Data in run: analysis of various information and data in cross-disciplinary task Lukáš Rokos September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia Interdisciplinarity and integration September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia There are many studies that support the use of visualisations in STEM education. Whether it is about how pupils and students work with data and are able to visualize it, use in science fields as well as in engineering, but also the general meaning of diagrams, graphics and other visual representations in STEM disciplines. There are some examples of which approaches work more or less, and how to present data clearly, which is also an important skill for pupils and students to learn. A specific approach that we will focus on in the contribution is the use of concept cartoons in relation to constructivism and argumentation. Most of the knowledge about the use of visuals in science education is summarized in the publication of John G. Gilbert. Importance of data September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia There are many studies that support the use of visualisations in STEM education. Whether it is about how pupils and students work with data and are able to visualize it, use in science fields as well as in engineering, but also the general meaning of diagrams, graphics and other visual representations in STEM disciplines. There are some examples of which approaches work more or less, and how to present data clearly, which is also an important skill for pupils and students to learn. A specific approach that we will focus on in the contribution is the use of concept cartoons in relation to constructivism and argumentation. Most of the knowledge about the use of visuals in science education is summarized in the publication of John G. Gilbert. Integration and cross-curricular tasks §Czech curricular documents Physics, Chemistry, Biology Mathematics Work with laboratory equipment, Use of digital technologies Work with technical materials, Design and models September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia There are many studies that support the use of visualisations in STEM education. Whether it is about how pupils and students work with data and are able to visualize it, use in science fields as well as in engineering, but also the general meaning of diagrams, graphics and other visual representations in STEM disciplines. There are some examples of which approaches work more or less, and how to present data clearly, which is also an important skill for pupils and students to learn. A specific approach that we will focus on in the contribution is the use of concept cartoons in relation to constructivism and argumentation. Most of the knowledge about the use of visuals in science education is summarized in the publication of John G. Gilbert. Integration and cross-curricular tasks September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia There are many studies that support the use of visualisations in STEM education. Whether it is about how pupils and students work with data and are able to visualize it, use in science fields as well as in engineering, but also the general meaning of diagrams, graphics and other visual representations in STEM disciplines. There are some examples of which approaches work more or less, and how to present data clearly, which is also an important skill for pupils and students to learn. A specific approach that we will focus on in the contribution is the use of concept cartoons in relation to constructivism and argumentation. Most of the knowledge about the use of visuals in science education is summarized in the publication of John G. Gilbert. §Case Study §Ethnography Study §Grounded Theory Study §Phenomenological Study §Content Analysis Study Research methods September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia It is possible to identify four areas summarizing the answers to the question "why?". 1. Cognitive aspects •abstraction •simplification •embodiment 2. Pedagogical frame •motivation •coummunication and collaboration •cultural activity 3. Didactic reasons •observation •representation •reasoning 4. Scientific practices •knowledge development •modeling •problem solving and creativity We will return to the selected aspects, but we will emphasize the area of ​​"scientific practices" due to the close connection with STEM education. Task introduction Every runner evaluates his or her results from time to time. A pervasive desire for improvement leads him or her to challenges that not only test physical limits, but also the ability to understand every step, every heartbeat, and every result in training or a race. This inquiry task consists of tracking the results of three different marathons. This challenge isn't just about running; it's about analyzing, understanding and discovering the deeper meaning of the conditions and other factors that can affect every step of the race. You have three races in front of you, three unique results – and your task is to find the factors that may have affected this runner's overall result. You are now at the starting line of this inquiry challenge, where you will find that all the data brings important information. And if they are properly visualized, they will help you better understand the various factors that influence the overall results. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §How long is exactly a marathon run? Find out why it is this distance. § § Marathon §Find some other interesting facts about marathon run. §What information would you need to know about this runner? Obsah obrázku vzor, Grafika, pixel, design Popis byl vytvořen automaticky September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Runner’s Card September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Runner’s Card – equipment September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §The aforementioned runner ran three different marathons and achieved the following results. Marathon results Marathon 1 2:52:27 Marathon 2 4:36:40 Marathon 3 3:15:15 September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Try to guess why the total time of each race is different? What could have influenced them? Marathon results September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Pace I. Marathon 1 Marathon 2 Marathon 3 km time 22 3:59 km time 22 4:57 km time 22 4:30 1 4:02 23 4:00 1 4:28 23 4:57 1 4:33 23 4:42 2 4:05 24 3:59 2 4:24 24 4:53 2 4:26 24 4:47 3 4:04 25 4:04 3 4:29 25 4:47 3 4:21 25 4:42 4 4:02 26 3:58 4 4:26 26 5:04 4 4:21 26 4:32 5 4:07 27 3:59 5 5:09 27 11:21 5 4:20 27 4:30 6 4:02 28 4:01 6 4:28 28 12:22 6 4:22 28 4:31 7 4:07 29 4:03 7 4:33 29 6:29 7 4:26 29 4:41 8 4:07 30 4:00 8 4:15 30 7:50 8 4:32 30 4:38 9 4:02 31 4:06 9 4:34 31 6:24 9 4:22 31 4:41 10 4:09 32 4:03 10 4:37 32 6:01 10 4:32 32 4:33 11 4:10 33 4:06 11 5:10 33 10:04 11 4:35 33 4:26 12 4:05 34 4:05 12 4:57 34 8:37 12 4:33 34 4:44 13 4:01 35 4:08 13 4:44 35 8:38 13 4:28 35 4:50 14 4:07 36 4:03 14 4:37 36 7:53 14 4:24 36 5:07 15 3:59 37 4:08 15 4:44 37 7:10 15 4:29 37 5:17 16 4:01 38 4:02 16 4:46 38 7:49 16 4:30 38 5:17 17 3:59 39 4:05 17 5:13 39 7:52 17 4:28 39 4:58 18 3:58 40 4:10 18 5:07 40 11:38 18 4:27 40 5:07 19 4:02 41 4:20 19 5:07 41 15:46 19 4:35 41 4:50 20 4:02 42 4:19 20 5:40 42 11:45 20 4:36 42 4:47 21 4:02 43 1:16 21 5:00 43 4:06 21 4:27 43 0:59 What caught your eye in the data? September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §The following graph shows the average pace within individual races. Rank them from best to worst. Pace II. Obsah obrázku vzor, Grafika, pixel, design Popis byl vytvořen automaticky September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Which pace will match the specific marathons above? Complete the data in the table below. Pace III. Time Pace Marathon 1 2:52:27 Marathon 2 4:36:40 Marathon 3 3:15:15 4:04 6:32 4:37 September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Go back to your hypotheses about the factors that may have influenced the results. Do you need to know more data to decide which factors are relevant? If yes, write which factors are involved. Routes I. Marathon 1 Marathon 2 Marathon 3 One of the factors that can affect performance is the environment in which the race took place. Look at the route maps and write how they differ. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Routes II. Maraton 1 Maraton 2 Maraton 3 September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Let's go back to our runner's results. The following table provides a detailed description of the routes in relation to the ascent and descent on individual kilometers. Profile I. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia Profile II. Marathon 1 Marathon 2 Marathon 3 As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Match specific race names to their routes. Find the fastest men's and women's times on these routes. Races and records I. C:\Users\lrokos\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Word\pim_logo.jpg September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Match specific race names to their routes. Find the fastest men's and women's times on these routes. Races and records II. C:\Users\lrokos\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\INetCache\Content.Word\pim_logo.jpg Men’s: Tyler McCandless – 2:21:08 (2022, US) Women’s: Brittany Lee Charboneau – 2:52:56 (2017, US) Men’s: Jonathan Wyatt - 2:49:01 (2003, NZ) Women’s: Maude Mathys - 3:12:56 (2017, CH) Men’s: Eliud Kiptanui – 2:05:39 (2010, KEN) Women’s: Lonah Salpeterová – 2:19:46 (2019, ISR) September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations World records §Find out the world records in the men's and women's category. Where were these times performed? Calculate the pace of the world record holders during their performances. How do you proceed with the calculation? Record your calculation and add the results to the table. Time Pace Place Men's Women's Time Pace Place Men's 2:00:35 2:51 Chicago, 2023 Women's Time Pace Place Men's 2:00:35 2:51 Chicago, 2023 Women's 2:11:53 3:07 Berlin, 2023 September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Calories §If you use a sporttester, you know that another value you get for individual exercises is calorie consumption. Can you find any relationship from the data below? Time Pace Ascent Calories Marathon 1 2:52:27 4:04 241 2 576 Marathon 2 4:36:40 6:32 2 024 3 846 Marathon 3 3:15:15 4:37 207 2 892 September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Running in higher altitude I. §Let’s focus on a marathon at a higher altitude and explore the role of altitude in influencing results. Discuss the effect that lower oxygen content has on the physical performance of runners. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §cellular respiration § § Running in higher altitude III. C6H12O6 + 6 O2 → 6 CO2 + 6 H2O + energy September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §Consider the substances and energy in the reaction above and try to draw a simple model (picture, diagram etc.) that explains how a runner can obtain and use energy before and/or during a race. Try to include all the factors you have already discussed in this assignment in the diagram. Use arrows and labels in the model to show the flow of energy and the cycle of matter. § § Running in higher altitude III. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §example of visual model created by students #1 Running in higher altitude IV. CO2 used to oxygen and home environment food (sugars) ball activity carbon dioxide energy + water + breath food CO2 oxygen (ball) ENERGY September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia Example of visual model created by students #1 §more examples of model created by students #2 Running in higher altitude IV. – from ketones mitochondria – less O2, less ATP – from food, glycogen supply C6H12O6 Mg – to release ATP energy from mitochondria + water (sun) LIGHT ENERGY PLAYER FOOD energy (sugars – banana) rapid breathing tiredness less energy less O2 low pressure September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia •more examples of visual models created by students Running in higher altitude IV. food digestion of food – split into simple substances, subsequent absorption glucose during physical activity, energy for muscle work is taken from sugars – glucose during long-term activity, after period of time, fats are burned the more glucose that needs to be burned for energy, the higher the respiratory consumption food player digestion muscle work it is necessary to have a supply of energy from which it is possible to obtain energy by splitting a chemical substance and use it for muscle work it is necessary to have a sufficient amount of O2 – aerobic work occurs oxygen food water PLAYER energy familiar environment home dry/moist air higher heart rate – sugars, carbohydrates September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia •more examples of visual models created by students Running in higher altitude IV. in the form of urine in the form of sweat rest energy stress low oxygen glucose – sugar September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia •more examples of visual models created by students Running in higher altitude IV. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Conclusions §You are on the finish line of this inquiry activity. Write the main conclusions you reached. Focus mainly on which data helped you identify some of the factors affecting the runner's performance. What other factors have you discovered? § September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Conclusions §Let's return to the beginning… September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations §How would you use and analyse the data? Conclusions I. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Conclusions II. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Conclusions III. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Conclusions IV. September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia As already mentioned above, look at visualizations and their importance in developing scientific practices within pupils and students learning. •scientific practises related to the use of visual information (Evagorou et al. 2015) •asking questions and defining problems •analysing and interpreting data •experimenting •modelling •students can build their own models, and the discussion of the models helps to better understand STEM topics (Hepworth & Canon, 2018) •similar to activities we want to do with students at classes when we include some visualisations and/or ask them to create their own visualisations Thank you for your attention! Lukáš Rokos September 9th, 2024 Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia