European Administrative Judiciary
Doc. Dr. Vuk Cucic
University of Belgrade
Faculty of Law

University of Belgrade
Faculty of Law


Vuk Cucic
´Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Law of the University of Belgrade (2008- )
´Teaching Administrative Law, Procedural Administrative Law and Comparative Judicial Control of
Administration ´PhD thesis “Administrative Dispute of Full Jurisdiction (Contentieux de pleine
juridiction) – Models and Types” ´Special Adviser to the Minister of Justice and Public
Administration (2013 - 2014) ´World Bank Consultant on Administrative Courts System within the
Ministry of Justice (2014) ´Member of the working parties in charge of drafting the General
Administrative Procedure Act, PAR Strategy, Administrative Disputes Act

´






Czech Republic & Serbia



Great Moravia & Lands of the Bohemian Crown



Saints Cyril and Methodius



Tomáš Masaryk



Petite Entente cordiale



Czech Language in Serbia



Administrative Legal Tradition
´
´
´Austrian Allgemeines Verwaltungsverfahrensgesetz 1925

Crown



European Administrative Judiciary
- The Basics -


Administrative Judiciary
´Building blocks


Key Issues
´Organization and Jurisdiction of AJ
´Type of Lawsuits (Acts, Claims)
´Judicial Control of Discretionary Acts
´Interim Measures
´Oral Hearings
´Decisions (Types, Scope, Execution)
´Legal Recourse
´Relation to Administrative Procedure
´

Administrative Judiciary
´Models


Fromont
´Criterion:
-Controlling Entities
-
-Conseils d’Etat (e.g. France, Italy, Greece)
-Administrative Courts (e.g. Germany, Austria)
-Ordinary Courts (Common Law Countries)
-

Braibant
´Criteria:
´- Special judicial order for the administration
´- Controlling entities
´
1.England, Austria (till 2014)
2.Hungary, China, Serbia (till 2010)
3.Poland, Indonesia, Mexico
4.Germany, Austria (since 2014)
5. France, Italy, Greece, the Netherlands, Belgium Egypt, Liban
´

Lemasurier
´Criterion:
-Types of administrative disputes judged
´
1.Administrative courts resolve all administrative disputes
2.Ordinary courts resolve all administrative disputes
3.Administrative and ordinary courts resolve administrative disputes
4.

Guyomar / Seiller
´Criteria:
-Controlling entities
-Special rules for administrative disputes
-
1.Germany, Austria
2.France, Italy, Belgium, the Netherlands
3.Common Law countries
4.Spain, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Montenegro, Serbia, Slovenia