THE RESULTS SECTIONS OF RESEARCH ARTICLES THE RESULTS SECTION IN A RESEARCH ARTICLE What is the difference between data and results? DATA VS. RESULTS  Often used interchangeably despite being different  Data: consist of facts and numbers presented in tables and figures  Data can be manipulated to obtain a result  Results: statements that summarize or explain what the data show  Results give readers a sense whether one value is higher/lower than another or some data differ from other data in significant ways  A result is supported by data DATA VS. RESULTS Results statements: After 80 visits, bees visited iridescent disks more frequently than after their immediate introduction to the arena [first 10 visits = 4.7; last visit = 8.1] (Fig. 4b) The surface morphology at 65ºC (fig. 5) was smoother than that at 35ºC and 55ºC (fig. 6). What language is typically used in the Results sections of research articles? LANGUAGE OF RESULTS SECTIONS Two important language characteristics of the Results sections: 1. The use of location statements 2. Comparative language Can you give some examples of each? LOCATION STATEMENTS Five patterns: Pattern A The high rates are shown in Table 3. Pattern B Table 3 shows the high rates. Pattern C The rates were high (see Table 3) / (Table 3) / (shown in Table 3). Pattern D The rates were high, as shown in Table 3. As shown in Table 3, the rates were high. Pattern E (other, not A-D) The results, given in Table 3, show the high rates. Figure 3 is a photograph of the bridge. COMPARATIVE LANGUAGE  Classic comparison: The median wage of a college graduate is now higher than the median wage of a high school graduate.  Avoiding repetition (the use of “that”): The median wage of a college graduate is now higher than that of a high school graduate.  Adding complexity (percentages, X times): The median wage of a college graduate is now more than 70 % higher than that of a high school graduate.  Adding hedging: The median wage of a college graduate is now slightly more than 70 % higher than that of a high school graduate. What moves should a Results section of a research article include? THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 1. REVISITING THE RESEARCH AIM/EXISTING RESEARCH 2. GENERAL OVERVIEW OF RESULTS 3. INVITATION TO VIEW RESULTS 4. SPECIFIC/KEY RESUTLS IN DETAIL 5. COMPARISONS WITH RESULTS IN OTHER RESEARCH 6. PROBLEMS WITH RESULTS 7. POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS OF RESULTS 1. REVISITING THE RESEARCH AIM/EXISTING RESEARCH - To what extent your study fulfills the aims you set out in the Introduction - You might want to go back to the Intro and redefine the original aims in relation to the results you obtained The main purpose of this work was to… In this work, we sought to establish a methodology for… In earlier studies attempts were made to establish … THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 2. GENERAL OVERVIEW OF RESULTS - Here, you summarize your methodology (highlight the important aspects of the materials, equipment or methodology you used to obtain your results) It is apparent that in all/most/the majority of cases… In this section, we compare/evaluate/present… The results are divided into two parts as follows:… THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 3. INVITATION TO VIEW RESULTS - You can’t always write Figure 1 shows… Figures and tables don’t always show things; sometimes they present things or summarize things. Figure 1 contains corresponds to demonstrates displays illustrates lists THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 4. SPECIFIC/KEY RESULTS IN DETAILS - The language used to describe specific results includes both language which provides objective description of the results (e.g., lower) and subjective, evaluative language or hedging (e.g., significantly lower, slightly lower) Objective: it was found, remains constant, did not occur … Hedging: in the majority of cases it was found, tends to remain constant, did not occur in general … THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 5. COMPARISONS WITH RESULTS IN OTHER RESEARCH - Make sure the location of the reference citation or number is accurate - Remember that the right place for a reference is not always at the end of the sentence. As reported by Hyland (2010), … This is consistent with results obtained in [1]. The results are qualitatively similar to those of earlier simulation studies. THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 6. PROBLEMS WITH RESULTS - Remember that research is not made invalid by inappropriate results if they are presented in a conventional, professional way. Minimize the problem/focus on good results: Although this was not obtained experimentally, it can be assumed to exist. Suggest reasons for the problem: …. was hard to control and is beyond the scope of this study. Offer a solution: … in future, it is advised that/case should be taken... THE STRUCTURE OF RESULTS SECTION 7. POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS OF RESULTS - Provide a general explanation or interpretation of what your results might mean. This signals the move towards the Discussion/Conclusion. Use hedging expressions. This suggests/indicates/implies that… It seems therefore that… It could be inferred therefore that these may have … Compare the two sentences:  We found that sunbathing is related to the onset of cancer. (NO HEDGING)  It is thought that excessive sunbathing may sometimes be considered as contributing to the onset of certain types of cancer. (EXTREMELY HEDGED STATEMENT) HEDGING