EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA Author(s): BRET WALLACH Source: Geographical Review , January 2013, Vol. 103, No. 1 (January 2013), pp. 1-19 Published by: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/43915958 JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at https://about.jstor.org/terms Taylor & Francis, Ltd. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Geographical Review This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms The Geographical Review volume 103 January 2013 number 1 EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIAf BRET WALLACH abstract. In this article I draw attention to the galaxy of European buildings built over the last five centuries in Asia. I show how quickly and accurately European styles of the day were adopted in Asia, whether that style was Renaissance, Neoclassical, Gothic, Idiosyncratic Revivalist, or Modern. I argue that recent attention in Asia to architectural and urban preservation is itself of European origin. Although I suggest in conclusion that this architectural galaxy is part of an overwhelmingly one-sided process of globalization, my primary focus remains on the buildings themselves as the residue of one culture diffusing across distant domains. Keywords: Asia. t colonial architecture , cultural diffusion European architectural styles, globalization. ^Zn the spring of 1980, shortly after arriving in India for the first time, I went to a lecture in Hyderabad by Mildred Archer, at that time a fine-arts curator at the India Office Library. She mentioned in passing that Hyderabad's former British Residency was one of the most noteworthy examples of Georgian architecture in India. I had never heard of the building, which then, as now, was hidden within the secure perimeter of a women's college, but I arranged to take a look at it. Figure 1 shows the building as I first saw it. I was impressed, as the builders presumably would have wanted. We know that at least one early Resident wanted the building to impress visitors because in 1811 the high and mighty twenty-seven-year-old Henry Russell, newly appointed as Resident, wrote that Indians could "judge of power and authority by no other standard than the external marks of it" (quoted in Davies 1985, 96). What struck me most, however, was the building's sense of insecurity and sentimental mortality. The insecurity came from a corner of the building where a veranda was protected by massive iron bars, installed perhaps after the building came under attack in 1857. Mortality came from behind the building, where a small cemetery was filled with disintegrating British tombstones. India has so many. Sentimentality came from a tiny memorial set into the front of the building. It bore the name of the daughter of the last Resident, the date 1947, and the words: "My beloved Fifi, whose tail still wags in my heart." t Additional information on all of the buildings discussed in this article is available at my Web site, [www .greatmirror.com] . Dr. Wallach is a professor of geography at the University of Oklahoma, Norman, Oklahoma 73019; [bwallach@ou.edu]. The Geographical Review 103 (1): 1-19, January 2013 Copyright © 2013 by the American Geographical Society of New York This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 2 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Fig. i- The Residency, Hyderabad, I What I did not appreciate at galaxy of colonial structures. It of it. Gradually, and without more. A few months after visi side-Calcutta's Government Ho Residency though built on a Wellington's older brother, Ca the home-away-from-home fo after 1857, India's viceroys. By governor of West Bengal. Raj Bhavan, as it was now call So did the Residency. Both bu columns both had pediments Unlike the Residency, Governm central block. Those arms, like Kedleston, a Derbyshire mansio Arriving as viceroy in 1899, in around the building even in th would have been unfamiliar and there were some other modifications. Meanwhile, a Hyderabad nobleman had built a hilltop palace a few miles from the Residency. Falaknuma, "the mirror of the sky," adopted the Kedleston plan of block and arms, although its pediment was- and is- crowned by a star and eresThis content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 3 cent. The palace soon became the property of t by 1980 that state no longer existed, and the high a wall and had a good look at the building, scared me away from the open doors. Curzo visited Falaknuma. I wonder now, when Falak his arrival in 1902 he was again reminded of K Neoclassical Asia One of the fundamental characteristics of this galaxy is that it mirro tural tastes of Europe both promptly and with great fidelity. The Bom of 1833 (Figure 2), which was built to house as well the Asiatic So museum, has been judged by one authority as wthe finest neo-cla India" (Davies 1989, 445). Another admires its "exceptional Neo-C and considers it "hardly inferior to many of the works of the master Classicism" (Tadgell 1990, 283; italics in the original). Surely this i building is tiny compared with Claude Perrault's facade on the Lo contender might be Bangalore's huge Karnataka High Court, ori Offices Building.) Granted, the fluted columns of the Bombay To from Britain as ballast, were considered so overwhelming that th the otherwise unknown Thomas Cowper of the Bombay Enginee Instead of pairing the columns, as they are paired on the Louvre, in a simple line. The leftovers were used on the nearby Christ Chu Fig. 2- Town Hall, Mumbai, India, 1833. (Photograph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 4 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Greek-temple look-alikes were soon s employed the form strictly, even grimly, French adopted it for the Hue National S and General Vo Nguyen Giap. So did the Philippines. Fresh from three years at th office of John Galen Howard, William E. been hired at the suggestion of Daniel Bu of public buildings closely modeled on t misses them as "grandiose," although he smaller projects (Hines 1973). And let u classical buildings facing the Shanghai B dan Street, is not far behind. Gothic Asia Devoted as they were to classical forms, the patrons of nineteenth-cent pean architecture were equally wed to Gothic architecture, and here ag served as a mirror. Mumbai in particular remains not only India's but t Gothic museum. William Wurster and Catherine Bauer sensed this in t when they called the city "the most thoroughly Victorian metropolis ext 38). A later author calls Mumbai's collection of Gothic buildings "unriva world" (London 2002, 37). Still another, comparing Bombay with postw don, calls Bombay "India's present and Britain's past" (Tindall 1982, 210 Fresh from designing the jewel box of the Albert Memorial and the i of the Midland Grand Hotel at St. Paneras Station, George Gilbert Scot Bombay University's library and iconic clock tower (Figure 4). Philip D sidered it "one of Scott's finest and least-known works" (1985, 164), but S no mention of it in his autobiography, Personal and Professional Recollection 1977)- Possibly he completed the manuscript before completing the tow but it could also be that he did not consider a project in India worth r Certainly Scott never visited India, which was far less important to the England than it was to the English on the spot. Again the style spread. Figure 5 shows the High Court in Cuttack, a ignored in the literature but significant, I think, because it is such a dir Calcutta's much-better-known High Court. That building itself is a ne the Cloth Hall of Ypres, although both in Cuttack and Kolkata the cen was reduced for fear that the ground was too soft to support the wei massive original. All of the buildings I have mentioned to this point were secular, but t style was almost inevitably chosen for the cathedrals that in the 1870s alone were built in Lahore, Singapore, Saigon, and Canton. Far less churches were built in many smaller places, and many of those churches very substantial. Figure 6, for example, shows the Coles Centennial Telu Church, which has a tower fit for Rapunzel yet stands in a town, Kurnoo This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 5 Fig. 3 {above)- Hall of Justice, Batavia (Jakarta), Indonesia, 1870. (Photograph by the author) Fig. 4 (right)- Raj abai Tower, University of Bombay Library, Mumbai, India, 1878. (Photograph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 6 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Fig. 5 (above)- High Co ca. 1916. (Photograph by Fig. 6 (left)- Coles C Baptist Church, Kurnoo graph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 7 Fig. 7 (above)- Our Lady of Divine Providence Church, Goa, India, 1661. (Photograph by the author) Fig. 8 (right)- St. Paul's Church, Diu, India, seventeenth century. (Photograph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 8 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW fewer than 30,000 residents at the time because an American missionary, recrui spent forty years in Kurnool. While ther a New York City physician whose own 1950, 99). Coles gave $20,000 for the ch Renaissance Roots One might well argue, and I would entirely agree, that this mirrorin Asia was nothing new and that it had been going on since the arriv earlier of the Portuguese. The style of that day was the style of the Ren the Portuguese put it to work. A good example is Our Lady of Divi (Figure 7), completed in Goa in 1661. With its giant-order columns between corner towers, it combines the facade of St. Peter's Basilic built, with Donato Bramante's earlier plan for the church. In cynic occurs to me that the biggest difference between the church in Goa Rome is that visitors to the Goa church do not have to wait in line an a security check. Jesuits, meanwhile, built