Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
1 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
By
Francisco Millarch
London, UK
February, 1998
This paper was
originally submitted
as a partial
requirement for my
Master Degree in
Hypermedia
Studies
at the
University of
Westminster
!"
#
# $
$ % &
$ #
' ( ) %
* & &
+ , - . /011
# * &
& 12
# 3 *+( ( 4 5 & &
& #
6 , 3 #
4 7 & & 3 3 7#
4 /" #
4 & & # *
8
& # 4
& & # 9 : &
- 3 5 & 3 #
& & & " # 9
& # * % & *
( 3 5 & & #
; & 3 &
& " & %
#
# (
6 , # 4
& &
# & &
, & , 3 5 &
# 4 3 & , , & &
# * & & & 6
# * #
$ /0<= 3 /<>2 * +
( "
& # - & *+( & ?2
" >2@ % A , "
3 1"#
*+(, & #%# A
& 5 # 4
#%# & *+( &
#
& 3 *+( & & &
# * /<?2 % . *4 B"& 3 *+(
/<?> % % 6 . %%. "
& , 3 . *4 ,
# ) & *+( =2B *+( =2? &
3 ?"# %
*+( 3 5 3 & #
( *+(, #
4 /<?> ,
& & & &
3 # *+( 3 /<0/ &
4 8
# + *+( 5 3
+ ! & 5 , *+( 8 ,
# * &
*+(, & &
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
2 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
# - * ,
0202" + + 8
& ( * 6#
*+(, 8 & +*)% C" &
)( # ; & 3 *+( 8
# 6 & 0
*+(, +*)% # (
& 6, 5 3 & *+(, +*)%
& D 4& # 4 ( * #
4(*"# 4 3 6 - A & 1222 &
( , -)% 02 " ; & <2 " * ,
, +*)% , & & 3 E-#
*+( 8 F ; *+( 3
8%G1 & # * & &
*+( 7; 7 # ( <? /@
)% 3 * 0C@ & , - 6 "
*+( 8 5 &
# + + #
*+( 8 3 A (
& 6 & H /<<0 .6
# -. " &
6 F 6 & 6 %IB>
3 & *+( #
%I<#= ="#
9 F 4 & *+( .
3 & #%#
- H - H"# H /<=<
3 *+( # * *+(
& & &
& =2 & ?2
# * /<01 & 5 7& 7 >"# *+(
5
#
& &
# ( * 3 *+(
+ + 3 # 4
! & . .) ) & , & 7*+(
5 # % & ( 7
# *+(, # * # 4 H
/<<0" ( & *+(
# ; & 3 & & & #
7; & ,F7
/<0? % + & # 4 * #
3 4 , #
* & # ) 1? H /<0? 4 (
4 # 4
& % H ,
4 *+( &# & & # 4
& # H 3 (
# * (
7
! " #! " $
% & '
# (
) " $ #! " " ! *
$ ! ! ! $ # "
* + 7 0"
4 H & & #
* & 4 ( & , # %
+ 4 " & # 7+
+ 7 *+( ( # : & , ,
# 4 4 & A *
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
3 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
A * " J 8
4 84 " ( 5 -)%
B#2 *+( 3 # 4 & 3 ; & & ,
3 /<<2 & ( ; & <C
( )% /<00#
% & ( <?#/@ 3
= > 4 , % 4 5
3 *+( 8 3 # H 4 & &
( A * J &
& ! ! F )
H , & ( & & *+( 8
3 # ' & &
( &
8 # 4 & & &
& ( # 4 & * (
& 3 4 & "
( & #
* % H )% 3 & & & ( )%
8 # & &
#
& & & & F %
&
" & &
& 4 , 3
3 ( ,
3 #
4 & & &
& , # 4 5 & & &
4 7( 3
, D 3
# * 3 (
3
7 <"#
; *+( 8 3 & : # - +
3 + $ 3 /<>< 4 ** # (
&
3 3 # * & & , 5
73 7 & & 5 #
& 5
# * & & & & &
& ' & &
4 * & % ; D 3# - + 3 ,
: 7& & 3 =2 & 5 & 3 & 7
/<<= $ /2"#
+ 3 , ; ' A *** 10G/2G/<CC" ,
& & 6 ,
& , 3 &
//"#
! "
( H /<>C (*8% & ,
4 0022# + & /<02 (
# *+( +4%* 8
( # A
& - , 8G(#
*+( & - A K , .) , &
& *+( 3 3 & - 3 *+( &
& 3
/1"#
*+( , 3 & & 3 ( & "
A - # + A
3 & &
3 8 4 8 % 8
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
4 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
