July 2023 Poly Beijing 5 Francisco GOYA Portrait of Doña María Vicenta Barruso Valdés (1805) $16,420,000 25 Jan. 2023 Christie's New York 6 Michiel SWEERTS The Artist’s Studio with a Seamstress $16,056,160 6 July 2023 Christie's London 7 REMBRANDT VAN RIJN Portrait of Jan Willemsz. van der Pluym (c.1565-1644), bustlength/Portrait of Jaapgen Carels (1565-1640), bust-length $14,299,720 6 July 2023 Christie's London 8 REMBRANDT VAN RIJN The Adoration of the Kings $13,793,700 6 Dec. 2023 Sotheby's London 9 Giovanni Antonio CANAL Venice: The Mouth of the Grand Canal from the East/The Molo, with the Piazzetta and the Doge’s Palace, from the Bacino $12,274,110 7 Dec. 2023 Christie's London 10 Agnolo BRONZINO Portrait of a young man with a quill and a sheet of paper, possibly a self-portrait of the artist $10,665,500 26 Jan. 2023 Sotheby's New York TOP 10 RESULTS FOR OLD MASTER WORKS SOLD AT AUCTION IN 2023 ©artprice.com 45 After the two Rubens works, the year’s third best result in the OM segment was hammered for a work by the Chinese artist ZHAO Mengfu, a great scholar of the Yuan dynasty, whose calligraphies are veritable treasures for Chinese collectors. The one offered in July by Poly International in Beijing, Calligraphy in regular script (1302/1322), fetched $25 million, in line with sums paid for the artist’s very best works. One of the surprises of the year was the appearance of Michiel Sweets among the segments top results. This Flemish artist, who was largely forgotten after his death, is currently being reconsidered as one of the most creative artists of the 17th century. In 2023, his new auction record at $16 million (four times its high estimate), put him ahead of his contemporary Rembrandt. 19th Century Art (artists born between 1760 and 1860) In 2023, it was unlikely that 19th Century Art would be as fully represented at auction as it was in 2022 when the segment generated over two billion dollars for the first time largely thanks to the dispersal of the Paul G. Allen collection. In 2022, that sale generated the majority of the segment’s remarkable auction results, notably with George Seurat’s Les Poseuses at $149.24 million, Paul Cézanne’s La Montagne Sainte-Victoire at $137.79 million, Vincent Van Gogh’s Verger avec cyprès at $117 million, Paul Gauguin’s Maternity II at $105.7 million, Claude Monet’s Waterloo Bridge, soleil voilé at $64.5 million and Artist Artwork Price Date Auction House 1 Claude MONET Le bassin aux nymphéas (c.1917/19) $74,010,000 9 Nov. 2023 Christie's New York 2 LE DOUANIER ROUSSEAU Les Flamants (1910) $43,535,000 11 May 2023 Christie's New York 3 Paul CÉZANNE Fruits et pot de gingembre (1890/93) $38,935,000 9 Nov. 2023 Christie's New York 4 Claude MONET Peupliers au bord de l’Epte, temps couvert (1891) $30,783,000 13 Nov. 2023 Sotheby's New York 5 Claude MONET Le Moulin de Limetz (1888) $25,612,500 13 Nov. 2023 Sotheby's New York 6 Vincent VAN GOGH Jardin devant le Mas Debray (1887) $23,314,500 16 May 2023 Sotheby's New York 7 Pierre-Auguste RENOIR Square de la Trinité (1878-1879) $11,910,000 11 May 2023 Christie's New York 8 Claude MONET Au Cap Martin (1884) $11,479,800 16 May 2023 Sotheby's New York 9 Paul GAUGUIN Nature morte avec pivoines de chine et mandoline (1885) $10,445,700 16 May 2023 Sotheby's New York 10 Paul CÉZANNE Quatre pommes et un couteau (c.1885) $10,415,000 9 Nov. 2023 Christie's New York TOP 10 RESULTS IN 19TH CENTURY ART (2023) ©artprice.com 46  PETER PAUL RUBENS (1577-1640) Salome Presented With the Head of John the Baptist (1609) - $26.9 million Sotheby's New York, 26 January 2023 47 Édouard Manet’s The Grand Canal in Venice at $51.9 million. Without a collection of this caliber in 2023, it wasn’t surprising that the 19th Century Art segment only generated half its previous year’s result, with its share of global art auction turnover shrinking from 14% to 8%, to the benefit, notably, of Modern Art, which remained 2023’s most dynamic market segment. New York hammered the year’s ten best results for 19th Century Art, all for famous French artists. As usual, Claude Monet dominated this market with four works selling above $10 million, including Le Bassin aux nymphéas (c.1917/19) which, at $74 million, was the third highest art auction result of the year 2023. This large canvas, one of the most beautiful in Monet’s Water Lilies series, was kept in the same family collection for fifty years. The segment’s second best result of the year was hammered for a work by Le Douanier Rousseau titled Les Flamants (1910), a painting that sold at double its low estimate for a breathtaking $43.5 million. At ten times the artist’s previous record, this was a new auction record for the selftaught painter who was misunderstood by his contemporaries, but admired by the ‘avant-garde’ artists of the 20th century. The third best result in the 19th Century segment came from Paul Cézanne’s Fruits et pot de gingembre (1890/93) which fetched $38.9 million. The buyer of this important painting seems to have got a very good deal since the work was estimated by Christie’s at up to $55 million. Modern Art (artists born between 1860 and 1920) Accounting for 41% of the value of the global art auction market, the Modern period is the most prosperous segment. It is the basis of the American market (40% of US turnover), the UK market (39%), but also several European countries, including France (48%) and Germany (46%) and it accounts for 35% of Hong Kong’s art auction turnover. Even in the absence of exceptional private collection sales, this segment held up well in 2023 generating several new records. Gustav Klimt (new record), Picasso (second best-ever result), Kandinsky (new record), Magritte, Bacon, Rothko and Modigliani… they all attracted the best results of the Modern Art period (and indeed of the entire art auction market) ranging from $34 million to $139 million. Post-War Art (artists born between 1920 and 1945) The second most lucrative period after Modern Art was Post-War Art, which accounted for a quarter of global art auction revenue from a quarter its transactions. The year 2022 was excellent for this period, generating $3.8 billion for the first time, including the $195 million result for Andy Warhol’s iconic Shot sage blue Marilyn from the Thomas and Doris Ammann Collection. A pillar of this creative period, in 2022 Warhol was the world’s top-selling artist with a record annual turnover of $590 million. In 2023 this total was reduced by 66%, taking $392 million away from the segment’s total turnover. Add to this the slowdown in the annual turnover totals of David Hockney, Cy Twombly and Lucian Freud, and the shortfall becomes $553 million compared with 2022. But whereas certain pillars of the market contracted, others moved onto higher price levels. The most notable result in this segment was Richard Diebenkorn’s new auction record at $46.4 million (adding $20 million to his previous record hammered in 2021 for a painting from his Ocean Park series). The painting that set his latest record is a tribute to Henri Matisse, titled Recollections of a visit to Leningrad (1965) and it reached a price commensurate with that of large 1955 painting by Mark Rothko sold the same day, Untitled (Yellow, Orange, Yellow, Light Orange). 48  LE DOUANIER ROUSSEAU (1844-1910) The Flamingos (1910) - $43.5 million Christie's, New York, 11 May 2023 49 Contemporary Art (artists born after 1945) In 2023, the overall volume of art auction turnover from Contemporary Art was stable compared with the previous year, generating more than $2.2 billion and accounting for 17% of the global market. In geographical terms, North America was the leading market for Contemporary art with more than 30,000 lots sold compared with 18,000 in the UK and 11,000 in France. Contemporary Art was also a key segment in Hong Kong accounting for 32% of total art auction turnover, and in Belgium with 22% of the total turnover and 35% of lots sold in the country. In 2023, Basquiat remained the Contemporary segment’s leading artist with an even better performance than the previous year, up 7% to $238 million. He was also the second top-selling artist in the world after Picasso. His works accounted for the three best results in the Contemporary segment this year, including one at $67.1 million for The Great Show (The Nile)(1983), the price of which increased thirteenfold after eighteen years of ownership. Another work, Self-Portrait as a Heel (Part Two) (1982) also generated a multi-million dollar value accretion when it fetched $42 million at Sotheby’s in November compared with an acquisition price of $772,500 in 1999 at Christie’s. The other 18 Contemporary artists who featured among the global Top 100 (in terms of annual auction turnover) did not all benefit from the same energy. While the annual totals of Mark Tansey and Mark Bradford were multiplied by three and those of Zhou Chunya and Richard Prince by two, those of Banksy and Damien Hirst shrank sharply (-47% and -37% respectively). The works of some Contemporary Blue Chip artists even lost value, like Jeff Koons’ sculpture Jim Beam - J.B. Turner Train (1986), a large polished steel train whose price has halved in almost a decade. Sold for $33.7 million at Christie’s in 2014, the work peaked at $16.9 million in 2023. Works by Christopher Wool also fell short of expectations, notably Untitled (Please) (1988), which sold for $8.37 million at Sotheby’s compared with more than double ($17.1 million) in 2017 at Christie’s. BREAKDOWN BY CREATIVE PERIOD OF GLOBAL FINE ART AND NFT SALES TURNOVER (2023) Old masters 9% 19th century 8% Modern art 41% Post-War art 25% Contemporary art 17% ©artprice.com 50 NFTs The year 2023 marked the anchoring of NFTs in major museums around the world, starting with the LACMA, the MoMA and the Pompidou Center, which exhibited its first collection of NFTs in May. The auction houses have also further developed their strategies in this segment: in July, Christie’s carried out an entirely on-chain partnership with the Italian fashion house Gucci (and digital artists like Claire Silver, Tyler Hobbs, Emily Xie and Zach Lieberman) while Sotheby’s opened its first generative art platform with 500 works from the latest series of NFTs by Véra Molnar, a great pioneer of digital art who died last December, shortly before her centenary. This year, the 32 sales sessions offering NFTs posted an overall success rate of 87% and generated several new records. Generative art elicited the seven highest bids in the segment for creations by Tyler Hobbs and Dmitri Cherniak, including the Ringers #879 (The Goose) (2021) which reached $6.2 million. Among the other remarkable works in 2023, five digital creations