city ID union offer employer offer employer wins arbitration date 1 43883 41898 0 2001-09-01 2 54675 49415 0 2003-01-01 3 49265 46329 0 2000-11-01 4 54920 52308 0 2002-12-01 5 45035 43771 0 2000-11-01 6 47977 43298 0 2002-12-01 7 51629 50589 1 2000-07-01 8 45724 41824 1 2003-04-01 9 48489 44730 0 2002-02-01 10 52633 49677 0 2001-05-01 11 49472 48422 0 2002-01-01 12 47851 44686 0 2002-08-01 13 44173 42418 0 2002-06-01 14 40730 35355 0 2002-03-01 15 52238 50649 1 2000-07-01 16 51268 48959 0 2001-11-01 17 46979 42490 0 2000-02-01 18 50215 47571 0 2003-10-01 19 46764 45716 0 2001-09-01 20 51519 45547 0 2000-01-01 21 49862 43769 1 2000-10-01 22 47234 42680 0 2001-11-01 23 47934 43002 0 2002-01-01 24 49414 44528 0 2002-11-01 25 50970 48149 1 2003-05-01 26 48908 45689 0 2001-06-01 27 48719 42657 1 2000-12-01 28 52562 51663 0 2001-11-01 29 44745 40823 0 2001-03-01 30 42687 38194 0 2003-04-01 31 55881 52309 0 2001-02-01 32 48306 43055 0 2001-04-01 33 60595 59497 1 2000-04-01 34 51888 47930 1 2000-05-01 35 47122 46123 1 2003-11-01 36 45502 42805 1 2003-05-01 37 47753 44861 0 2003-12-01 38 42751 42116 0 2000-03-01 39 51474 48064 0 2002-11-01 40 40202 36600 0 2003-01-01 41 53430 52468 0 2001-08-01 42 47380 41960 1 2002-02-01 43 49485 47541 0 2000-04-01 44 47727 47114 0 2001-09-01 45 52242 46533 0 2003-07-01 46 50840 48519 0 2002-06-01 47 44749 42857 1 2003-12-01 48 48903 46619 0 2000-04-01 49 48352 47470 1 2000-12-01 50 46459 40857 0 2000-01-01 51 57129 51632 1 2002-08-01 52 50621 46475 1 2001-11-01 53 46234 45210 0 2001-06-01 54 43097 38126 1 2000-02-01 55 44787 43796 0 2003-06-01 56 58420 55864 0 2002-06-01 57 46802 43802 0 2000-08-01 58 49150 47188 1 2000-07-01 59 51137 46606 0 2001-07-01 60 48109 46446 0 2003-05-01 61 50726 47859 0 2000-10-01 62 45076 42886 0 2000-09-01 63 48229 45497 0 2000-09-01 64 51030 49688 1 2002-04-01 65 45352 42437 1 2001-01-01 66 41408 40569 0 2000-04-01 67 49066 47650 1 2002-04-01 68 54137 51241 0 2002-04-01 69 42730 41168 0 2001-01-01 70 50384 48785 0 2000-11-01 71 51597 48521 0 2003-04-01 72 50738 44721 0 2002-09-01 73 48155 43608 1 2001-04-01 74 50413 47422 0 2001-10-01 75 48297 42236 1 2000-09-01 76 44197 39117 1 2000-07-01 77 53277 48593 0 2001-09-01 78 50563 49633 0 2003-02-01 79 54048 49253 1 2002-03-01 80 57297 52766 1 2000-05-01 81 46342 41270 0 2002-12-01 82 49480 44371 0 2000-04-01 83 50199 46446 1 2002-04-01 84 44935 41246 0 2003-06-01 85 45209 44069 0 2002-04-01 86 45373 41489 0 2000-10-01 87 47129 43010 0 2003-04-01 88 50738 44714 0 2000-10-01 89 40843 39209 0 2000-07-01 90 47938 45851 0 2001-06-01 91 43151 42427 1 2003-08-01 92 47715 45405 0 2003-02-01 93 47084 41954 1 2002-01-01 94 46077 42732 0 2001-01-01 95 49050 47048 0 2001-06-01 96 52952 50350 0 2003-03-01 97 51337 47178 0 2000-10-01 98 44324 39765 0 2000-02-01 99 39264 33228 1 2001-12-01 100 45241 43361 1 2003-12-01 101 44493 38880 1 