3 5 & # 8 ,
8G( L-)%# 3 & (
%IC2 222 (% -)%
*+(
#
; *+( ( &
& 8 #
*+( (% -)% &
& *+( 8 & & -)% & 8G( &
(% -)% 6 3 3
8G( & # (
& &
3 3 &
/B"#
+ - & ( , (% -)%
8G( - -)%# * (
(% -)% B#B /<0=
- -)% & # * /<<2 & -)%
& - -)% ( 7 &
-)%7 & 3 - -)%
$ # 9 ( & (% -)% C#2 & - -)%
& " & & & &
3 - -)% /?"# ( 6
(% -)% (
, & (% -)% # 3 8
& ( # . &
( , )% 7 7
#
+ /<02 ( 3 M (% -)%
02@ # ( &
3 # ! / 1 B ; 8 &
#
# $ % & '
* & ; & B#2 ( /<<2 (
& # * 4 /<<1 ( B#/"
7 7
" & & -)%# +
& ; & (
& & 5 3 & &
( , # ( & 3
; & &
&
#
* * . & &
& ( - H # 5
& 3 ( , # ;
6 4 % & /<<=" & ! E
' /<<>" & & &
& 6 ; & & 7 7
/C"# ; & 3# +
& 3 F
( )
% ; & B#2 & ( . B#2 ; & ;
1#2 ; & # !
; 8 ; & &
#
* & ( , 3 &
, 3 # ( 3
7 ; 7 & ,
& 3
# $ & & ( &
5 3 )!." ; & .
& &
/="# 4 & 3 &
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
5 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
# ( , 3 & ; & &
# 4 /<<1 3 7
; & 7 4 & % )%
; & />"#
( 3 3 & ) % # + 3 &
3 & & (
3 # &
) - & ( , )!. # ) &
; &
)!. & ( ,
# 4 ( 3 & & & D (%) &
) ! % % #
+ /<<> ( & 3 0C@ & <2@
3 & # + &
) ( 3 &
* #
*% + , - ,
/<<2 & F : & 3 &
& # *
* & /<<? &
& & # ( & & & & "& &
& 3 , &
5 & 3 &
#
) & & ( F
. / - ) '
( & 4 /<<? H 3 %
A * # ( 4 %4 ( & & &
* # * /? /<<?
& ; ; ; #
* ) /<<? ;B & ( *
(* " & 5
* # 4 &
5 & ;;;
# * &
& & &
& #
&
/2 222 ' 8 & $ 8 A 8
& " # & & ' 8
! %4 ( # *
& A*$ H8.A (8.A#
% & 3& &
' 8 %4 . ' 8- #
' (! # &
B ' 8 /0"#
4 & 5 ;B & &
# 7+ 3
& * 7 /<"#
# * & 5 & 3
% & #
) 1B ( /<<C H %
( # * &
*
& 3 & # &
& H & &
# 4 >C & 3
12"#
0 1 !
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
6 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
* & &
3 * 3 3
# 4 * 3
/<<? /<<C &
& ( #
( , 3 & ( & 3
* # ; & (
& * 1/"#
+ & ( , 6 3 3 * 3
5 & & , & #
' * ( &
&
* # ( , 7 7 "
* 3 #
7+ & & 7
& ( & &
* # 3 & /<<?
3 ( *
. ; & <C # % - H
& ( ; & ,
& & # (
& & #
( & &
7#-!!7 11" & * . # 4 &
& & # (
& ( ; & ;
)% 1B"#
& & &
# * &
& # + & ; ; ;
# * &
3 , 3 & # , & &
3 & & &
& & #
+ ; & .
3 ( * 3 4 E
4 ) ( * 8 . & #
* &
&
* # * (
& ; & &
. 1?"# & ( &
4 & %I/C2 4 * .
& ( ; &
( 1C"#
*
( , 3
H # H & *
& &
3 # 3 H
& & H : (
& H )% "# 4 ; &
&
& 3 " & )% * M
& & & & 3
7 7" #
) H , 7& & 7 (
& HG- & &
H ; & # * & , H
HG- ( , H : ( H:("
7/22@ 7 H:( % # 4
& HG- & ,
; & #
+ & ( H
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
7 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
& # 3 & (
H:( & &
H #
* , ( , H 3
% , H ( *
& H
H & & &
# ; , ; 3 (
& H 7 & ; & 7# +
H ( D H 5
&
#
& 3 /<<?# ) &
% & 3 &
& # 4 '
& 3 6 7 *
#
3 # $ &
& & & & &
& 7 1="# ( 5
( , #
( & & # ( 3
8 1>" . 10"
( * 1<" % & 3 B2"
' B/" ( 8 D B1"#
; ( 3
# * 3
& ,
& 7 7 3
7 7#
4 , + A 3 5
100 & & *
. # * < A 5 # +
A , &
/<0<# ; A & 3
8 ( 4 A !