created by Keith Haring were put on sale as NFTs by his eponymous foundation and each found a buyer at prices ranging from $250,000 to $350,000 at Christie’s in September. Sotheby’s stood out as the most active auction operator in this market, regularly organizing sales dedicated to this medium while including NFTs in general sessions as well. Its strong commitment to this innovative market segment allowed it to hammer 82% of the $22.7 million generated by NFTs at auction last year. In 2023, the global turnover on this segment was also up 65% compared with 2022, but it is clear that buying was much less speculative than in previous years, allowing digital art to settle peacefully in the international cultural and economic environment. Artist Sales proceeds Lots sold Unsold lots Maximum price 1 Dmitri CHERNIAK $7,880,900 14 0 $6,215,100 2 Tyler HOBBS $4,919,950 15 2 $1,016,000 3 LARVA LABS $1,811,680 9 0 $571,500 4 Keith HARING $1,587,600 5 0 $352,800 5 SNOWFRO $743,530 3 0 $635,000 6 Kjetil GOLID $453,390 7 0 $330,200 7 Refik ANADOL $386,800 4 0 $138,140 8 SHROOMTOSHI $342,900 2 0 $241,300 9 0XDEAFBEEF $325,120 3 0 $241,300 10 DES LUCRÉCE $289,600 10 0 $35,280 TOP 10 ARTISTS BY NFT AUCTION TURNOVER (2023) ©artprice.com 51 WHICH ARTISTS GENERATED THE HIGHEST TRANSACTION VOLUMES The three artists whose works generated the greatest number of annual transactions are Pablo Picasso, Salvador Dali, Andy Warhol. Together they accounted for over 8,400 lots sold in 2023. All three artists produced large volumes of ‘multiple’ works. The winning trio Picasso’s market is the densest of all with more than 3,500 lots sold over the year, half of which were prints, and most of which changed hands for less than $5,000. The artist also has the broadest geographical footprint: although half of the transactions take place in North America, his works are popular all over Europe, Asia (primarily China and Japan) and South Africa. He is followed by Salvador Dali with nearly 3,000 lots sold last year under his signature, an absolute record for this artist whose transaction volume has doubled in ten years. The Americans are his primary clients, absorbing half of his works, with a sales success rate of 86%. But this formidable sales ratio is not just based on major works. The vast majority of American transactions (60%) concern prints, i.e. multiples, which Dali produced in large quantities (and with quite inconsistent quality). Andy Warhol also engaged in ‘mass production’, which he ‘legitimized’ as a creative process. In 2023, his prints represented 72% of his 1,900 auction transactions throughout the year. They are mainly sold in Europe and collectors from France, Germany, Italy and Belgium are GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF WORKS BY PABLO PICASSO SOLD AT AUCTION (2023) Others China South Africa Romania Denmark Poland Monaco Canada Ireland Belgium Spain Italy Sweden Australia Austria Japan Switzerland Germany United Kingdom France United States 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 ©artprice.com 52 GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF WORKS BY SALVADOR DALI SOLD AT AUCTION (2023) Others Australia Poland Spain Belgium Switzerland Italy United Kingdom Germany France United States 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 ©artprice.com GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF WORKS BY ANDY WARHOL SOLD AT AUCTION (2023) Others Canada Austria Japan Belgium Switzerland France Germany United Kingdom Italy United States 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 ©artprice.com 53 so fond of his screen prints that the number of transactions recorded in Europe on these works is surprisingly higher than in America. These three artists with plethoric productions and totally globalized markets have enjoyed a maximum level of demand, especially since the boom in online sales observed during the Covid-19 pandemic which contributed considerably to broadening the population of print buyers, further boosting the market for the most productive artists in the field of multiples. The most sought-after artists by country American collectors actively seek works by major European artists. In fact, Picasso, Dali, Chagall and Miró generate more annual transactions (3,600) than the top-selling American artists, namely Warhol, Calder, Lichtenstein, Peter Max and LeRoy Neiman, even though there has been no decline in the demand for works by these five American top-selling artists, all of whom recorded new record transaction volumes this year (with the exception of Warhol, for whom 2023 was only his second-best year after a historic peak in 2022). The French art market is rich in Picasso works. In 2023, nearly 600 were acquired at French auctions generating $20 million (or 2.4% of the country’s 2023 art auction revenue). Bernard Buffet, whose works generated nearly $10 million, was the second best-selling artist in France and, last year, sales of his works reached a new high. Buffet was highly appreciated by collectors in the 1980s, before falling somewhat out of fashion. However, in recent years his works have returned to fetching 7-digit auction results in Paris, New York and Hong Kong. Max Agostini owes his position as the third most traded artist in France to the dispersal of the holdings of the Martin Caille Matignon Gallery (Paris), which had 550 of his works. The sale followed a judicial liquidation after the death of the gallery’s founder, Janet Greenberg, who had signed a world exclusivity contract with Max Agostini. With the exception of works by Picas- ©artprice.com TOP 10 ARTISTS BY LOTS SOLD IN THE UNITED STATES (2023) Artist Sales proceeds Lots sold Unsold lots Maximum price 1 Salvador DALI $6,618,450 1,203 187 $2,238,000 2 Pablo PICASSO $456,259,470 1,115 158 $139,363,500 3 Andy WARHOL $139,517,120 722 157 $25,940,000 4 Marc CHAGALL $38,846,830 694 187 $15,616,200 5 Joan MIRO $11,651,670 661 131 $1,734,000 6 ERTÉ $605,140 579 159 $9,440 7 Alexander CALDER $51,995,260 503 96 $5,555,500 8 Roy LICHTENSTEIN $52,445,060 455 75 $15,360,000 9 Peter MAX $813,110 447 118 $62,500 10 LeRoy NEIMAN $961,290 371 49 $97,660 54 TOP 10 ARTISTS BY LOTS SOLD IN FRANCE (2023) Artist Sales proceeds Lots sold Unsold lots Maximum price 1 Pablo PICASSO $21,097,380 578 162 $2,503,260 2 Bernard BUFFET $9,958,490 562 138 $591,570 3 Max AGOSTINI $613,610 534 11 $15,960 4 Haruhiko SUNAGAWA $216,060 389 15 $4,300 5 Shepard FAIREY $640,910 346 202 $48,960 6 Salvador DALI $2,527,870 345 114 $938,400 7 Robert SAINT-CRICQ $37,700 340 42 $1,090 8 JABER $103,520 331 18 $3,060 9 d'après Pablo PICASSO $394,730 270 109 $19,430 10 Robert DOISNEAU $170,900 267 50 $9,270 ©artprice.com©artprice.comTOP 10 ARTISTS BY LOTS SOLD IN THE UK (2023) Artist Sales proceeds Lots sold Unsold lots Maximum price 1 Pablo PICASSO $82,072,750 596 96 $21,748,480 2 David HOCKNEY $23,399,900 540 81 $5,278,510 3 David SHRIGLEY $925,000 412 228 $29,020 4 Damien HIRST $14,884,230 374 218 $1,810,930 5 Harry OUSEY $30,380 372 218 $740 6 BANKSY $19,714,430 326 163 $3,289,290 7 Laurence Stephen LOWRY $11,005,300 290 83 $1,661,420 8 Ewart JOHNS $25,880 279 39 $830 9 John PIPER $814,510 253 73 $92,010 10 Tracey EMIN $3,471,860 228 61 $1,648,170 so, who was the most frequently bought and sold artist in the UK in 2023, British buyers invested first and foremost in works by their compatriots, generally, English artists active in the 20th and 21th centuries. Two of them, Harry Ousey and Ewart Johns, had unusually high transaction numbers in 2023 following the dispersal, at low prices, of the contents of their workshops. Conversely, the regulars in this ranking are the unavoidable signatures like Banksy, Damien Hirst and David Hockney. The latter posted a record number of transactions (540) during 2023, as did Tracey Emin (228), who adorned the new doors of the National Portrait Gallery in London in June by honoring an order for 45 portraits. 55 SECOND BEST PERFORMANCE BY FEMALE ARTISTS Although women are still largely in the minority among the most valued artists, the gap is shrinking compared to their virtual invisibility just ten years ago. At that time, Joan Mitchell was the only woman in the global Top 50 and her annual turnover at that time was just over a third of what it was last year. In 2023, five women reached the global Top 50 with strong turnover figures and, in some cases, new auction records. They are Yayoi Kusama ($189.7 million), Joan Mitchell ($112.6 million), Georgia O’Keeffe ($56.2 million), Louise Bourgeois ($50.2 million) and Cecily Brown ($46.6 million). The greatest female artists of the 20th century are therefore gradually approaching the place they deserve on the art market. This movement has been largely driven by a determined effort among key art market players (including museums) to reduce the gender disequilibrium, particularly regarding the pecuniary values of art created by women. This has involved the inclusion of a growing number of their works in sales catalogs and a substantial gain in the visibility of works by female artists. In fact, the progress has been relatively rapid, since the number of transactions involving artworks by women has doubled in five years and tripled in ten years. This past year, artworks by women artists reached a new peak in the history of the art auction market, and it’s a dynamic that is unlikely to run out of steam any time soon. The number of transactions on artworks by women artists is higher than ever. The increase in demand has been evident in all price segments, including the most prestigious: in 2023, the number of 7-digit results (in USD) for works by women was 206 compared with 80 in 2013, which represents a growth rate of +157% over the decade. We should also point out EVOLUTION OF AUCTION TURNOVER FOR WOMEN ARTISTS SINCE 2000 $1.4 billion $1.2 billion $1 billion $800 million $600 million $400 million $200 million 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 ©artprice.com 56  LAVINIA FONTANA (1552-1614) Portrait of Antonietta Gonsalvus (detail) - $1.34 million Rouillac, Vendôme, 04 June 023 57 that this rise in million-plus transactions only concerned women since, over the same period, results in this price bracket contracted for male artists (-24%). Indeed, driven by the feminization of sales catalogs and the price inflation on artworks by women, 2023 was the third year that global annual auction turnover on art created by women reached above the $1 billion threshold. At $1.3 billion, 2023 was the second best performance after that of 2022 ($1.32 billion) – indicating that the market for female artists is resilient despite the slowdown in the overall market and that it still has plenty