Jméno: Zuzana Fialová
                                                                                        Učo: 390799


                                            BRIEF CASE


Parties

Under-age Zuzana and František

Facts

In 1965 František met Marta. Their relationship lasted only 5-6 weeks. During their relationship
they had sexual intercourse. At that time, Marta was already pregnant as she had sexual intercource
with other three men, but Frantisek did not know it. He got to know it many years later. Marta’s
daughter (Zuzana) had no father until 1970 when the first instance court ruled that František is
her father. The court decision was based on blood test. The result was higher than 50% probability
that František is the father.  And that was the reason why the court decided that František is the
father.

Legal issue

The question before the court is whether mother’s testimony is credible.
And the next issue in this case is, if the reasoning of the lower court is sufficient.

The rulling of the court

The court affirmed the decision of the lower court.

The reasoning of the court

The court argued that mother’s testimony is credible because she has good behavior.
The court also noted that there are no serious circumstances that would exclude paternity.