# ; /0 /12
# / %-IC22 G BB"# ;
& &
& ; 6 3
# + & & 3
, ; & * . #
4 &
# *
3 & & % , + 4 (
3 *+( ( # *
5
# 4
& #
3 %
# * & , )% 3
A & & #
+ # 3 &
# $ + ,
" *+(, & & %
" * % ( " ; ; ;
, - . / ' . , . "
& & &
# 5
3 #
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
8 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
( 3 # 6 &
, & , 6 & #
+ ! ;;; 7 ; &
N& O 5 # 4
3 & # * , 3 ; ;
; * /<</#7 B?"
+ + A 7& + ! ; ; ; /<0< &
,
& 7 BC"# ; ( 73 7
; F
& 7 7
( # ) , &
& - % 3 7- % , % *
A 7# 4 % 3 7 6
7#
01 " 2 3 ! # ! ! $
1 "
$ ! $ " $ ! $ 3
! # & # ! $ ! #!
! 4 0 B="
2
/" *+( *% % G=222 %8G1 % 8);. % "
& A K ( /<<># GG&&&# # # G 3 "
1" 4 M . H M % H % # + + + #
%
GG # # G G 12/G G8 5 G G P # #
3 "
B" . * # 3 "
?" ; H # H# 8 8 8 $ E # $ % E #"# . +
% G+ + 3 /<<2 /01 /0? + D "# 3 "
C" 8 M
& ) % &
+*)% & + * G) % # 3 "
=" ( A H # 6 - - A # Q- ? $ /<<0
GG&&&#D # GD G G &3G2C2?G10/??2# # 3 "
>" 8 . ;## + *+( % * * # (* 8 /<<C# 3
"
0" 9 H %## % H H * & # ! + 3 /<00 B?1# 3
"
<" & # $ ( ; ( ; ' & ( + A
( # 4 G /<<># GG&&&# # G G& G(%; 1; #
3 "
/2" $ # # /<<=# 3
"
//" ( 4# % ;## ( % ' & & &
& 3 # ' + /<<=
1B# 3 "
/1" * - # ! A 4 ( # ( /<<B <B <C# 3 "
/B" ( % 4 & 8 # A ' & ( ( * (
' ( 4 # % E % /<<B /<1 /<B# 3 "
/?" * ?1/# 3 "
/C" & # $ ( ; ( ; ' & ( + A
( # 4 G /<<> // 3 "
/=" 4 M . H M % H % # ( 3 ( #
%
GG # # G G 12/G G8 5 G G P #
Monopolies x Open Standards - Francisco Millarch http://www.millarch.org/francisco/papers/monopolies.htm
9 of 9 27.2.2005 14:34
1# 3 "
/>" ( + # ( ( # GG&&&# # # GR G /B# 1#
3 "
/0" # 8 # ;B
* # 1CG/2G/<<?# GG # # G & G G & 1# 3
"
/<" # 8 # & & 3
* # 1BG/2G/<<?# GG # # G & G G & /# 3 "
12" # 8 # % H ! #
1BG2CG<C# GG # # G & G G & 1C# 3 "
1/" & # $ ( ; ( ; ' & ( + A
( # /=# 3 "
11" - 3 # " & &
3 # 3 "
1B" A H# ; # & )%# & # 1= H /<<0
GG&&&# & # G8 G G2 />= //B 22# , # # # # 3 "
1?" & # $ ( ; ( ; ' & ( + A
( # /># 3 "
1C" 8 3 4 +## H ; ; & # ' /<<>
GG&&&# # G G ?0G # 3 "
1=" ' - # & " # ( 8 /<<>
<<# 3 "
1>" GG # # G 3 "
10" GG&&&# # G 3 "
1<" GG # # G 3 "
B2" GG&&&# & 3# G 3 "
B/" GG&&&# # G 3 "
B1" GG D # # G 3 "
BB" & # $ ( ; ( ; ' & ( + A
( # 1C# 3 "
B?" ' - # & " # CB# 3 "
BC" A + # 4 # 8 + 3 /<<= >C# 3 "
B=" % 3 - # - % % * A # ' . /<<> CB# 3
"