of upside potential. One of the most striking phenomena was the sharp acceleration observed just after the Covid-19 crisis: between 2020 and 2021, the annual global art auction turnover on art by women made an extraordinary progression of 66%. History’s female painters revalued The auction houses, like the museums, have also revalued female artists from the past in a desire to ‘repair historical oversights’. In 2019, the Ghent Museum of Fine Arts hosted a major exhibition dedicated to “Ladies of the Baroque. Women Painters in Italy during the 16th Century and 17th Centuries” which almost certainly had an impact on the prices of works by Artemisia Gentileschi (a major artist from that era). In 2019 Artcurial managed to sell her depiction of Lucretia on the verge of suicide in a caravaggesque chiaroscuro style for $5.2 million. In 2023, an allegorical sculpture by Artemisia fetched $2.36 million against Christie’s high estimate of just $500,000. NUMBER OF MILLION-PLUS RESULTS BY GENDER IN 2023 VS 2013 1,770 1,344 80 206 500 1,000 1,500 2 000 2013 2023 WomenMen ©artprice.com 58 Also in 2023, a work by a contemporary of Gentileschi, the Bolognese artist Lavinia Fontana, crossed the million-dollar threshold for the first time thanks to the discovery of a painting that was previously unknown to art historians. The painting is a portrait of a “bearded girl” representing the young Antonietta Gonsalvus who suffered from a genetic disease called hypertrichosis. This masterpiece of the Italian Renaissance sold for $1.3 million although it was estimated ten times less in a sale organized by Aymeric Rouillac in the small French town of Vendôme. This was just one of the wonderful surprises that the exploration of France’s provincial auction operators can generate. Both Gentileschi and Fontana are among the rare women of the Italian Renaissance to have had careers as painters and they enjoyed real artistic reputations during their lifetimes. Long left in the shadows of history, they are today being rehabilitated by museums and market players. On 15 June at Christie’s in Paris, National Gallery of Art in Washington acquired a superb still life by the 18th century French painter, Anne Vallayer-Coster, one of the rare women admitted to the Royal Academy of Painting and Sculpture. The NGA, which has clearly focused its recent acquisitions on paintings by female painters, paid $2.8 million for this splendid depiction of a magnificent bouquet of flowers, a record price which places the artist among the major signatures of her time. 20th Century works revalued by several million dollars Works by key female artists from the second half of the 20th century have also been revalued, like Louise Bourgeois’ Spider which fetched $32.8 million in Hong Kong in May 2023, adding two million dollars to the price paid five years ago in New York. Another bronze sculpture, The Family of Man: Ancestor II (1970), raised Barbara Hepworth’s auction record to $11.5 million, whereas this same work remained unsold in 2014 with a price estimated $10 million less. Similarly, Georgia O’Keeffe’s sensual Black Iris VI, painted in 1936, sold last year for $21.1 million compared with $1.1 million in 1998 ($20 million less!). We should also mention Jenny Saville, whose painting Shift, sold for $10.9 million in November 2023, adding two million dollars since its last sale in 2016. Indeed, examples of this type are legion. They reflect profound changes in the mindsets of the auction houses, which more firmly support female creativity in a historically male-dominated sector, but also among collectors, some of whom have made the purchase of works created by women a strategic priority. Barbara Hepworth crossed the $10  million threshold for the first time, while Louise Bourgeois achieved a new record for a sculpture sold at auction in Asia, at $32.8 million. Yayoi Kusama beats Gustav Klimt In 2023, Yayoi Kusama’s extravagant genius established her as the most successful female artist in the world, and works generated nearly $190 million in annual income giving her eighth place in the global Top 10, between René Magritte and Gustav Klimt. This is the highest she has ever ranked after reaching 10th position in 2021. Her success reflects a very organized and diversified market, made up of both prestigious works and a large quantity of pieces in limited editions allowing all categories of collectors access to her work. An artist with an impressive production force, Yayoi Kusuma creates works as she disperses the obsessive pattern of her polka dots, and this creative abundance feeds her growing auction market. She stands out as the female artist who has sold the most works in her lifetime with nearly 59 9,400 lots sold since her auction debut, including more than 800 this year. Joan Mitchell generates over $100 million A central figure in the second generation of Abstract Expressionists, Joan Mitchell has had a historic year 2023 ($112.6 million) punctuated by two new auction records at more than $27 million each. Since 2018, her work has been promoted by David Zwirner, a powerful gallery at the global level that has successfully raised Mitchell’s visibility around the world. Since the Zwirner gallery has taken control of her estate, no less than 13 out of 14 lots have exceeded $10 million at auction. The price of some of her large diptychs has increased five or six times since the beginning of the 2010s. The artist now holds 12th place in the world, ahead of Mark Rothko and Cy Twombly. Julie Mehretu – most expensive artist of African origin Julie Mehretu’s complex and intricate paintings, a unique form abstraction in touch with the issues of our time, have been acquired by the largest museum colArtist Artwork Price Date Maximum price 1 Louise BOURGEOIS Spider (1996) $32,804,500 18 May 2023 Sotheby's New York 2 Joan MITCHELL Untitled (c.1959) $29,160,000 9 Nov. 2023 Christie's New York 3 Agnes MARTIN Grey Stone II (1961) $18,718,500 8 Nov. 2023 Sotheby's New York 4 Barbara HEPWORTH The Family of Man: Ancestor II (1970) $11,565,000 9 Nov. 2023 Christie's New York 5 Julie MEHRETU Walkers With the Dawn and Morning (2008) $10,737,500 15 Nov. 2023 Sotheby's New York 6 Amrita SHER-GIL The story teller (1937) $7,432,690 16 Sept. 2023 Saffronart Mumbai 7 Claude LALANNE Très grand choupatte, pièce unique (2008) $5,276,400 30 Oct. 2023 Sotheby's Paris 8 Alma Woodsey THOMAS A Fantastic Sunset (1970) $3,922,000 17 May 2023 Christie's New York 9 Paula REGO Dancing Ostriches from Walt Disney's Fantasia (1995) $3,720,180 13 Oct. 2023 Christie's London 10 Lynette YIADOM-BOAKYE Six Birds in the Bush (2015) $3,602,760 12 Oct. 2023 Sotheby's London TOP 10 AUCTION RECORDS FOR FEMALE ARTISTS (2023) ©artprice.com 60 lections and the most important private collections, including those of the French collector, François Pinault and the Americans Eli and Edythe Broad. At 52, the artist of Ethiopian origin climbed into 2023’s 100 top-selling artists with an exceptional result and two absolute records. In October 2023, one of her works fetched $9.32 million at Sotheby’s Hong Kong, reaching a peak for an artist of African origin. A monumental diptych measuring almost five meters (Untitled, 2011), the work had already been sold at auction in 2015, when it reached $2.85 million. In eight years, therefore, its price increased by 227%, which is approximately the same revaluation as her overall price index. The record was short-lived, as it was surpassed on 15 November by a large drawing that sold for $10.7 million during Sotheby’s Now Evening Auction. Indeed, works by female artists generated 45% of the value of Sotheby’s Contemporary session… almost gender parity! Paula Rego - record year one year after her death The death of the great Portuguese painter Paula Rego in June 2022 considerably agitated her auction market with transactions up 39% this year and bidding competition stronger than ever. In 2023 her annual auction turnover reached $4.8 million, a new record in her market history. In October, Christie’s London set the artist’s new auction record at $3.8 million (more than double the previous record) for a diptych entitled Dancing Ostriches from Walt Disney’s ‘Fantasia’ (1995), a large pastel work that was part of the famous Saatchi Collection. Claude Lalanne - France’s top-selling female artist In 2023, Claude Lalanne’s prices moved into another dimension in the same year that her accomplice, François-Xavier Lalanne, became the top-selling artist on the French art market. Claude’s new auction record now stands at $5.27 million, five times the low estimate after a bidding war that took place on 30 October at Sotheby’s France. The sculpture that was the object of the bidding (Très grand choupatte) is a unique piece created in 2008 for Pauline Karpidas, whose works Sotheby’s was selling in Paris. The result gave Claude Lalanne the best result for a female artist in France in 2023, while her annual turnover of $5.5 million put her ahead of illustrious male artists like Pierre Bonnard, Auguste Rodin and Paul Gauguin. Enthusiastic bidding for emerging female artists In 2023, we also saw very competitive bidding for younger women artists. One example was Christie’s well-attended New York sale on 7 November where enthusiastic bidding for works by younger women contrasted with lukewarm bidding for Blue Chip artists like Andy Warhol, Keith Haring, Cy Twombly and even Jeff Koons. There was particularly lively and competitive bidding for the works of artists like Stefanie Heinze, aged 36, whose painting Le Troisième rendez-vous (2020) tripled its estimate to $239,400 on 7 November. Jenna Gribbon’s (b.1978) lesbian female nude, Regarding Me Regarding You and Me (2020), raised the artist’s personal record to just under $500,000 against a high estimate of $150,000. In the same sale, a work (Carnal Field (2022)) by Sanya Kantarovsky (b.1982), a Russian painter living in New York, again exceeded $200,000, against a high estimate half that price. The American artist Ilana Savdie (b.1989) achieved a new record at $201,600 after her exhibition at the Whitney Museum of American Art. Lastly, a work titled Fanta Car interior by Issy Wood (b.1993) fetched $277,200, more than double its high estimate, while Jadé Fadojutimi’s (b.1993) A Thistle Throb (2021) sold for nearly $1.7 million, a short-lived new record for the British artist of Nigerian descent because another of her works rea- 61 ched nearly $2 million the following week at Sotheby’s. Jadé Fadojutimi and Michaela Yearwood-Dan are the two most prominent young abstract artists on the current British scene. Jadé Fadojutimi’s work has been attracting bidders since 2020 when her auction debut sold for $52,000, or 13 times its high estimate. Two months later, Phillips sold a larger painting for $378,000, and her prices rose very quickly in 2021, exceeding a million dollars. In 2022, she became the youngest artist in the permanent collection of the Tate Modern and she participated in the prestigious Venice Biennale, two factors that considerably boosted demand for her work, and their prices. Another major factor has been her admission to the powerful Gagosian gallery alongside artists like Damien Hirst and Takashi Murakami. Her three best auction results, all 7-digit, date from 2023 and were shared between Phillips, Sotheby’s and Christie’s New York. Another young British abstract painter to have enjoyed a super-fast price ascension is Michaela Yearwood-Dan. Unknown to the auction market before 2022, she was among the world’s 500 top-selling artists in 2023. At the end of February, one of her paintings, Love me nots (2021), reached $884,000 at Christie’s, multiplying its high estimate of $72,000 by more than ten times. Although this auction record was hammered in London, where the artist lives and works, the prices of her paintings have soared just as much in New York and Hong Kong. Christie’s, Sotheby’s and Phillips have all participated in the phenomenal success of this powerful artist, who has not yet celebrated her 30th birthday. Prices are also rising for the American artist Loie Hollowell, whose paintings of flexible and geometric shapes with corporeal/sensual echoes have prompted comparisons with the work of Georgia O’Keeffe. Her popularity rocketed after she joined the Pace gallery in 2017. Starting with an auction debut at $68,750 in May 2018, the artist crossed the million-dollar threshold for the first time in 2021. In 2023, her auction record rose to $2.29 million for Standing in Red (2019) during Sotheby’s 50th anniversary sale in Asia. However she has publicly expressed frustration with her new record as she considers it an affront that collectors she met when they bought her works in galleries quickly resell her works on the secondary market for large profits. It way well be partly for this reason that she has produced a collection of NFTs giving her greater control: in the event of resale, Loie Hollowell will automatically receive a commission payment thanks to the smart contract. This type of arrangement is, in principal, fairer to the artist. ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 62 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Artwork Price Date Auction House Record* 1 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmeàlamontre(1932) $139,363,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 2 GustavKLIMT(1862-1918) DamemitFächer[...](1917-1918) $108,743,230 27June2023 Sotheby'sLondon X 3 ClaudeMONET(1840-1926) Lebassinauxnymphéas(c.1917/19) $74,010,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 4 Jean-MichelBASQUIAT(1960-1988) ElGranEspectaculo(TheNile)(1983) $67,110,000 15May2023 Christie'sNewYork 5 GustavKLIMT(1862-1918) InselimAttersee[...](c.1901/02) $53,188,500 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 6 FrancisBACON(1909-1992) FigureinMovement(1976) $52,160,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 7 RichardDIEBENKORN(1922-1993) RecollectionsofaVisittoLeningrad(1965) $46,410,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork X 8 MarkROTHKO(1903-1970) Untitled(Yellow,Orange[...])(1955) $46,410,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 9 WassilyKANDINSKY(1866-1944) MurnaumitKircheII[...](1910) $44,721,120 1March2023 Sotheby'sLondon X 10 LEDOUANIERROUSSEAU(1844-1910) LesFlamants(1910) $43,535,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork X 11 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmeendormie(1934) $42,960,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 12 RenéMAGRITTE(1898-1967) L'Empiredeslumières(1951) $42,273,000 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 13 Jean-MichelBASQUIAT(1960-1988) Self-PortraitasaHeel(PartTwo)(1982) $42,000,000 15Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 14 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Naturemorteàlafenêtre(1932) $41,810,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 15 JasperJOHNS(1930) Flags(1986) $41,000,000 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 16 WANGMeng(1308-1385) Inkstonewashing $40,562,800 30Nov.2023 ChinaGuardianBeijing 17 EdRUSCHA(1937) SecuringtheLastLetter(Boss)(1964) $39,400,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 18 PaulCÉZANNE(1839-1906) Fruitsetpotdegingembre(1890/93) $38,935,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 19 RenéMAGRITTE(1898-1967) L’empiredeslumières(1949) $34,910,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 20 AmedeoMODIGLIANI(1884-1920) PauletteJourdain(c.1919) $34,849,700 5Oct.2023 Sotheby'sHongKong 21 GerhardRICHTER(1932) AbstraktesBild(636)(1987) $34,800,000 14Nov.2023 PhillipsNewYork 22 FrancisBACON(1909-1992) Self-Portrait(1969) $34,622,500 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 23 CUIRuzhuo(1944) RaftingInWindAndRain(2019) $33,064,110 24Feb.2023 BeijingYongleBeijing 24 LouiseBOURGEOIS(1911-2010) Spider(1996) $32,804,500 18May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork X 25 ZHANGDaqian(1899-1983) PinkLotusesonGoldScreen(1973) $32,057,500 5Apr.2023 Sotheby'sHongKong 26 GerhardRICHTER(1932) AbstraktesBild(1997) $31,932,000 15Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 27 WillemDEKOONING(1904-1997) Orestes(1947) $30,885,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 28 ClaudeMONET(1840-1926) Peupliersauborddel’Epte[...](1891) $30,783,000 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 29 JoanMITCHELL(1925-1992) Untitled(c.1959) $29,160,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork X 30 GerhardRICHTER(1932) AbstraktesBild(1986) $29,070,020 1March2023 Sotheby'sLondon 31 Jean-MichelBASQUIAT(1960-1988) Now'stheTime(1985) $28,634,000 18May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 32 AlbertoGIACOMETTI(1901-1966) FemmeLeoni(1947) $28,485,000 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 33 JoanMITCHELL(1925-1992) Sunflowers(1990/91) $27,910,500 15Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 34 PeterPaulRUBENS(1577-1640) Salomepresentedwiththehead[...] $26,926,000 26Jan.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 35 CyTWOMBLY(1928-2011) Untitled(1968) $26,761,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 36 PeterPaulRUBENS(1577-1640) PortraitofaManasMars(c.1620) $26,187,000 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 37 AndyWARHOL(1928-1987) SixteenJackies(1964) $25,940,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 38 ClaudeMONET(1840-1926) LeMoulindeLimetz(1888) $25,612,500 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 39 ZHANGDaqian(1899-1983) AutumnMountainsinTwilight(1967) $25,526,010 9Dec.2023 Sotheby'sHongKong 40 ZHAOMengfu(1254-1322) Calligraphyinregularscript(1302/1322) $25,070,780 5July2023 PolyBeijing 41 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) L'Arlésienne(LeeMiller)(1937) $24,560,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 42 SANYu(1895/1901-1966) Femmenuesuruntapis[...](1929) $24,031,220 28Nov.2023 Christie'sHongKong 43 MarkROTHKO(1903-1970) Untitled(1968) $23,889,000 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 44 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Compotieretguitare(1932) $23,463,500 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 45 ArshileGORKY(1904-1948) CharredBelovedI(1946) $23,410,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork X 46 VincentVANGOGH(1853-1890) JardindevantleMasDebray(1887) $23,314,500 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 47 EdRUSCHA(1937) BurningGasStation(1966-1969) $22,260,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 48 MarkROTHKO(1903-1970) Untitled(1958) $22,165,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 49 JoanMIRO(1893-1983) Peinture(Femmes,lune,étoiles)(1949) $21,967,900 20Oct.2023 Christie'sParis 50 GerhardRICHTER(1932) 4096Farben(1974) $21,839,000 18May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork TOP 100 FINE ART AND NFT WORKS SOLD AT AUCTION IN 2023 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 63 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Artwork Price Date Auction House Record* 51 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Filletteaubateau,Maya(1938) $21,748,480 1March2023 Sotheby'sLondon 52 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmenuecouchée[...](1964) $21,240,000 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 53 GeorgiaO'KEEFFE(1887-1986) BlackIrisVI(1936) $21,110,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 54 LucioFONTANA(1899-1968) Concettospaziale,LafinediDio(1963) $20,556,900 15Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 55 LucianFREUD(1922-2011) IbReading(1997) $20,456,620 1March2023 Sotheby'sLondon 56 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmedansunrocking-chair[...](1956) $20,441,210 28Feb.2023 Christie'sLondon 57 EdvardMUNCH(1863-1944) Danspåstranden[...](1906/07) $20,367,050 1March2023 Sotheby'sLondon 58 CyTWOMBLY(1928-2011) Untitled[Bolsena](1969) $19,960,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 59 CyTWOMBLY(1928-2011) Untitled(Bacchus1stVersionII)(2004) $19,960,000 7Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 60 François-XavierLALANNE(1927-2008) RhinocrétaireI(1964) $19,411,150 20Oct.2023 Christie'sParis X 61 DavidHOCKNEY(1937) EarlyBlossom,Woldgate(2009) $19,385,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 62 RenéMAGRITTE(1898-1967) LeDomained’Arnheim(1949) $18,948,300 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 63 AgnesMARTIN(1912-2004) GreyStoneII(1961) $18,718,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork X 64 FrankSTELLA(1936) HondurasLotteryCo.(1962) $18,718,500 15Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 65 AndyWARHOL(1928-1987) Self-Portrait(1986) $18,144,000 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 66 FernandLÉGER(1881-1955) Le14juillet(c.1912-1913) $17,625,000 14Nov.2023 PhillipsNewYork 67 FranciscoGOYA(1746-1828) PortraitofDoñaM.V.B.Valdés[...](1805) $16,420,000 25Jan.2023 Christie'sNewYork X 68 MichielSWEERTS(1618/24-1664) TheArtist’sStudiowithaSeamstress $16,056,160 6July2023 Christie'sLondon X 69 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmeauchapeaujaune[...](1939) $15,846,000 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 70 MarcCHAGALL(1887-1985) Au-dessusdelaville(1924) $15,616,200 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 71 RoyLICHTENSTEIN(1923-1997) RouenCathedral,SetIV(1969) $15,360,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 72 TamaraDELEMPICKA(1898-1980) Filletteenrose(c.1928/30) $14,785,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 73 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmeencorset[...](c.1914-1918) $14,762,500 14Nov.2023 PhillipsNewYork 74 MortonWayneTHIEBAUD(1920-2021) CandyCounter(1969) $14,697,000 18May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 75 BALTHUS(1908-2001) LaPatience(1943-1948) $14,697,000 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 76 DavidHOCKNEY(1937) TheGate(2000) $14,670,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 77 REMBRANDTVANRIJN(1606-1669) PortraitofJanWillemsz.[...](c.1565-1644) $14,299,720 6July2023 Christie'sLondon 78 REMBRANDTVANRIJN(1606-1669) TheAdorationoftheKings $13,793,700 6Dec.2023 Sotheby'sLondon 79 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Nucouché(1968) $13,635,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 80 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Bustedefemme(1909) $13,622,500 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 81 RenéMAGRITTE(1898-1967) L’îleautrésor(1945) $13,347,500 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 82 KeesVANDONGEN(1877-1968) LaQuiétude(1918) $13,078,290 13Oct.2023 Christie'sLondon 83 GeorgiaO'KEEFFE(1887-1986) WhiteCalicoRose(1930) $13,060,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 84 EdRUSCHA(1937) Mint(Green)(1968) $12,973,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 85 FUBaoshi(1904-1965) ScenerieofYuntaiMountain(1942) $12,875,220 12June2023 ChinaGuardianBeijing 86 YoshitomoNARA(1959) IntheMilkyLake(2012) $12,809,700 5Apr.2023 Sotheby'sHongKong 87 ZHANGDaqian(1899-1983) Mountainandpavillion $12,752,490 4July2023 PolyBeijing 88 LongQIAN&TingbiaoJIN(XVIII) Portraitsoffiftymeritorious[...](1760) $12,694,070 5July2023 PolyBeijing X 89 Jean-MichelBASQUIAT(1960-1988) FutureSciencesVersustheMan(1982) $12,659,540 13Oct.2023 Christie'sLondon 90 AlbertoGIACOMETTI(1901-1966) FemmedeVeniseVIII(1973) $12,650,000 13Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 91 IsamuNOGUCHI(1904-1988) TheFamily(1956/57) $12,284,100 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork X 92 GiovanniAntonioCANAL(1697-1768) Venice:TheMouthoftheGrandCanal[...] $12,274,110 7Dec.2023 Christie'sLondon 93 LucianFREUD(1922-2011) NightInterior(1968-1970) $12,220,610 27June2023 Sotheby'sLondon 94 Pierre-AugusteRENOIR(1841-1919) SquaredelaTrinité(1878-1879) $11,910,000 11May2023 Christie'sNewYork 95 Jean-MichelBASQUIAT(1960-1988) Untitled(1981) $11,910,000 7Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork 96 PabloPICASSO(1881-1973) Femmedansunfauteuil(1948) $11,858,290 5Apr.2023 Sotheby'sHongKong 97 RenéMAGRITTE(1898-1967) Lavalsehésitation(1955) $11,838,420 19Oct.2023 Sotheby'sParis 98 CyTWOMBLY(1928-2011) Untitled(1962) $11,824,500 16May2023 Sotheby'sNewYork 99 MarkTANSEY(1949) TriumphOverMasteryII(1987) $11,824,500 8Nov.2023 Sotheby'sNewYork X 100 BarbaraHEPWORTH(1903-1975) TheFamilyofMan:AncestorII(1970) $11,565,000 9Nov.2023 Christie'sNewYork X ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 64 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 1 Pablo PICASSO (1881-1973) Spain $596,984,580 3,510 $139,363,500 2 Jean-Michel BASQUIAT (1960-1988) UnitedStates $238,161,820 105 $67,110,000 3 ZHANG Daqian (1899-1983) China $230,560,160 586 $32,057,500 4 Gerhard RICHTER (b. 1932) Germany $214,408,670 303 $34,800,000 5 Andy WARHOL (1928-1987) UnitedStates $198,843,850 1,937 $25,940,000 6 Claude MONET (1840-1926) France $197,221,610 31 $74,010,000 7 René MAGRITTE (1898-1967) Belgium $192,865,040 182 $42,273,000 8 Yayoi KUSAMA (b. 1929) Japan $189,713,150 812 $10,019,690 9 Gustav KLIMT (1862-1918) Austria $169,141,550 104 $108,743,230 X 10 QI Baishi (1864-1957) China $157,866,100 636 $7,725,130 11 Ed RUSCHA (b. 1937) UnitedStates $114,335,130 236 $39,400,500 12 Joan MITCHELL (1925-1992) UnitedStates $112,631,950 54 $29,160,000 X 13 WU Guanzhong (1919-2010) China $107,662,400 177 $10,943,930 14 Mark ROTHKO (1903-1970) Latvia $107,523,870 11 $46,410,000 15 Cy TWOMBLY (1928-2011) UnitedStates $102,062,190 99 $26,761,500 16 Francis BACON (1909-1992) Ireland $100,196,180 96 $52,160,000 17 David HOCKNEY (b. 1937) UnitedKingdom $99,265,740 1,001 $19,385,000 18 Willem DE KOONING (1904-1997) TheNetherlands $98,064,510 112 $30,885,000 19 Lucio FONTANA (1899-1968) Argentina $88,601,640 234 $20,556,900 20 Yoshitomo NARA (b. 1959) Japan $87,795,160 399 $12,809,700 21 François-Xavier LALANNE (1927-2008) France $86,270,500 238 $19,411,150 X 22 FU Baoshi (1904-1965) China $84,413,070 100 $12,875,220 23 Marc CHAGALL (1887-1985) Belarus $83,979,750 1,698 $15,616,200 24 Paul CÉZANNE (1839-1906) France $81,503,390 67 $38,935,000 25 ZAO Wou-Ki (1921-2013) China $77,027,240 350 $6,223,000 26 Jasper JOHNS (b. 1930) UnitedStates $72,085,950 313 $41,000,000 27 Alberto GIACOMETTI (1901-1966) Swiss $68,079,310 151 $28,485,000 28 Wassily KANDINSKY (1866-1944) Russia $64,589,970 126 $44,721,120 X 29 Richard DIEBENKORN (1922-1993) UnitedStates $62,268,560 68 $46,410,000 X 30 Peter Paul RUBENS (1577-1640) Germany $62,227,170 9 $26,926,000 31 Alexander CALDER (1898-1976) UnitedStates $60,659,790 722 $5,555,500 32 Roy LICHTENSTEIN (1923-1997) UnitedStates $58,028,500 694 $15,360,000 33 Georgia O'KEEFFE (1887-1986) UnitedStates $56,208,590 19 $21,110,000 34 Joan MIRO (1893-1983) Spain $55,214,770 1,783 $21,967,900 35 Lucian FREUD (1922-2011) Germany $54,583,140 59 $20,456,620 36 Pierre-Auguste RENOIR (1841-1919) France $53,059,710 363 $11,910,000 37 Henri MATISSE (1869-1954) France $50,773,780 552 $9,035,000 38 Louise BOURGEOIS (1911-2010) France $50,234,800 80 $32,804,500 X 39 HUANG Binhong (1865-1955) China $49,660,470 237 $3,621,150 40 REMBRANDT VAN RIJN (1606-1669) TheNetherlands $49,237,160 889 $14,299,720 41 Cecily BROWN (1969) UnitedKingdom $46,602,990 27 $6,711,450 42 George CONDO (1957) UnitedStates $46,303,950 104 $3,652,800 43 Morton Wayne THIEBAUD (1920-2021) UnitedStates $46,194,990 95 $14,697,000 44 Amedeo MODIGLIANI (1884-1920) Italy $44,680,220 87 $34,849,700 45 LE DOUANIER ROUSSEAU (1844-1910) France $43,555,620 11 $43,535,000 X 46 LIU Ye (b. 1964) China $40,658,090 28 $7,972,260 47 WANG Meng (1308-1385) China $40,564,560 2 $40,562,800 48 WU Changshuo (1844-1927) China $40,458,040 396 $2,116,910 49 Fernando BOTERO (1932-2023) Colombia $38,914,580 146 $5,132,000 X 50 Vincent VAN GOGH (1853-1890) TheNetherlands $38,399,310 20 $23,314,500 TOP 500 ARTISTS BY AUCTION REVENUE IN 2023 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 65 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 51 Agnes MARTIN (1912-2004) Canada $37,238,870 54 $18,718,500 X 52 LI Keran (1907-1989) China $36,609,470 162 $3,337,120 53 Fernand LÉGER (1881-1955) France $35,272,450 254 $17,625,000 54 BANKSY (b. 1974) UnitedKingdom $35,234,030 770 $9,724,500 55 Barbara HEPWORTH (1903-1975) UnitedKingdom $35,149,140 74 $11,565,000 X 56 ZHAO Mengfu (1254-1322) China $34,549,500 4 $25,070,780 57 LIN Fengmian (1900-1991) China $34,200,410 153 $3,060,920 58 Jean DUBUFFET (1901-1985) France $33,874,360 218 $4,900,000 59 CUI Ruzhuo (b. 1944) China $33,761,070 26 $33,064,110 60 Philip GUSTON (1913-1980) Canada $33,085,070 36 $9,610,000 61 XU Beihong (1895-1953) China $32,604,490 163 $2,502,840 62 Keith HARING (1958-1990) UnitedStates $32,000,640 676 $3,206,000 63 SAN Yu (1895/1901-1966) China $31,377,460 76 $24,031,220 64 Richard PRINCE (b. 1949) UnitedStates $30,936,960 104 $4,890,000 65 Georg BASELITZ (1938) Germany $30,583,290 124 $7,320,000 66 Helen FRANKENTHALER (1928-2011) UnitedStates $30,571,130 120 $3,448,000 67 Damien HIRST (b. 1965) UnitedKingdom $30,112,120 866 $2,220,000 68 Edvard MUNCH (1863-1944) Norway $30,012,960 107 $20,367,050 69 CHU Teh-Chun (1920-2014) China $29,368,700 97 $2,519,000 70 Arshile GORKY (1904-1948) Armenia $28,483,440 10 $23,410,000 X 71 Jeff KOONS (b. 1955) UnitedStates $27,705,320 197 $7,770,150 72 Christopher WOOL (b. 1955) UnitedStates $27,467,630 55 $10,070,000 73 Donald JUDD (1928-1994) UnitedStates $27,233,390 96 $8,492,400 74 Egon SCHIELE (1890-1918) Austria $26,980,500 70 $10,990,000 75 Frank STELLA (b. 1936) UnitedStates $25,747,870 253 $18,718,500 76 Julie MEHRETU (b. 1970) Ethiopia $25,621,330 29 $10,737,500 X 77 Sayed Haider RAZA (1922-2016) India $25,390,440 124 $6,258,650 X 78 Nicolas PARTY (b. 1980) Swiss $25,231,920 41 $4,990,120 79 Pierre SOULAGES (1919-2022) France $25,076,530 218 $3,314,280 80 LU Yanshao (1909-1993) China $24,800,120 217 $2,547,320 81 ZHOU Chunya (b. 1955) China $24,673,420 57 $3,986,130 82 Paul SIGNAC (1863-1935) France $24,242,530 90 $10,135,570 83 WEN Zhengming (1470-1559) China $23,751,790 70 $5,553,650 84 HUANG Zhou (1925-1997) China $23,137,120 283 $4,176,440 85 Kees VAN DONGEN (1877-1968) TheNetherlands $22,882,040 103 $13,078,290 86 Mark BRADFORD (1961) UnitedStates $22,828,380 14 $4,285,000 87 PU Ru (1896-1963) China $21,193,360 556 $830,470 88 Tamara DE LEMPICKA (1898-1980) Poland $20,937,590 43 $14,785,000 89 Francisco GOYA (1746-1828) Spain $20,850,550 275 $16,420,000 X 90 Jenny SAVILLE (b. 1970) UnitedKingdom $20,466,430 7 $10,905,300 91 Matthew WONG (1984-2019) Canada $20,314,690 10 $6,662,110 X 92 Bernard BUFFET (1928-1999) France $20,280,660 1,138 $591,570 93 Kerry James MARSHALL (1955) UnitedStates $20,061,150 12 $10,275,500 94 Mark TANSEY (1949) UnitedStates $20,009,650 7 $11,824,500 X 95 Jean-Paul RIOPELLE (1923-2002) Canada $19,979,000 220 $4,161,150 96 Camille PISSARRO (1830-1903) France $19,795,750 117 $4,174,000 97 Alighiero BOETTI (1940-1994) Italy $19,491,050 170 $3,922,000 98 LE PHO (1907-2001) Vietnam $19,348,740 132 $2,369,450 X 99 Maqbool Fida HUSAIN (1915-2011) India $19,339,580 168 $2,782,500 X 100 CHEN Yifei (1946-2005) China $19,337,120 29 $4,015,250 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 66 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 101 Henry MOORE (1898-1986) UnitedKingdom $19,120,690 371 $5,627,840 102 Michiel SWEERTS (1618/24-1664) Flanders $18,688,300 4 $16,056,160 X 103 Josef ALBERS (1888-1976) Germany $18,627,840 319 $2,954,000 104 Takashi MURAKAMI (b. 1962) Japan $18,575,850 1,182 $2,831,880 105 Frantisek KUPKA (1871-1957) Czechia $18,260,790 67 $5,585,810 106 Giovanni Antonio CANAL (1697-1768) Italy $18,113,460 33 $12,274,110 107 HUANG Yuxing (b. 1975) China $18,064,290 66 $2,890,980 108 Brice MARDEN (1938-2023) UnitedStates $17,875,650 47 $9,840,000 109 Kazuo SHIRAGA (1924-2008) Japan $17,871,290 63 $5,132,000 110 Frank AUERBACH (b. 1931) Germany $17,663,210 14 $7,094,220 X 111 Francis Newton SOUZA (1924-2002) India $17,508,800 139 $4,172,430 X 112 Alex KATZ (b. 1927) UnitedStates $17,425,960 275 $2,470,000 113 ZHANG Jizhi (1186-1266) China $17,293,340 4 $9,656,410 X 114 Robert RAUSCHENBERG (1925-2008) UnitedStates $17,263,690 380 $4,900,000 115 Lee BONTECOU (1931-2022) UnitedStates $16,770,980 24 $8,690,000 116 Barkley L. HENDRICKS (1945-2017) UnitedStates $16,610,000 6 $8,377,500 X 117 Ufan LEE (b. 1936) SouthKorea $16,237,860 128 $1,502,000 118 Yves KLEIN (1928-1962) France $16,161,100 65 $2,988,690 119 Jonas WOOD (b. 1977) UnitedStates $16,118,590 99 $4,295,000 120 Félix VALLOTTON (1865-1925) Swiss $16,095,520 105 $4,454,510 X 121 Edgar DEGAS (1834-1917) France $16,082,830 113 $5,616,000 122 QI Gong (1912-2005) China $15,858,620 350 $510,100 123 Claude LALANNE (1925-2019) France $15,568,770 117 $5,276,400 X 124 DONG Qichang (1555-1636) China $15,375,310 73 $4,601,600 125 BALTHUS (1908-2001) France $15,358,330 26 $14,697,000 126 Pierre BONNARD (1867-1947) France $15,278,510 156 $3,448,000 127 Auguste RODIN (1840-1917) France $15,233,270 119 $2,985,850 128 Salvador DALI (1904-1989) Spain $15,083,960 2,981 $2,238,000 129 Raja RAVI VARMA (1848-1906) India $14,643,690 11 $5,286,830 X 130 Sean SCULLY (b. 1945) Ireland $14,529,790 116 $1,367,000 131 Edward HOPPER (1882-1967) UnitedStates $14,424,600 42 $7,228,500 132 Paul GAUGUIN (1848-1903) France $14,391,260 56 $10,445,700 133 ZENG Fanzhi (b. 1964) China $14,361,710 26 $3,146,860 134 PAN Tianshou (1897-1971) China $14,335,160 64 $3,363,560 135 Marlene DUMAS (b. 1953) SouthAfrica $14,285,200 66 $5,879,500 136 Alexej VON JAWLENSKY (1864-1941) Russia $14,267,830 37 $6,860,560 137 Lynne Mapp DREXLER (1928-1999) UnitedStates $14,223,730 72 $1,381,000 138 Diego GIACOMETTI (1902-1985) Swiss $14,041,500 30 $6,216,890 139 Seo-Bo PARK (1931-2023) SouthKorea $13,911,790 70 $2,606,970 X 140 Pieter II BRUEGHEL (c.1564-1637/38) Belgium $13,842,930 12 $2,940,000 141 Adrian GHENIE (b. 1977) Romania $13,825,710 16 $5,479,570 142 Isamu NOGUCHI (1904-1988) UnitedStates $13,646,310 24 $12,284,100 X 143 WU Dayu (1903-1988) China $13,500,360 30 $3,152,860 144 ZHANG Enli (b. 1965) China $13,500,060 45 $765,340 145 Lynn Russell CHADWICK (1914-2003) UnitedKingdom $13,256,420 114 $3,317,000 146 Francis PICABIA (1879-1953) France $12,889,140 75 $2,349,690 147 Georges BRAQUE (1882-1963) France $12,787,450 353 $8,465,000 148 FAN Zeng (b. 1938) China $12,785,900 180 $1,067,880 149 Long QIAN & Tingbiao JIN (XVIII) China $12,694,070 1 $12,694,070 X 150 SALVO (1947-2015) Italy $12,596,260 181 $1,115,020 X ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 67 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 151 Blinky PALERMO (1943-1977) Germany $12,480,450 40 $6,309,300 X 152 KAWS (b. 1974) UnitedStates $12,275,290 803 $1,875,000 153 Giorgio MORANDI (1890-1964) Italy $12,260,370 54 $2,374,240 154 Jadé FADOJUTIMI (1993) UnitedKingdom $12,203,780 26 $1,935,500 X 155 Robert H. COLESCOTT (1925-2009) UnitedStates $12,193,900 12 $4,500,380 156 Mark GROTJAHN (b. 1968) UnitedStates $12,183,450 18 $4,295,000 157 WANG Hui (1632-1717) China $12,180,280 32 $3,057,860 158 Trung Thu MAI (1906-1980) Vietnam $12,090,020 98 $728,030 159 Günther FÖRG (1952-2013) Germany $12,030,400 172 $1,001,900 160 Sam FRANCIS (1923-1994) UnitedStates $11,907,350 423 $819,000 161 WANG Yuanqi (1642-1715) China $11,838,320 23 $3,446,720 162 Ayako ROKKAKU (b. 1982) Japan $11,693,270 177 $791,620 163 HOKUSAI (1760-1849) Japan $11,584,370 227 $2,760,000 X 164 AILI Jia (b. 1979) China $11,572,760 15 $4,769,000 X 165 HUANG Yongyu (1924-2023) China $11,512,260 193 $826,600 166 Hermann Max PECHSTEIN (1881-1955) Germany $11,445,850 134 $3,303,840 167 Tsuguharu FOUJITA (1886-1968) Japan $11,289,140 417 $727,190 168 XIE Zhiliu (1910-1997) China $11,102,190 208 $1,841,950 169 Laurence Stephen LOWRY (1887-1976) UnitedKingdom $11,043,880 308 $1,661,420 170 YUN Shouping (1633-1690) China $10,947,100 30 $7,300,630 171 WANG Xuetao (1903-1982) China $10,942,290 333 $721,060 172 Serge POLIAKOFF (1900-1969) Russia $10,769,550 187 $914,700 173 Agnolo BRONZINO (1503-1572) Italy $10,665,500 1 $10,665,500 X 174 Antony GORMLEY (b. 1950) UnitedKingdom $10,616,310 75 $1,139,930 175 Rashid JOHNSON (b. 1977) UnitedStates $10,524,470 32 $1,744,000 176 CHEN Chun (1483-1544) China $10,468,060 22 $4,839,610 177 Jackson POLLOCK (1912-1956) UnitedStates $10,449,450 19 $6,705,000 178 QIAN LONG Emperor (1711-1799) China $10,333,370 36 $2,370,900 179 Piet MONDRIAAN (1872-1944) TheNetherlands $10,331,720 23 $9,166,500 180 Tom WESSELMANN (1931-2004) UnitedStates $10,321,960 220 $1,197,000 181 Hans COPER (1920-1981) Germany $10,249,470 83 $784,900 182 Peter DOIG (b. 1959) UnitedKingdom $10,180,740 58 $7,355,400 183 HONG Yi (1880-1942) China $10,159,730 64 $952,950 184 Jean-Honoré FRAGONARD (1732-1806) France $10,106,450 15 $6,216,800 185 GUAN Liang (1900-1986) China $10,094,150 215 $467,200 186 MASTER OF THE BARONCELLI PORTRAITS (act.1490) Flanders $10,037,750 1 $10,037,750 X 187 Joseph William TURNER (1775-1851) UnitedKingdom $10,030,560 23 $4,620,000 188 Caroline WALKER (b. 1982) UnitedKingdom $10,001,770 56 $1,106,090 X 189 Max ERNST (1891-1976) Germany $9,984,870 256 $2,374,240 190 Emil NOLDE (1867-1956) Germany $9,905,900 112 $1,781,910 191 Ernie BARNES (1938-2009) UnitedStates $9,884,750 56 $1,170,000 192 Vilhelm HAMMERSHOI (1864-1916) Denmark $9,807,700 7 $9,124,350 X 193 Elizabeth PEYTON (b. 1965) UnitedStates $9,770,360 34 $2,238,000 194 Robert MOTHERWELL (1915-1991) UnitedStates $9,730,730 313 $4,658,000 195 Andrew WYETH (1917-2009) UnitedStates $9,669,730 110 $4,769,000 196 ZHANG Xiaogang (b. 1958) China $9,620,050 34 $2,569,760 197 Anish KAPOOR (b. 1954) India $9,563,010 55 $1,001,960 198 CHEN Jiru (1558-1639) China $9,502,470 21 $8,248,740 X 199 Robert RYMAN (1930-2019) UnitedStates $9,491,030 16 $3,811,000 200 QIU Ying (c.1494-1551/52) China $9,351,720 10 $4,088,140 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 68 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 201 Lee KRASNER (1908-1984) UnitedStates $9,344,780 13 $4,285,000 202 Lynette YIADOM-BOAKYE (b. 1977) UnitedKingdom $9,253,170 12 $3,602,760 X 203 TOYEN (1902-1980) CzechRepublic $9,089,470 40 $2,988,690 204 Alice NEEL (1900-1984) UnitedStates $9,083,300 44 $2,591,000 205 ZHU Da (1626-1705) China $9,047,780 26 $3,145,210 206 Lawrence ALMA-TADEMA (1836-1912) TheNetherlands $8,971,670 14 $7,068,000 207 WANG Duo (1592-1652) China $8,953,560 31 $1,496,740 208 Gustave CAILLEBOTTE (1848-1894) France $8,865,510 7 $2,838,990 209 TANG Yin (1470-1523) China $8,808,060 13 $7,407,990 210 Magdalena ABAKANOWICZ (1930-2017) Poland $8,794,940 93 $2,395,230 211 Frida KAHLO (1907-1954) Mexico $8,738,160 3 $8,230,000 212 Robert DELAUNAY (1885-1941) France $8,693,870 9 $8,624,940 X 213 Wojciech FANGOR (1922-2015) Poland $8,688,880 32 $1,886,090 214 El ANATSUI (b. 1944) Ghana $8,667,690 19 $2,228,000 X 215 Mario SCHIFANO (1934-1998) Libya $8,589,130 559 $800,370 216 Vasudeo S. GAITONDE (1924-2001) India $8,561,480 10 $5,745,600 217 Hans HARTUNG (1904-1989) Germany $8,553,250 312 $1,008,870 218 Nicolas DE STAËL (1914-1955) Russia $8,534,660 28 $2,457,910 219 Loie HOLLOWELL (b. 1983) UnitedStates $8,517,700 20 $2,292,380 X 220 Tyeb MEHTA (1925-2009) India $8,516,330 9 $3,573,910 221 OUYANG Chun (b. 1974) China $8,410,930 62 $842,810 222 Paul KLEE (1879-1940) Swiss $8,391,170 123 $3,196,000 223 Albert OEHLEN (b. 1954) Germany $8,389,280 39 $1,575,570 224 Alma THOMAS (1891-1978) UnitedStates $8,283,650 13 $3,922,000 X 225 Max LIEBERMANN (1847-1935) Germany $8,283,180 169 $1,872,330 226 Ad REINHARDT (1913-1967) UnitedStates $8,247,440 22 $3,569,000 X 227 Simone LEIGH (1968) UnitedStates $8,227,800 10 $3,085,000 X 228 Marsden HARTLEY (1877-1943) UnitedStates $8,183,610 17 $3,750,500 229 XU Beihong & Qi Baishi (XIX-XX) China $8,172,640 1 $8,172,640 X 230 Sam GILLIAM (1933-2022) UnitedStates $8,163,850 87 $1,239,980 231 YU Fei'an (1888-1959) China $8,134,790 70 $1,268,360 232 Alfred SISLEY (1839-1899) France $8,105,830 19 $2,300,000 233 Domenikos EL GRECO (1541-1614) Greece $8,006,340 2 $8,005,800 234 Georges MATHIEU (1921-2012) France $7,950,550 115 $2,049,980 235 Javier CALLEJA (b. 1971) Spain $7,939,290 126 $1,283,430 236 ZHU Dunru (1081-1159) China $7,935,800 1 $7,935,800 237 Manjit BAWA (1941-2008) India $7,897,820 14 $3,011,090 X 238 Dmitri CHERNIAK (b. 1988) Canada $7,880,900 14 $6,215,100 X 239 Amrita SHER-GIL (1913-1941) Hungary $7,872,830 10 $7,432,690 X 240 Sol LEWITT (1928-2007) UnitedStates $7,861,190 293 $1,633,000 X 241 Iwamoto MASAKAZU (b. 1969) Japan $7,793,030 71 $904,950 242 Richard ORLINSKI (b. 1966) France $7,775,910 196 $1,548,360 X 243 Lyonel FEININGER (1871-1956) UnitedStates $7,745,820 174 $2,579,200 244 Maurice DE VLAMINCK (1876-1958) France $7,581,080 172 $992,480 245 Akbar PADAMSEE (1928-2020) India $7,553,540 26 $3,107,000 X 246 Sidney Robert NOLAN (1917-1992) Australia $7,522,680 712 $1,737,130 247 Rufino TAMAYO (1899-1991) Mexican $7,517,880 289 $1,623,000 248 Shara HUGHES (b. 1981) UnitedStates $7,486,690 36 $762,370 249 LIU Haisu (1896-1994) China $7,387,510 109 $1,334,850 250 Lucy BULL (b. 1990) UnitedStates $7,372,940 16 $1,757,140 X ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 69 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 251 Scott KAHN (b. 1946) UnitedStates $7,283,920 38 $1,183,490 252 Gerrit DOW (1613-1675) TheNetherlands $7,092,230 3 $7,068,000 X 253 Eugène BOUDIN (1824-1898) France $7,091,690 94 $384,510 254 SHI Lu (1919-1982) China $7,090,440 30 $1,480,650 255 Günther UECKER (b. 1930) Germany $7,076,750 340 $1,024,560 256 André DERAIN (1880-1954) France $6,966,520 166 $3,085,000 257 John Angus CHAMBERLAIN (1927-2011) UnitedStates $6,937,970 43 $1,645,230 258 Franz KLINE (1910-1962) UnitedStates $6,898,670 18 $3,590,000 259 Anselm KIEFER (b. 1945) Germany $6,879,100 23 $1,284,330 260 Remedios Lizarraga VARO (1908-1963) Spain $6,877,810 13 $4,697,650 261 Oscar DOMINGUEZ (1906-1957) Spain $6,873,630 34 $5,568,930 X 262 Frederick Ronald WILLIAMS (1927-1982) Australia $6,870,750 51 $2,065,400 263 GONG Xian (1618-1689) China $6,811,880 10 $5,077,390 264 Ernst Ludwig KIRCHNER (1880-1938) Germany $6,789,610 195 $1,157,940 265 CHRISTO (1935-2020) Bulgaria $6,789,380 625 $320,150 266 CHEN Georgette (1907-1993) China $6,772,360 6 $1,823,990 X 267 Domenico BECCAFUMI (1486-1551) Italy $6,753,780 2 $6,488,990 X 268 Sigmar POLKE (1941-2010) Poland $6,725,840 131 $1,535,320 269 Albrecht DÜRER (1471-1528) Germany $6,696,300 619 $734,080 270 HE Haixia (1908-1998) China $6,678,190 88 $1,466,540 271 Ellsworth KELLY (1923-2015) UnitedStates $6,631,930 222 $2,238,000 272 ZHAO Zhiqian (1829-1884) China $6,537,930 40 $2,164,130 273 Giorgio DE CHIRICO (1888-1978) Greece $6,527,640 257 $654,520 274 Victor VASARELY (1906-1997) Hungary $6,517,580 1,063 $340,110 275 WANG Chong (1494-1533) China $6,508,610 12 $5,394,980 X 276 CHEN Peiqiu (1922-2020) China $6,484,280 78 $2,562,720 X 277 Wifredo LAM (1902-1982) Cuba $6,414,120 191 $1,512,000 278 MAN RAY (1890-1976) UnitedStates $6,402,560 367 $1,623,000 279 Ruth ASAWA (1926-2013) UnitedStates $6,391,010 14 $2,470,000 280 FRA ANGELICO (c.1395-1455) Italy $6,368,310 2 $6,365,190 X 281 Moïse KISLING (1891-1953) Poland $6,345,620 122 $600,800 282 Ivan AIVAZOVSKY (1817-1900) Russia $6,329,840 23 $1,157,250 283 Fitz Henry LANE (1804-1865) UnitedStates $6,327,410 4 $6,079,500 X 284 LI Kuchan (1899-1983) China $6,318,390 202 $767,540 285 Ram KUMAR (1924-2018) India $6,285,270 98 $595,650 286 Rudolf STINGEL (b. 1956) Italy $6,274,370 15 $1,740,000 287 Henri DE TOULOUSE-LAUTREC (1864-1901) France $6,141,240 332 $2,712,000 288 Raoul DUFY (1877-1953) France $6,130,470 286 $1,113,500 289 DONG Bangda (1699-1769) China $6,099,910 14 $4,989,830 290 David HAMMONS (b. 1943) UnitedStates $6,059,660 15 $2,188,000 291 Avery SINGER (b. 1987) UnitedStates $6,008,690 5 $4,063,450 292 Winslow HOMER (1836-1910) UnitedStates $6,004,790 32 $4,295,000 293 Max BECKMANN (1884-1950) Germany $5,991,080 150 $1,986,000 294 WU Hufan (1894-1968) China $5,980,460 126 $954,530 295 Emily M. CARR (1871-1945) Canada $5,948,430 30 $1,437,980 296 Stanley WHITNEY (b. 1946) UnitedStates $5,946,890 31 $1,294,260 297 Robert INDIANA (1928-2018) UnitedStates $5,932,220 480 $957,600 298 CHEN Fei (b. 1983) China $5,930,250 17 $1,211,780 X 299 ZHANG Ruitu (1570-1641) China $5,890,140 21 $1,997,660 300 Anita MAGSAYSAY-HO (1914-2012) Philippines $5,867,380 31 $1,564,510 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 70 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 301 XIANG Shengmo (1597-1658) China $5,865,370 10 $4,770,160 X 302 Jan I BRUEGHEL (1568-1625) Flanders $5,863,290 10 $1,980,000 303 Cao Dam VU (1908-2000) Vietnam $5,859,270 69 $889,820 304 STURTEVANT (1930-2014) UnitedStates $5,827,740 18 $2,419,500 305 HE Jiaying (b. 1957) China $5,792,870 48 $443,920 306 Ben NICHOLSON (1894-1982) UnitedKingdom $5,784,490 76 $1,665,900 307 Ernst Wilhelm NAY (1902-1968) Germany $5,746,800 81 $1,742,280 308 JIN Shangyi (b. 1934) China $5,740,230 7 $2,996,500 309 Henry TAYLOR (b. 1958) UnitedStates $5,680,180 14 $2,480,000 X 310 Alberto BURRI (1915-1995) Italy $5,679,840 55 $3,722,910 311 Piero DORAZIO (1927-2005) Italy $5,655,610 458 $362,070 312 Antonio CANOVA (1757-1822) Italy $5,630,340 4 $4,517,110 313 Joseph SIMA (1891-1971) Czechia $5,623,880 55 $862,390 314 WANG Xingwei (b. 1969) China $5,601,030 17 $1,317,000 315 Izumi KATO (b. 1969) Japan $5,522,160 56 $728,040 316 MEI Qing (1623-1697) China $5,496,480 9 $2,502,840 317 LU Zhi (1496-1576) China $5,492,430 5 $5,465,470 X 318 Karl SCHMIDT-ROTTLUFF (1884-1976) Germany $5,482,040 233 $819,010 319 Karel APPEL (1921-2006) TheNetherlands $5,453,740 415 $343,930 320 Gustave LOISEAU (1865-1935) France $5,413,210 50 $394,320 321 Etel ADNAN (1925-2021) Lebanon $5,391,050 80 $397,630 322 Irma STERN (1894-1966) SouthAfrica $5,342,730 41 $1,228,010 323 Maurice UTRILLO (1883-1955) France $5,338,720 118 $375,860 324 Cindy SHERMAN (b. 1954) UnitedStates $5,302,490 80 $971,360 325 HUANG Daozhou (1585-1646) China $5,284,000 9 $3,765,810 326 HUANG Jiannan (b. 1952) China $5,253,430 7 $1,933,780 327 Miriam CAHN (b. 1949) Swiss $5,243,590 44 $702,370 X 328 YAN Wenliang (1893-1988) China $5,232,840 16 $3,111,220 329 Marie Mela MUTER (1876-1967) Poland $5,155,820 72 $386,560 330 JIANG Zhaohe (1904-1986) China $5,146,350 22 $3,569,200 331 Brett WHITELEY (1939-1992) Australia $5,138,210 103 $1,421,280 332 SHEN Zhou (1427-1509) China $5,135,630 22 $998,830 333 Otto MUELLER (1874-1930) Poland $5,120,780 57 $1,285,140 334 CHENG Shifa (1921-2007) China $5,119,980 222 $264,280 335 Morris LOUIS (1912-1962) UnitedStates $5,091,500 4 $2,954,000 336 WANG Shimin (1592-1680) China $5,075,960 8 $3,244,730 337 Pietro LORENZETTI (1276/80-1348) Italy $5,060,830 2 $3,273,080 338 JU Ming (1938-2023) Taiwan $5,043,840 48 $755,890 339 CHEONG Soo Pieng (1917-1983) China $5,015,630 24 $1,475,800 X 340 Rembrandt BUGATTI (1884-1916) Italy $4,977,460 20 $584,800 341 Roberto MATTA (1911-2002) Chile $4,972,940 393 $482,600 342 Martin KIPPENBERGER (1953-1997) Germany $4,965,100 63 $3,000,000 343 SHI Tao (1642-c.1707) China $4,957,220 17 $1,423,330 344 CHEN Ke (b. 1978) China $4,926,880 40 $1,252,500 X 345 Whan-Ki KIM (1913-1974) Korea $4,924,890 27 $1,413,730 346 Tyler HOBBS (b. 1987) UnitedStates $4,922,580 16 $1,016,000 X 347 Ewa JUSZKIEWICZ (b. 1984) Poland $4,906,250 24 $762,370 348 VALENTIN DE BOULOGNE (1594-1632) France $4,890,000 1 $4,890,000 349 Orazio GENTILESCHI (1563-1639) Italy $4,890,000 1 $4,890,000 350 LIN Sanzhi (1898-1989) China $4,882,710 180 $320,340 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 71 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 351 LENG Jun (b. 1963) China $4,854,620 22 $1,439,990 352 Paula REGO (1935-2022) Portugal $4,819,230 93 $3,720,180 X 353 Marino MARINI (1901-1980) Italy $4,817,560 266 $1,381,000 354 Fairfield PORTER (1907-1975) UnitedStates $4,805,150 37 $2,843,000 X 355 Lovis CORINTH (1858-1925) Germany $4,803,400 153 $983,570 356 Camille Jean-Baptiste COROT (1796-1875) France $4,797,660 77 $756,000 357 André BRASILIER (b. 1929) France $4,772,120 177 $388,280 358 Lucie RIE (1902-1995) Austria $4,766,280 160 $438,630 X 359 LIU Wei (b. 1965) China $4,745,690 29 $1,553,740 360 YU Youren (1879-1964) China $4,714,960 294 $317,030 361 Wade GUYTON (b. 1972) UnitedStates $4,702,490 16 $1,740,000 362 Roman OPALKA (1931-2011) France $4,695,130 38 $1,126,340 363 Konrad KLAPHECK (1935-2023) Germany $4,689,490 45 $2,654,710 X 364 CHEN Hongshou (1598-1652) China $4,679,350 23 $979,950 365 Paul DELVAUX (1897-1994) Belgium $4,676,620 130 $1,502,960 366 Richard ESTES (b. 1932) UnitedStates $4,657,730 75 $1,284,000 X 367 Bhupen KHAKHAR (1934-2003) India $4,616,510 16 $2,466,070 368 Kenneth NOLAND (1924-2010) UnitedStates $4,614,600 46 $1,134,000 369 Glenn LIGON (b. 1960) UnitedStates $4,588,090 22 $3,177,000 370 Paul SÉRUSIER (1864-1927) France $4,575,080 29 $1,391,000 371 Alfons WALDE (1891-1958) Austria $4,544,860 44 $488,310 372 Howard A. TERPNING (b. 1927) UnitedStates $4,523,960 52 $2,360,000 X 373 Hermann NITSCH (1938-2022) Austria $4,510,750 241 $170,560 374 Giovanni GIACOMETTI (1868-1933) Swiss $4,505,530 42 $1,303,400 375 Jagdish SWAMINATHAN (1928-1994) India $4,493,170 22 $904,030 376 AFFANDI (1907-1990) Indonesia $4,470,790 36 $548,830 377 Hans HOFMANN (1880-1966) Germany $4,459,820 34 $3,075,000 378 Simon HANTAÏ (1922-2008) Hungary $4,455,360 26 $1,020,320 379 Anne VALLAYER-COSTER (1744-1818) France $4,434,010 7 $2,824,500 X 380 Barbara KRUGER (b. 1945) UnitedStates $4,429,250 43 $1,068,830 381 Fernando ZOBEL DE AYALA (1924-1984) Philippines $4,409,070 80 $381,250 382 Fernando AMORSOLO (1892-1972) Philippines $4,396,610 56 $349,480 383 Diego VELÁZQUEZ & Pietro MARTIRE-NERI (XVII) $4,369,540 1 $4,369,540 X 384 Attribué à MASTER JOHN (XVI) UnitedKingdom $4,367,000 1 $4,367,000 X 385 Jaune Quick-to-See SMITH (b. 1940) UnitedStates $4,346,480 43 $571,500 386 Tracey EMIN (b. 1963) UnitedKingdom $4,270,880 252 $1,648,170 387 William Adolphe BOUGUEREAU (1825-1905) France $4,258,090 32 $882,000 388 Robert GOBER (b. 1954) UnitedStates $4,205,770 23 $3,448,000 389 Aristide MAILLOL (1861-1944) France $4,202,420 117 $2,912,420 390 Aboudia DIARRASSOUBA (b. 1983) IvoryCoast $4,191,280 68 $180,280 391 QIAN Songyan (1899-1985) China $4,172,370 83 $333,710 392 FANG Lijun (b. 1963) China $4,171,980 14 $2,867,530 393 Berthe MORISOT (1841-1895) France $4,157,300 41 $1,623,000 394 Milton Clark AVERY (1885-1965) UnitedStates $4,145,790 73 $1,986,000 395 Eva HESSE (1936-1970) Germany $4,137,160 6 $3,085,000 396 A.R. PENCK (1939-2017) Germany $4,131,280 284 $481,830 397 Paul MANSHIP (1885-1966) UnitedStates $4,101,410 24 $1,143,000 398 Robert COMBAS (b. 1957) France $4,100,670 197 $208,420 399 WANG Yidong (b. 1955) China $4,094,340 6 $1,351,530 400 REN Yi (1840-1896) China $4,092,830 75 $321,880 ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 72 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 401 Fernandez ARMAN (1928-2005) France $4,079,260 600 $139,760 402 WANG Guangle (b. 1976) China $4,072,440 13 $592,340 403 Katharina GROSSE (b. 1961) Germany $4,031,940 48 $327,600 404 Richard AVEDON (1923-2004) UnitedStates $4,013,480 90 $444,500 405 Emil FILLA (1882-1953) Czechia $4,009,220 37 $849,570 406 John MARIN (1870-1953) UnitedStates $3,973,220 47 $1,925,500 X 407 LI Chen (b. 1963) Taiwan $3,972,090 19 $533,420 408 William Merritt CHASE (1849-1916) UnitedStates $3,968,140 18 $2,843,000 409 Gertrude ABERCROMBIE (1909-1977) UnitedStates $3,966,280 30 $352,800 410 Bridget RILEY (b. 1931) UnitedKingdom $3,963,020 97 $1,216,330 411 William KENTRIDGE (b. 1955) SouthAfrica $3,941,940 238 $279,400 412 Howard HODGKIN (1932-2017) UnitedKingdom $3,938,910 112 $940,080 413 SHANG Yang (b. 1942) China $3,936,970 16 $1,371,910 414 CÉSAR (1921-1998) France $3,936,580 247 $441,350 415 Bernardo CAVALLINO (1616/22-1654/56) Italy $3,922,000 1 $3,922,000 X 416 André MASSON (1896-1987) France $3,897,910 287 $1,212,530 417 Lawren Stewart H. HARRIS (1885-1970) Canada $3,882,250 26 $1,617,730 418 Kenny SCHARF (b. 1958) UnitedStates $3,879,720 76 $435,000 419 Young Kuk YOO (1916-2002) Korea $3,861,910 10 $973,460 420 SONG Wenzhi (1919-1999) China $3,841,440 115 $634,050 421 ZHENG Banqiao (1693-1765) China $3,831,470 30 $576,610 422 Yves TANGUY (1900-1955) France $3,818,250 26 $1,506,710 423 William HOGARTH (1697-1764) UnitedKingdom $3,806,220 75 $3,136,720 X 424 Jean Édouard VUILLARD (1868-1940) France $3,791,430 73 $1,512,000 425 Erich HECKEL (1883-1970) Germany $3,778,890 287 $751,340 426 Maximilien LUCE (1858-1941) France $3,763,860 168 $529,550 427 Per KIRKEBY (1938-2018) Denmark $3,759,260 73 $484,140 428 LAN Ying (1585-c.1664) China $3,753,810 31 $666,840 429 Tschang-Yeul KIM (1929-2021) NorthKorea $3,746,810 54 $643,310 430 Carla ACCARDI (1924-2014) Italy $3,727,580 152 $389,920 X 431 Jesús Rafael SOTO (1923-2005) Venezuela $3,720,050 119 $952,500 432 Pierre ALECHINSKY (b. 1927) Belgium $3,710,270 332 $343,930 433 HERGÉ (1907-1983) Belgium $3,705,560 117 $2,302,660 434 Charles BLACKMAN (1928-2018) Australia $3,684,270 222 $982,270 435 Georges DE LA TOUR (1593-1652) France $3,680,000 1 $3,680,000 436 Eduardo CHILLIDA (1924-2002) Spain $3,669,080 216 $1,948,900 437 GUAN Shanyue (1912-2000) China $3,667,690 70 $563,290 438 Hiroshi SUGIMOTO (b. 1948) Japan $3,655,900 135 $508,000 439 Anthonius VAN DYCK (1599-1641) Belgium $3,649,210 13 $3,075,000 440 ZHU Yunming (1460-1526) China $3,647,550 12 $3,145,210 441 QIN Qi (b. 1975) China $3,647,100 28 $546,070 442 Nicole EISENMAN (b. 1965) France $3,645,910 28 $2,430,000 X 443 Julian SCHNABEL (b. 1951) UnitedStates $3,644,570 42 $1,270,000 444 Hans ARP (1886-1966) France $3,607,820 151 $1,391,000 445 HAO Liang (b. 1983) China $3,603,370 3 $3,140,160 X 446 Newell Convers WYETH (1882-1945) UnitedStates $3,595,850 10 $2,450,000 447 James ROSENQUIST (1933-2017) UnitedStates $3,581,810 219 $954,190 448 Jacques Louis DAVID (1748-1825) France $3,528,490 7 $3,444,290 449 LIU Yong (1719/20-1804/05) China $3,520,660 72 $568,840 450 Toshiko TAKAEZU (1922-2011) UnitedStates $3,516,430 211 $541,800 X ©artprice.com1987-2024/ARAA 73 *New personal record for the artist Rank Artist Country Sales proceeds Lots sold Best Sale Record* 451 Michaela YEARWOOD-DAN (b. 1994) UnitedKingdom $3,506,140 12 $884,350 X 452 Albert ANKER (1831-1910) Swiss $3,482,790 40 $1,275,360 453 Agnes PELTON (1881-1961) UnitedStates $3,465,490 4 $3,438,000 X 454 Vicente MANANSALA (1910-1981) Philippines $3,464,540 38 $1,050,380 X 455 Enrico CASTELLANI (1930-2017) Italy $3,464,360 52 $584,890 456 HE Duoling (b. 1948) China $3,437,910 18 $1,284,880 457 Salman TOOR (b. 1983) Pakistan $3,433,110 14 $558,800 458 Albert MARQUET (1875-1947) France $3,419,650 171 $362,850 459 LIANG Yuanwei (b. 1977) China $3,407,430 6 $1,901,210 460 Heinz MACK (b. 1931) Germany $3,393,220 129 $542,270 461 Hiroshige ANDO (1797-1858) Japan $3,392,290 715 $365,140 462 WEI Jia (b. 1975) China $3,355,040 25 $404,290 463 DING Yi (b. 1962) China $3,350,350 22 $417,590 464 Maurice DENIS (1870-1943) France $3,344,470 66 $733,670 465 JIANG Tingxi (1669-1732) China $3,341,960 22 $1,132,490 466 XU Yang (act.c.1751-c.1776) China $3,339,120 2 $3,302,270 467 Jean-Baptiste OUDRY (1686-1755) France $3,334,310 13 $2,700,000 X 468 Robert LONGO (b. 1953) UnitedStates $3,328,700 102 $587,210 469 Arnaldo POMODORO (b. 1926) Italy $3,309,810 171 $326,500 470 MA Ke (b. 1970) China $3,297,260 58 $216,910 471 Howardena Doreen PINDELL (b. 1943) UnitedStates $3,293,080 8 $1,633,000 X 472 John James AUDUBON (1785-1851) Haiti $3,260,530 241 $756,000 473 Jaume PLENSA (b. 1955) Spain $3,259,810 51 $482,600 474 SHENG Mou (c.1313-c.1362) China $3,256,760 2 $2,856,170 475 DONG Shouping (1904-1997) China $3,248,160 128 $713,450 476 Ganesh PYNE (1937-2013) India $3,237,570 43 $720,060 X 477 Ansel Easton ADAMS (1902-1984) UnitedStates $3,232,490 235 $381,000 478 Thomas Hart BENTON (1889-1975) UnitedStates $3,220,440 345 $1,623,000 479 Harry BERTOIA (1915-1978) Italy $3,206,830 149 $287,500 480 Bae LEE (b. 1956) SouthKorea $3,205,460 47 $154,970 481 KANG Youwei (1858-1927) China $3,199,010 71 $368,860 482 Franz MARC (1880-1916) Germany $3,196,740 30 $2,652,650 483 Winfred REMBERT (1945-2021) UnitedStates $3,192,790 33 $327,600 X 484 Leonora CARRINGTON (1917-2011) UnitedKingdom $3,189,600 19 $1,067,320 485 Hendra GUNAWAN (1918-1983) Indonesia $3,185,670 23 $775,670 486 Frederick LEIGHTON (1830-1896) UnitedKingdom $3,178,730 20 $1,623,000 487 QIU Xiaofei (b. 1977) China $3,178,300 13 $835,170 X 488 Arthur BOYD (1920-1999) Australia $3,168,870 118 $556,620 489 Louis FRATINO (b. 1993) UnitedStates $3,166,330 43 $336,450 490 GUERCINO (1591-1666) Italy $3,141,890 26 $1,865,000 491 Issy WOOD (b. 1993) UnitedStates $3,136,060 14 $511,490 492 WANG Yuan (1271-1368) China $3,125,460 1 $3,125,460 493 MAO Dun (1896-1981) China $3,117,290 8 $2,883,050 494 Artemisia GENTILESCHI (1593-c.1654) Italy $3,117,010 2 $2,361,010 495 Matazo KAYAMA (1927-2004) Japan $3,108,320 33 $1,390,790 X 496 Raymond PETTIBON (b. 1957) UnitedStates $3,108,150 88 $1,865,000 497 Maynard DIXON (1875-1946) UnitedStates $3,099,480 42 $2,130,000 X 498 José JOYA (1931-1995) Philippines $3,096,980 49 $1,078,240 499 Mohammed SAMI (b. 1984) Iraq $3,094,340 8 $952,500 X 500 Robert MANGOLD (b. 1937) UnitedStates $3,090,240 92 $478,800 74  Wan Jie and Thierry Ehrmann 75 ABOUT ARTPRICE BY ARTMARKET Artmarket.com is a global player in the Art Market with, among other structures, its Artprice department, world leader in the accumulation, management and exploitation of historical and current art market information in databanks containing over 30 million indices and auction results, covering more than 833,900 artists. Artprice Images® allows unlimited access to the largest Art Market image bank in the world: no less than 180 million digital images of photographs or engraved reproductions of artworks from 1700 to the present day, commented by our art historians. Artmarket.com with its Artprice department accumulates data on a permanent basis from 7,200 Auction Houses and produces key Art Market information for the main press and media agencies (7,200 publications). Its 7.2 million members log in’ users have access to ads posted by other members, a network that today represents the leading Global Standardized Marketplace® to buy and sell artworks at a fixed or bid price (auctions regulated by paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article L 321.3 of France’s Commercial Code). Artmarket, with its Artprice department, has twice been awarded the State label “Innovative Company” by the Public Investment Bank (BPI), which has supported the company in its project to consolidate its position as a global player in the art market. Artmarket.com is listed on Eurolist by Euronext Paris: Euroclear: 7478 - Bloomberg: PRC - Reuters: ARTF. ABOUT ARAA ABOUT ARAA, A Professional and Authoritative Chinese ArtworkMarket Data Service Platform and Research Institution ArtronResearchAcademyofArts(ARAA) is an independent third-party Chinese artwork market data service platform and research organization of Artron Art Group, focusing on data search, artwork valuation, AMMI, data reporting and other relevant services of the Chinese artwork market. It concentrates on the data monitor of the Chinese art market, analysis and investigation of the Chinese art market, return of art investment, and artwork valuation consultation service. Our research and consulting services are on the basis of China’s first and most comprehensive database, Artron’s Chinese Artworks Database, recording over 30,000,000 Chinese artworks auction results from over 120,000 sales, with highdefinition images and complete illustrative information from over 2,500 auction houses since the first art auction hammer was knocked in China in 1993, as well as Chinese artworks sold overseas. With its powerful database and its expertise in art market data analysis that establishes its authority, ARAA has become the most important partner of the government, institutions, auction houses and media organizations in art related fields in China — the main partnerships include the Ministry of Culture and Tourism of the People’s Republic of China, Beijing Municipal Bureau of Culture, the Palace Museum, the Department of Culture of Guangdong Province, Shanghai Municipal Bureau of Culture and Tourism, and the Art Financial Research Institute of Renmin University of China, TEFAF, as well as Larry’s List and the world famous art market database & market place Artprice.com. Follow Artprice.com on Founder and CEO: thierry Ehrmann ArtMarket.com, a limited company with capital of €6,651,515 - RCS Lyon 411 309 198 Domaine de la Source/Abode of Chaos, B.P. 69 St-Romain-au-Mont-d’Or 69270 - FRANCE Tel +33 (0)4 78 22 00 00 - Fax +33 (0)4 78 22 06 06 Publication Director: thierry Ehrmann Editorial Director: Nadège Ehrmann Writing and editing: Céline Moine, Jean Minguet Economic and financial analysis: thierry Ehrmann Designers: Audrey Savoye, Gabrielle Pélissier Market Analysis and Econometrics: Jean Minguet Artmarket.com is listed on Eurolist by Euronext Paris, Euroclear: 7478 - Bloomberg: PRC - Reuters: ARTF ArtMarket.com is a company of / S.A.S. Capital €61,741,050 - RCS Lyon 408 369 270 All rights reserved for all countries - © Artprice.com 2024 For journalists: Need specific art market data for your stories? Please contact us by email: econometrics@artprice.com We will be happy to provide you with relevant data and statistics. In compiling this report its authors and publisher have made every effort to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the information it contains. However, they cannot be held responsible for the information provided, or for any typos, errors or omissions that it may contain in spite of the care taken in writing and compiling the information. To the knowledge of the publisher, as this document lists no repurchases, the works listed in this book were actually sold at the prices indicated. Auction houses and auctioneers were questioned to this effect. The editor declines any responsibility for uses made of this publication. The prices indicated may in no way be considered as professional appraisals and have a purely indicative value. No data contained in this publication may be reproduced, transcribed or indexed, whether by means of analogical or digital storage systems, nor distributed via electronic, mechanical or other means without the prior written agreement of the copyright holder. Any unauthorised reproduction, in whole or in part, by any means whatsoever, of the data contained in the present publication is illegal and constitutes a forgery (law of 11 March 1957 art. 40/41 French Penal code art. 425). This is a non contractual document - ArtMarket.com company reserves the right to modify any data or products characteristics. ©Artprice by Artmarket.com 1987/2024 - Indexed auction records are based on Fine Art and Design cataloged auctions (paintings, sculptures, drawings, photographs, prints, watercolors, etc) recorded by artprice.com, except antiques and furniture. Artmarket.com declines all responsibility for any use made of the provided information. Any reproduction or representation of all or part of the information or graphics by any means whatsoever that does not include a mention stating “copyright Artprice by Artmarket.com/Artron.net” is illegal and represents a breach of copyright. ARAA (Artron Research Academy of Arts, ARAA) A Professional and Authoritative Artwork Market Data Service Platform Research Analysts & Writing & Editing: Cuiyun Xu, Tingting Chen, Jiali Duan Media: Baoxing Li Design: Weijie Li Legal Support: Zhe Qin Tel: +4006690999-+80451188 Web: http://amma.artron.net Email: amma@artron.net Address: Artron Art Center, No.3 Dasheng Road, JinMa Industrial Zone, Shunyi District, Beijing The Art Market in 2023 by Artprice.com & ARAA This 28th edition is available for free and in 3 languages on Artprice.com