AN INTRODUCTION TO COGNITIVE POETICS Lecture 1: COGNITIVE POETICS BASICS (September 24-25, 2015) Presented by Svitlana Shurma (Kyiv, Ukraine) Email: lanashurma@gmail.com Outline •Types and kinds of poetics •Basic principles of CP •Basic notions of CP • • •What is Poetics? • Origin •Greek poietikos - pertaining to poetry; lit. creative, productive •Who introduced the term ‘poetics’? Principles of Aristotle’s Poetics The principles of Poetics as it exists today were laid as long ago as 335 BC by a famous Greek philosopher Aristotle. The philosophical treatise Poetics marked the shift from approaching poetry as social and religious means of public influence to poetry as a form of art. Principles of Aristotle’s Poetics •Mimesis (imitation) by means of language (man has an instinct to imitate things) •Universal vs individual •Metaphor and knowledge •Human as encoder of information •Perception comes prior to mental representation • Modern Poetics? •Major issues: •Objective world in literature •Creativity and its nature •Everyday speech vs the language of literary works • •See Vorobyova O.P. Cognitive Poetics: gains and new vistas: in Ukrainian. Accessed at http://uaclip.at.ua/Kognitivna_poetikakharkiv2004pdf.pdf Micro- and macropoetics •Macropoetics •a branch of science bordering linguistics and literary studies which approaches literature as a system, and deals with the notions of “genre”, “composition”, etc. •Micropoetics •focuses on the peculiar elements of artistic speech, and the expressive meaning behind the author’s choice of words, grammatical structures, literary forms, artistic details, images etc. Micro- and macropoetics Micropoetics Macropoetics Rhetocal poetics Linguopoetics Mythopoetics Literary poetics Semantic poetics Semiotic poetics Structural poetics Historical poetics Organic poetics Rhetorical poetics, or the study of language means which become the "building blocks" of tropes, stylistic devices and the whole text on a wider scale from the perspective of rhetoric strategies and tactics. Semiotic poetics mainly associated with the names of Roland Barthes, Algirdas Greimas, Umberto Eco. It regards language as a generative system which creates semiotic sequences or texts as well as other signs in the process of communication and cognition Structural poetics, sometimes mixed with semiotic poetics, was popular in 1960-1970s, and had its centers in Paris, France, Moscow, Russia, and Tartu, Estonia. The representatives include Claude Levi-Strauss, Roland Barthes, Yuri Lotman, Vladimir Toporov, Viacheslav Ivanov, Jan Mukarovsky and others. Structural poetics proclaimed the systematicity of a literary text as well as any other semiotic object. This meant that the text was viewed as a whole, which was greater than its hierarchically structured compositional elements. They introduced statistics, information theory, mathematical analysis into the studies of literature. Historical poetics, introduced by Alexander Veselovsky, and further developed by Mykhail Bakhtin and Vjacheslav Propp. This is the study of literary theory in diachrony, or from the historical perspective. It mainly focuses on the development of literary genres, styles and texts in the history of literature. Mythopoetics, or poetics of myth. It is viewed as a part of general poetics, which focuses on myth (its motif, element, image, plot) projection onto the text of a specific writer. Generative poetics is viewed as a part of structural poetics and was developed in the USSR in 1960s under the influence of generative linguistics. The founders of generative poetics were Yuri Shcheglov and Alexander Zholkovsky, who now both live in the USA. Yet, the ideas became quite popular with Teun Van Dijk, Richard Ohmann, Samuel Levin and others. The main focus was that of modeling the process of text generation. The text was regarded as a sum total of some abstract theme and expressive means that were used to transform the theme into a real text. Organic poetics. The term emerged from the notion of "organicism" which was used to describe the "conditions of poetic unity and the nature of form, as well as … the inextricability of form from meaning" (The Princeton, p. 981). The idea dates back to Plato and Aristotle and was further elaborated by the 18 century German philosophers and poets such as Goethe, Kant, Schiller. In the 20 century the idea of organic poetics was discussed in the works of representatives of Russian Formalism, New Criticism and the Chicago School. Organic poetics focuses on establishing the connection between the being and the text. The word is viewed not a separate building block, but in its unity with thingness which is encoded in it. Semantic poetics. The term dates back to the article by Vladimir Toporov, Yuriy Levin, Dmitiy Segal, Tatiana Tsivjan, Roman Timenchik. They speak about two Silver Age poets Anna Akhmatova and Osip Mandelshtam, focusing their attention on the semantic indefiniteness of poetry and two-fold nature of it. They also focused on the interplay of conscious and subconscious in poetry. Basic Principles of CP •Where is the place of Cognitive Poetics? • Basic Principles of CP •Reuven Tsur, 1983 • Basic Principles of CP •Cognitive poetics, as I conceive of it, offers cognitive theories that systematically account for the relationship between the structure of literary texts and their perceived effects • •(‘Aspects of Cognitive Poetics’ in Cognitive Stylistics: Language and Cognition in Text Analysis, 2002, p. 279) • • Basic Principles of CP •R. Tsur •Emotional qualities of poetry •Poetic texts convey meanings and emotions perceived by the reader •Words are tags used to identify mental processes •Poetry exploits, for aesthetic purposes, cognitive processes that were initially involved for non-aesthetic purposes • Basic Principles of CP •Margaret Freeman •“cognitive poetics is Janus-faced: looking both toward the text and toward the mind” • •(Article “The Fall of the Wall Between Literary Studies and Linguistics: Cognitive Poetics”) • Basic Principles of CP •Reader’s perspective •Prototypical reading •Conceptual space of imagery •Emotivity •Categorization •Aesthetic effects •Defamiliarization •Discursive attitudes and interpretation •Text processing •Context and reading Basic principles of CP •Text perspective •Embodied understanding •Blurring the borderline between common and literary mind •From analogous projection to parabolic projection •Cognitive constraints or metaphoric entailments •Literary texture and literariness •Rhetoric patterns and grammatical representation of conceptual structures •Conceptual spheres and conceptual picture of the world • Basic notions of CP •Reading •Figures and grounds •Cognitive deixis •Text worlds •Iconicity Basic Notions of CP •Reading •P. Stockwell: “Cognitive poetics is all about reading” (p. 1) •Reading as the object of research and tool •Reading as cognitive solution •Reading = text-processing of aesthetic and polyvalent nature •Reading occurs in context • • • Miall “A Feeling for Foregrounding: Why conventionalism isn’t the whole story”: An interpretation can never be more than a distant, possibly distorted echo of the reading experience. The action at stake in reading is not usually direct but potential, encoded in feeling: feeling situates readers in relation to complex modes of experience, memory, and social understanding; as such, literature intervenes on readers' modes of feeling and may challenge them or modify them in significant ways. Such challenges lead primarily to action, not thought: they embody alternative ways of construing the self and its position and effect in the world. Basic notions of CP Oleg Shupliak. A portrait of Taras Shevchenko Basic notions of CP •Figure and ground •Foregrounding •Czech theorist Jan Mukarovský •It refers to the range of stylistic effects that occur in literature, whether at the phonetic level (e.g., alliteration, rhyme), the grammatical level (e.g., inversion, ellipsis), or the semantic level (e.g., metaphor, irony) Mialll: Striking stylistic features. Reading tends to slow down, a sense of ‘strikingness’, greater degree of ‘uncertainty’, heightened feeling. Three-phase model of response to foregrounded moments: 1. Defamiliarization; 2. Search for context; 3. Recontextualization. Basic Notions of CP •Figure and ground •Defamiliarization •1917 Viktor Shklovsky’s essay 'Art as Technique’ •the technique of writing through which objects are made 'unfamiliar’ •Forces readers to experience the ordinary in new ways through the use of artistic language •The dominant •Gestalt • Miall: Defamiliarization is response to foregrounding Basic Notions of CP •Cognitive deixis •Person (perceptual) deixis •Spatial deixis •Temporal deixis •Psychological (relational) deixis •Textual deixis •Compositional deixis • • • Basic Notions of CP •Deictic center •Deictic projection •Deictic shift • Basic Notions of CP •Text (discourse) worlds •the sets of scenarios and type of reality that the text is about (E. Semino “Text Worlds” in Cognitive Poetics: Goals, Gains and Gaps, 2009, p. 33) •Possible worlds of logic • • • • • • • • Basic Notions of CP •Possible world of fiction and literature •Dynamic and “furnished” •“Parasitical” and incomplete •Principle of minimal departure •Intertextuality •Flexible and superficial •Believable and plausible • Basic notions of CP •Iconicity •Peirce’s signs: icons, indices and symbols •Icons share a direct relation between the sign and what the sign represents • • Basic Notions of CP •Iconicity is motivation between form and meaning •(According to M. Freeman): •Ontology •Metaphor •Fusion •Feeling • Basic notions of CP •Freeman: •“Poetic iconicity creates sensory-emotional perceptions in language that enable us to encounter them as phenomenally real. In this way, poetic iconicity bridges the “gap” between mind and world, not through conceptual reasoning or scientific methodology by which we attempt to know the world, but through aesthetic experience of the world…” •