STRUCTURE IT USING NOUN CLAUSES Situation John and Susan work in the same office. Another colleague, Larry, had asked them to meet with him on Monday morning at 7:00 a.m. to discuss a pressing issue. It is now 7:20 a.m. on Monday. John and Susan are in the office. Larry has not shown up or called. Read the conversation that John and Susan are having: John: Where is Larry? Susan: I don't know where he is. John: When did he leave the house? Susan: I can't tell you when he left. I called his place five minutes ago, but no one answered. John: He must be on his way then. How does he get to the office? Does he drive? Susan: I've never asked him how he gets here. John: Why don't we ask his secretary what time she expects him? Susan: None of the secretaries get in before 8:30. I'm sure we're the only ones here this early. John: I hope Larry's okay. I'm getting kind of worried about what might have happened to him. Susan: He's probably stuck in traffic. Why he wanted to meet so early is a mystery to me! Function of a Noun Clause The underlined statements in the preceding conversation are all examples of noun clauses. Noun clauses are used in a sentence to describe actions which are subordinate to the main action of the sentence. Let's look closely at some of John's and Susan's statements: John: When did he leave the house? Susan: I don't know when he left. The action expressed in John's question is leave. The main action expressed in Susan's response is know. "When he left" describes an action which is subordinate to the main action (know) of the sentence. A noun clause gets its name from the function it serves. A noun is the name of a person, place, or thing. Examples of nouns are: - my boss - the affidavit - a witness A noun can function as: (1) subject of a verb - His reasons are a mystery to me. (2) object of a (transitive) verb - I don't know his location. (3) object of a preposition - I'm worried about my colleague. A clause is composed of a subject and a verb. Examples of clauses are: - She knows - My boss went - The client isn't coming A noun clause has the same functions as a noun. A noun clause can function as: (1) the subject of a verb (2) the object of a verb (3) the object of a preposition For example: (1) subject of a verb His reasons are a mystery to me. Why he wanted to meet is a mystery to me. (2) object of a verb I don't know his location. I don't know where he is. (3) object of a preposition I'm worried about my colleague. I'm worried about what might have happened to him. In each of the above examples, the noun has been replaced by a description of that noun. The description is expressed by means of a subject and a verb, that is, by means of a clause. Form of a Noun Clause As explained earlier, noun clauses function in the sentence to describe actions which are subordinate to the main action. Therefore, a noun clause must be introduced by a subordinating conjunction. A conjunction is a word that joins two actions. And and but are typical conjunctions. For example: She leaves work and picks up her kids from school. He understands almost everything, but he has a hard time expressing himself. The subordinating conjunction joins a subordinate action to the main action. For example: I don't know why they refused to arbitrate. main action subordinate action subordinating conjunction The first word of the noun clause must be a subordinating conjunction. Because most noun clauses describe who, what, when, where, whose, which, and how, the subordinating conjunctions used to introduce noun clauses are almost always WH-words. For example: They can't remember where they put that file. (1) The wh-word indicates the kind of information the noun clause contains: location = where. (2) The subject of the noun clause must follow the subordinating conjunction: where they. (3) The verb of the noun clause follows the subject, just as in any other clause: where they put NOTE Sometimes the subordinator is used as the subject of the noun clause. For example: I can't remember who told me that. I'm very interested in what happened. In these instances, the verb follows the wh-word. REMEMBER Use sentential -- not interrogative -- word order in noun clauses. CORRECT: We objected to what she said. INCORRECT: We objected to what did she say. The function of the auxiliary (do, did) in the interrogative is to notify the listener (or the reader) that a question is being asked. Information is requested in a question, and the listener/reader must typically provide this information in his/her response. For example: Why did he leave the firm? The listener/reader has to provide an answer: Because he . . . . However, in the following statement: I can't tell you why he left the firm. there is no information requested. Instead I can't tell you why he left the firm. is equivalent to: I can't tell you his reason. EXERCISES Answer the following questions using a noun clause as indicated: Example: What did the client say? I can't discuss what the client said. 1. Where are they holding next month's conference? I don't know ________________________. 2. When will they be ready for trial? They haven’t told me _______________________. 3. How much are they claiming in damages? I still haven’t heard ______________________. 4. Who are their key witnesses? We’ll find out tomorrow _________________________. 5. Why didn’t they include an arbitration clause in that contract? I can't understand ________________________. 6. Whose office should we use? It doesn't matter _________________________. 7. What is the definition of materiality in that jurisdiction? My associate is checking _____________________. YOUR TURN ANSWER SHEET 1. Where are they holding next month's conference? I don't know where they're holding next month's conference. 2. When will they be ready for trial? They haven’t told me when they’ll be ready for trial. 3. How much are they claiming in damages? I still haven’t heard how much they’re claiming in damages. 4. Who are their key witnesses? We’ll find out tomorrow who their key witnesses are. 5. Why didn’t they include an arbitration clause in that contract? I can't understand why they didn’t include an arbitration clause in that contract. 6. Whose office should we use? It doesn't matter whose office we use. 7. What is the definition of materiality in that jurisdiction? My associate is checking what the definition of materiality is in that jurisdiction.