2003-08-01 102 51640 50251 1 2002-10-01 103 44242 38595 0 2000-03-01 104 56407 51491 0 2001-01-01 105 51840 46338 1 2000-09-01 106 50210 47236 1 2000-08-01 107 50278 49050 0 2001-01-01 108 45369 41657 1 2001-03-01 109 45009 41495 0 2003-01-01 110 50485 47577 0 2000-03-01 111 60850 58231 0 2001-02-01 112 51278 49150 0 2002-05-01 113 41535 39211 0 2001-04-01 114 46325 41965 0 2000-12-01 115 48574 46081 0 2003-05-01 116 51304 48054 0 2001-04-01 117 51721 46706 1 2000-01-01 118 45591 43962 0 2003-09-01 119 48000 45753 0 2002-03-01 120 49447 44712 1 2000-04-01 121 44290 42401 0 2000-02-01 122 43295 39100 1 2000-03-01 123 48517 44883 0 2000-01-01 124 47633 43804 0 2001-12-01 125 41548 37003 0 2000-10-01 126 40294 39519 0 2000-01-01 127 47452 44482 0 2003-09-01 128 50394 47528 0 2000-04-01 129 52798 48680 0 2000-02-01 130 45400 42038 0 2003-01-01 131 47651 43308 0 2000-12-01 132 45293 39649 1 2002-03-01 133 39565 37387 1 2001-12-01 134 43977 42547 1 2002-03-01 135 52606 51339 0 2003-06-01 136 57744 51928 0 2002-04-01 137 53541 51608 0 2000-07-01 138 45120 44308 0 2002-03-01 139 46770 45409 0 2000-09-01 140 45483 40621 1 2001-12-01 141 49610 45824 0 2002-11-01 142 53381 51788 0 2001-06-01 143 45968 40105 0 2001-09-01 144 49862 47705 0 2002-05-01 145 46565 43689 0 2001-07-01 146 43429 39094 0 2003-03-01 147 56771 51251 1 2001-02-01 148 40655 35870 1 2000-08-01 149 45398 39360 1 2001-02-01 150 49201 44234 0 2002-04-01 151 53757 51120 0 2002-08-01 152 52485 48844 1 2001-10-01 153 50406 46255 1 2000-12-01 154 42412 38236 0 2003-11-01 155 42673 41646 1 2002-01-01 156 52568 47311 0 2003-03-01 157 41550 38640 0 2003-06-01 158 49919 48761 1 2002-06-01 159 51075 48218 1 2002-07-01 160 46401 45039 1 2001-08-01 161 54784 50622 0 2002-05-01 162 51649 49764 0 2001-09-01 163 47400 45438 0 2001-06-01 164 44338 43670 0 2002-04-01 165 39749 37019 1 2002-10-01 166 55129 54280 0 2001-12-01 167 41053 39658 1 2003-01-01 168 50506 48780 1 2000-07-01 169 51972 48574 1 2003-07-01 170 52914 51828 0 2001-01-01 171 45380 44229 0 2001-02-01 172 48208 47606 0 2001-06-01 173 49312 48571 0 2001-01-01 174 46757 43731 0 2002-05-01 175 49465 44213 0 2003-11-01 176 49360 45306 0 2000-11-01 177 48505 46937 0 2002-02-01 178 50068 47399 0 2001-09-01 179 50537 46193 0 2000-08-01 180 49045 46885 0 2000-12-01 181 43377 42096 0 2002-08-01 182 50444 48233 0 2001-05-01 183 43405 42561 1 2002-07-01 184 55029 52074 1 2002-11-01 185 41829 37051 1 2001-12-01 186 47919 43336 0 2000-03-01 187 49591 48138 0 2001-05-01 188 48892 47269 1 2000-02-01 189 50415 47942 1 2001-10-01 190 46281 44171 1 2002-06-01 191 49411 45325 0 2002-12-01 192 45931 43813 0 2002-03-01 193 47331 43634 0 2001-11-01 194 42994 39456 0 2002-10-01 195 47635 44056 0 2002-01-01 196 46770 41472 1 2000-11-01 197 61023 58747 1 2001-11-01 198 48030 44831 1 2001-12-01 199 51630 49841 1 2001-04-01 200 43749 38211 1 2002-12-01