many churches in Portuguese Asia on a from Rome's Gesù Church, where the preaching space was maximize the nave and eliminating the aisles. Bom Jesu in Goa is a good exam Fig. 9- St. Andrew's Church, Chennai, India, 1821. (Photograph by the author) smaller St. Paul's in Diu, whose interior is shown in Figure 8. And of cours there are the Portuguese fortress which are built like a chain around the Indian Ocean from Mozambique Island on the west to Diu, Goa, and Malacca on the east, with an extension in Macao. Some of the fortress walls survive, along with ornamented gateways faithful to the inspiring form of the Roman triumphal arch. Idiosyncratic Revivalism Asia mirrored later and more origin European styles, too. How many vis tors to Chennai today happen upon Andrew's (Figure 9) and see, as I fail to see, that its facade is a near copy London's St. Martin-in-the-Fields? The London church, which appears from the front to be a Greek temple sprouting a slightly setback steeple, had been devised by James Gibbs and was subseThis content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 9 quently emulated very widely, not least in the Paul's Chapel, the only colonial church surviv St. Andrew's in Bombay (1815), St. John's in M (1816), and farther east, at St. George's on Pena those parishes wore clothing that was as au cou Chafing at the stylistic straitjacket of a worl confined to classical or Gothic forms, the ver 1882, "Old work is real and . . . ours is not re 474; italics in the original). His response was a today as Queen Anne. It has little to do with century before Shaw's birth, but Shaw did m ornamental gables, and white woodwork, he m even if it looked old. The style is perhaps mo University of Cambridge's Newnham College, gland is the Norman Shaw Buildings, originally two near twins was completed in 1890. Strikin ings (Figure 10) is a near copy and was complet building was finished in 1906. Much as Shaw reworked European traditio Queen Anne, so European architects rework famously in the Indo-Saracenic style displayed by Bombay's Municipal Corporation Building. Other examples abound. Among them, the Lahore Museum has the distinction of having been designed by an Indian, Bhai Ram Singh, whose remarkable but little-known rise from a family of carpenters has been traced in a recent monograph (Vandal and Vandal 2006). The style spread eastward, too, prominently to Kuala Lumpur and its public buildings, especially the railway station. Figure 11 shows an unroofed stairway deep within the huge Madras High Court, completed in 1892. Davies calls this building the culmination of the Indo-Saracenic style (1985, 198), but this does not mean that the style has been universally praised. One critic calls it "no more than a superficial applique of Indian motifs on otherwise conventional European buildings" (Evenson Fig. 10- Royal Insurance Buildings, Kolkata, India, 1902. (Photograph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 10 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Fig. ii (left)- Madras H India, 1892. (Photograph Fig. 12 (Mow)- Unive (Vietnam National Unive 1926. (Photograph by th Fig. 13 (facing page > t dung Institute of Techn nesia, 1920. (Photograph Fig. 14 (facing page , West Hall, Bandung In Bandung, Indonesia, 19 author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 11 This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 12 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW 1959> 93)- Another mocks the E a "flagrant late Mughal Revival" grand buildings designed by Edw corners with empty stone paras called them "stupid, useless th broader attack he wrote, "I do n (quoted in Evenson 1959, 93). Perhaps the Indo-Saracenic style ing the outward forms of India's e rable tactic. Ernest Hébrard, best k Thessalonika after a fire in 1917, w ture and Town Planning Service fr he designed for Hanoi's Universit sity; other examples of his work Orient (now the Louis Finot Mu writes that in these buildings Hé a Beaux- Arts plan." She continues Sarraut, the colonial minister at th sions of mutual engagement an political support from the Vietnam 1987, 307-308). A much more sy tect of "Vinterculturalite" who wa gionalism critique " (Yiakoumis 2 An even more striking examp enous style can be seen at Bandu of the Bandung Institute of Tec Sumatran longhouse (Figure 13) space unencumbered with colum congruously light parabolic arch was the work of the Java-born-b bining modern engineering wit thirty-six-year-old Pont's last c signed it as an experiment in p forty-three years of his life Po may call this expiation, but I cal Modern Architecture Two or three miles from the Institute of Technology is yet anothe mirror, this time reflecting a style that appeared in Paris in 1925 a monly called Art Deco. The building I have in mind, Villa Isola (Figu part of a college campus but was built as the private house of a n nate. When new, it stood surrounded by rice paddies; hence th House." Despite its massive appearance, it is actually a stone-clad-bu This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 13 building, the work of Wolff Schoemaker, another enjoyed a more extensive practice than did Pont. S remarkable honor. The young Sukarno had studied Technology. Many years later, after he had become Sukarno said: "Professor Wolff Schoemaker was a gr difference between whites and non-whites. For him nesians. No free men or slaves. All that mattered f do" (quoted in van Dullemen 2009, 159). The Villa Isola is the most spectacular and best k Indonesia, but the style was briefly popular else include the lineups of apartment buildings on Mu the west side of the city's Oval Maidan; another col Mau neighborhood. Deco was only one branch of modern architectu of Le Corbusier it had a sibling of greater longevity. I lal Nehru commissioned a capital for the newly cr was Chandigarh (Figure 16), where Nehru anticipa totally fresh and wholly responsive to the aspiratio this great country" (quoted in Evenson 1966, 6). Nehru remained enthusiastic as the city took sh he said, "come to see what is going on in Chandigar the city has not worn well, although it retains en buildings are reportedly being mined by dealers se into the international art market" (Gentleman 2008 while arrived in India, not least Edward Durell Sto 1958. (Geographers may recall that Stone also d Center in Washington, D.C., but also the Nation quarters there.) Since the 1950s, of course, Asia has become not on display of high-rise buildings but its clear superior ings for Europeans in Asia has become European bu a case can be made that modern architecture is no it long ago became, as it claimed to be, internatio Kuala Lumpur or Shanghai the proudest towers ar For people as proud as Asians and as sensitive to c reliance on outsiders is astonishing, as though the architecture of the colonial era and the architectur Scott and the University of Bombay's Rajabai Tow inspect a site before the steel begins rising. Architectural Preservation The belated preservation of a few Singapore shophouses, shown in F us to an ironic sequel. The battles between developers and preserve This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 14 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Fig. 15 (above)- Villa Isola, Bandung, Indonesia, Fig. 16 (below)-' The Secretariat, Chandigarh, I This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 15 Fig. 17- Shophouses, Singapore. (Photograph by today in Asia as anywhere. Even in China, wher fills the glove of government, the tension betw is not only real but almost certain to grow str The irony is that preservation itself is a Euro gins in 1590, when Sixtus V ordered the restor Marcus Aurelius. The idea arrived in Asia abou monuments that fell within the colonial empi restore a Taj Mahal, an Angkor Wat, and a Bor historic districts. Figure 18 shows one case in w the construction of a walkway opened to the pu the Old City of Jerusalem in 1919. The wall was wrapping the city with a greenbelt, parts of w largely forgotten contribution of C. R. Ashbee by the then-governor of the city, Ronald Storr work for the Pro-Jerusalem Society survives phy, Orientations ([1937] 1945). Surprisingly, perhaps, such an interest in the ture was almost unknown in Asia until introd Western universities. An easily overlooked restoring- often rebuilding- the monuments o but a more poignant story comes from China a This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms l6 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW Fig. 18- Walkway on the Old City wall, Christia and Harvard-trained architect and arch nent historian, discouraged Liang's inte cent of ancient architecture has been Liang persisted, his explorations culmi Foguang Temple (Figure 19), one of the Tang Dynasty. Liang wrote that "the i made those the happiest hours of my (quoted in Fairbank 1994, 95). Liang fought to save not just isolated Beijing. Here he ran into insurmoun notion of urban planning amounted to was more traditional than he knew, for of past repairs was to replace the old b building; if this meant the demolition o praise- worthy as virtuous achievement Liang's efforts to save Beijing were cru Revolution. Posthumously, he has been respected to the point of veneration, a yard house in Beijing from recent and architectural historian reminds us that sical archaeology and visiting the Part China" (Dyer 2007). This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 17 Simple Truths For most readers, this story is an obvious sliver of the much grander narra globalization. What else, one might ask, should one expect from a colonial ag its aftermath? Architectural styles would inevitably be introduced, along languages, administrative systems, infrastructure, and commercial enterpr I would only add that this reading has unwelcome implications for anyone wants to understand globalization as hybridization or cross-fertilization. The sion of European architectural styles doesn't offer much support for that b reading. True, a strong current of diffusion from the East to the West once existed. More than 500 years ago Leon Battista Alberti wrote that the architects of ancient Greece "began by examining the works of the Assyrians and the Egyptians" ([1450] 1988, 157-158). Later historians have agreed. The Mycenaean palaces at the start of the architectural history of Greece, they write, were "inspired by the great columnar halls of Egyptian temples" and "profoundly influenced by oriental architecture" (Dinsmoor 1975, 124; Lawrence 1996, 3). Still, the last 500 years is a long time for the ball to have been in the European coürí. It is also true that one can find recent examples of Asian-styled buildings in Europe, most familiarly perhaps with the pagoda at Kew Gardens and the IndianFig. 19- Foguang Temple, Shanxi Province, China (Photograph by the author) This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms l8 THE GEOGRAPHICAL REVIEW inspired Royal Pavilion at Brighton. Still, the battering ram of European styles in A saying, "I think we have to go in whateve If we are not connected to this modern w fishing village we once were." What does t nos," Lee has said, "but the world has chan resort like the ones in Las Vegas- Las Veg and Arnold 2007). A casino opened in 2010 revenues jumped 50 percent. For myself, I prefer to focus less on the cu on the architectural galaxy itself. The buil tably only a tiny sample of the hundreds over from Europe's collision with Asia. Zelinsky's 1955 article on place-names in t be possible to produce maps of Asia loaded European architectural style surviving in fatigability to produce such maps, but m increases as the decades go by. Perhaps I am phy addresses the face of the earth, and if galaxy as I once did, then perhaps it is wo even with a very broad brush. References Alberti, L. B. [1450] 1988. On the Art of Building in Ten Books. Translated by J. Rykwert, N. L R. Tavernor. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. Davies, R 1985. Splendours of the Raj: British Architecture in India , 1660 to 1947. London: J York: Viking Press. Dinsmoor, W. B. 1975. The Art of Ancient Greece. New York: Norto Dyer, G. 2007. China Bulldozes Its Urban Heritage. Financial Times , /c7d28d46-iba7-iidc-bc55-ooob5dfio62i.html#axzz2BYamcJYM ] . Evenson, N. 1959. The Indian Metropolis: A View Toward the West. N sity Press. Fairbank, W. 1994. Liang and Lin: Partners in Exploring China's versity of Pennsylvania Press. Gentleman, A. 2008. A City That Sat on Its Treasures, but Di March. fwww.nvtimes.c0m/2008/03/19/w0rld/asia/iQchandigar Hines, T. S. 1973. American Modernism in the Philippines: Th E. Parsons. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 3 Jacobs, A. 2012. In Beijing's Building Frenzy, Even an "Immova York Timesy 3 February, [www.nytimes.c0m/2012/02/05/w0rld house-stirs-outrage.html] . Lawrence, A. W. 1996. Greek Architecture. 5th ed. New Haven, Li S. 2010. Memory without Location. Fabrications 19 (2): 126-1 London, C. W. 2002. Bombay Gothic. Mumbai: India Book Ho Mydans, S., and W. Arnold. 2007. Modern Singapore's Creator 2 September, [www.nytimes.c0m/2007/09/02/w0rld/asia/02si Scott, G. G. [1879] 1977. Personal and Professional Recollections This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms EUROPEAN ARCHITECTURE IN ASIA 19 Stanton, W. A. 1950 . The Awakening of India: Forty Years am Publishing House. Storrs, R. [1937] 1945. Orientations. London: Nicholson & Tadgell, C. 1990. The History of Architecture in India: From Rai. New York: Phaidon. Time. 1958. Lightning at Chandigarh. Time Magazine , 21 April, 70. Tindall, G. 1982. City of Gold: The Biography of Bombay. London: Temple Smith. Van Dullemen, C. P. 2009. Tropical Modernity: Life and Work ofC.P. Wolff Schoemaker. Amsterdam: Sun Publishers. Vandal, P., and S. Vandal. 2006. The Raj , Lahorey and Bhai Ram Singh. Lahore, Pakistan: National College of Arts. Watkin, D. 2000. A History of Western Architecture. New York: Watson-Guptill. Wolwahsen, A. 2002. Imperial Delhi: The British Capital of the Indian Empire. Munich: Prestei. Wright, G. 1987. Tradition in the Service of Modernity: Architecture and Urbanism in French Colonial Policy, 1900-1930. Journal of Modern History 59 (2): 291-316. Wurster, W., and C. Bauer. 1959. Indian Vernacular Architecture: Wai and Cochin. Perspecta 5: 36-48. Yiakoumis, H. 2001. Ernest Hébrard, 1875-1933. Athens: Potamos. Zelinsky, W. 1955. Some Problems in the Distribution of Generic Terms in the Place-Names of the Northeastern United States. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 45 (4): 319-349* This content downloaded from 147.251.101.74 on Wed, 30 Mar 2022 07:48:11 UTC All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms